Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 November 2006

Skype, video from home, IM, search ‘ 3 breaks all the cellular rules

The announcement of Skype, of all things, on a mobile handset from cellular operator 3, is likely to send reverberations around the cellular community that will change it forever.

Sure we have already heard, back in February, that Skype was being trialed by 3 in Sweden, and various critics pointed out that this was far from a good idea. The logic was that first it had not been adapted to a handset, it was actually running over the cellular network connecting PCs running Skype using cellular data cards. The second point was that it was disastrously inefficient, using up half a megabit per hour of data just to have the Skype client open

Yes, but that was before Niklas Zennstr’m and his Skype team re-wrote the Skype client for the mobile, and not just for a Windows mobile, but for Symbian devices. 3 announced the Nokia N73 and the Sony Ericsson W950i, both Symbian phones, as the devices that will bring its new X-Series class of services to market come the end of this year.

X-Series will be launched by 3 in the UK in December and in its other group territories in early 2007 including, Australia, Denmark, Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy, Israel, Austria and Sweden.

The 3 approach is certainly radical. Instead of attempting to maintain the walled garden, and the process by which cellular operators bill for each bit delivered over its network, as well as charging for content services, 3 is saying it will offer ‘Flat rate internet, with all the services that entails.’

That may not be too different to what T-Mobile has been preaching, but the emphasis on web based partners and a loud launch means that it cannot backtrack and pull away from the strategy easily.

The big names that have been signed for the deal, led by Skype and its eBay parent, include Microsoft and Yahoo for instant messaging, Sling Media and Orb Networks for place shifting video content, and Google for search and Google’s YouTube for UGC. They all make it look like the cellular operator has sold out and not only invited the internet onto the phone, but also abdicated voice responsibilities to Skype. It now appears that it will just lay down a data pipe and become a bit carrier, an idea that other cellular operators loathe.

Other cellular operators have sworn not to allow outside Instant Messaging services into their demesne, with something like 62 operators signing up since 3GSM in February to take an instant messenger designed by the cellular community. That breakaway was pretty much created by the fear of Skype or VoIP over an instant messaging service. Cellcos needed to link the world of SMS messaging to the world of IM, but not with the penalty that they open up a free-for-all IP path on and off the handset.

The question now is just what will happen. If 3’s network stands up and isn’t brought down by impossible-to-sustain data rates, then the next question is whether or not 3’s revenues will stand up. To a certain extent all of that is under 3’s control. It has only got 3G networks, it is partway through upgrading to HSDPA, which presumably will be timed to coincide with the uptake of data services on its network.

If voice skips to Skype from W-CDMA, then this will definitely take up more bandwidth than the hyper efficient W-CDMA, but by manipulating the monthly bill for open flat rate broadband access, and by setting monthly data limits for what it sees as ‘unreasonable’ data usage, it should cope. Of course Skype, whatever people say about it, is nothing like as clear as switched mobile voice, and 3 is being careful to say that calls to free Skype users and to other mobiles with Skype on are free, but it hasn’t said whether or not Skye-out ‘the process whereby Skype users can call normal phones and mobile customers ‘ is available or not, but we think it is likely.

Gradually 3 then adheres more to a DSL business model. Now that cannot be good for margins, but for an ambitious cellco that sees the taking down of the walled garden as inevitable, it can use that inevitability to take market share. Better to have a bigger share of a lower margin market than to be stuck on a low share of a market that will experience gradually declining margins.

In the end 3’s next move is to work deals with content businesses, the way it has in 3 Italia for its DVB-H mobile TV service. It has said in the past that it is intent on becoming a content company, and it is the only cellular operator in Europe (in Italy) that has gone and bought DVB-H spectrum and decided to operate its own mobile TV service. Most of the others involves cellular operators but are not being paid for by them.

The X-Series launch also coincided with the launch of mobile MyCasting services from Orb Networks. Orb allows your PC to transcode and resend a QVGA sized video image from your home TV service to your mobile phone or a larger one to you PC. It operates a different business model from Sling Media, which sells the device for $250 or its equivalent, which does the repackaging of content and the sending across the network. Orb charges for this as a monthly service at $10 a month, with your PC tidying and resizing TV video data and forwarding it to a remote PC or to your phone. Orb said that the Orb MyCasting service is free although we suspect that it means that the extra work to shape the video for handset viewing is free, and that Orb in general still has a monthly charge.

Placeshifting is a great way to offer TV at the phone but is likely to have a lower standard of video than DVB-H, because the data is traveling over the data network of the cellular operator, 3G, or where they have it, HSDPA, whereas mobile TV travels over a separate piece of spectrum as a broadcast.

But the fact that the cellular operator gets none of the revenue for providing the TV content runs contra intuitive for most cellular players, which are constantly trying to control the services on a handset.

(See also our piece comparing 3’s strategy with Vodafone and others, further inside this issue entitled 3 and Vodafone demonstrate the two sides of mobile internet alliances.