America Movil, the world’s fourth largest Telco, is to divest both fixed and mobile assets in its home Mexican market in an attempt to preempt action from the new and tougher regulator Ifetel.
As we wrote last week the current government is attempting to reverse 20 years of lax regulation that has allowed America Movil to build a position of dominance unmatched in other leading economies, which have already dismantled incumbent Telco monopolies to varying extents. We believe that it is too late for Mexico to unravel America Movil’s hold over its domestic market without doing serious damage to the whole country’s competitive position. In this context the overtures by America Movil’s owner, the world’s second richest man Carlos Slim, can be seen as a clever gambit to minimize the impact of regulatory action by merely selling off the least profitable bits of its home kingdom.
The current government under President Enrique Pe’a Nieto was elected in December 2012 with a perceived mandate to modernize the country’s institutions and infrastructure in line with leading developed countries. As part of that it disbanded the toothless regulator Cofetel, replacing it with Instituto Federal de Telecomunicaciones (Ifetel), which has since moved to curb America Movil’s power. Our story last week covered Ifetel’s steps to prevent America Movil colluding with pay TV operator Dish Mexico and attempting to influence its strategy over pricing and distribution. The two have no significant common shareholders but America Movil has been supplying Dish with billing systems and some equipment, and does have an option to acquire a 51% stake in the operator through its subsidiary Telmex. This option has been waived as part of the pre-emptive concessions announced this week in an attempt to appease the regulator.
It does not require too close inspection to conclude that these measures are a classic gambit to minimize the overall regulatory impact of the new tougher regime. The Dish concessions exemplify this, since it looks like America Movil had no intention of taking up that 51% stake option anyway and is still going to be working with Dish on distributing and supporting its services. Telmex has pointed out to the regulator in the same breath that these support services, including the billing and equipment rental, are available to other carriers, including MSOs and DTH operators.
The key point lies in the definition of market dominance, which is typically defined in terms of overall subscriber numbers. America Movil has pledged to bring its share of both the fixed and mobile Mexican markets down below 50% to meet Ifetel’s definition of non-dominance. Currently it has 70% of mobile subs and controls 80% of landlines, which it originally hoped to maintain while opening them up belatedly to competition via unbundling. But the subscribers it is now offering to divest to an as yet undetermined Telco will be rural ones that generate the smallest profits, often in areas where there is little competition. If Ifetel accepts these concessions it will have only marginal impact over either America Movil’s revenues or competitive position in the country’s converging communications and entertainment markets.
There are precedents elsewhere, notably in the US where Verizon hived off 4.8 million rural access lines to Telco Frontier Communications in 2009.
The Mexican government has been talking up this concession because it is in its interests to settle with America Movil in return for investment in the country’s emerging LTE mobile infrastructure. The government stated therefore that ‘This decision could transform the conditions of effective competition in the telecoms sector with better quality and better prices to end-users’.
This does not really hold water if these concessions are accepted, since there is precious little competition for provision of services to those rural subscribers concerned. The key point lies in the government’s plan to build a nationwide LTE network at an estimated cost of $10 billion. It wants to minimize its own investment and encourage America Movil to put up the money, as well as donating its existing cell towers for the RAN (Radio Access Network) and fiber for the backhaul.
Even if Ifetel does bow to this two way pressure from America Movil and the government to accept America Movil’s concessions, there is the question of whether any Telco will be interested in mopping up these relatively low revenue rural subscribers, which may not offer sufficient economies of scale.
This comes to the pivotal point for America Movil, which is its ability to enter Mexico’s fast growing and increasingly lucrative pay TV market. Telmex, the arm that sells fixed line and broadband services, is currently banned from entering TV under the terms of its original license and now America Movil has to demonstrate to Ifetel over an 18 month period that it is conforming with the new regulations designed to level the overall competitive playing field for converged communications and media that the regulator now covers in their entirety.
Pay TV is not only where the country’s highest ARPUs are but also fastest rates of subscriber growth, which we predict will continue until 2018, even if at a decreasing rate. The total soared by just over 16% during 2013 to reach just short of 15 million by the year end, compared with 12.95 million a year earlier, and pushed on to 15.56 million by the end of Q1 2014, according to Ifetel. We expect the total to pass 20 million early in 2016 and approach 25 million by the end of 2018. This leaves a lot to play for, which is why America Movil is playing a long game at the moment. Ifetel is ironically under pressure not just from America Movil but also the government that created it ostensibly to bolster competition. We await its response to Slim’s overtures.