Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 June 2011

So if the set top can become a plug, will it go away all together

Sigma Designs this week announced what it described as ‘a new class of set top box,’ built around a new SoC chip and a reference design that effectively sees the set top taken off the top of the TV, and placed into the plug in the wall. (See separate story).

Within hours of that going public we had journalists on the phone asking about the future of set tops ‘ would they die out, would they get integrated into the TV set, would they be replaced by games consoles?

Sometimes we are too close to the subject matter, and from a consumer point of view the existence or otherwise of a set top box perhaps doesn’t matter. To a pay TV operator the existence of set top capabilities matters, but then again lately so much more matters than that, such as OTT capability.

If you think about the intelligence of what goes on when a video signal reaches the home, and what might go on in future, and what consumers would like, there is a lot of function to take care of. And it’s not the consumer that decides much about where this processing goes on. If it’s pay TV through a satellite or through cable, traditionally it is the pay TV supplier than decides on where ‘some’ of that processing power is situated, and of course it’s not just processing power, it’s tuning capability for the most part. And of course, as tuning capability becomes more of a digital process this capability too can be shrunk. For instance last week Broadcom launched what it calls Full-Band Capture digital tuners which can tune up and down the entire 1 GHz of cable bandwidth. It can support multiple parallel demodulations in real time and for Broadcom’s this removed as many as 9 separate tuner components from devices.

Off the top of your head think about the roles that can have similar savings. Tuning, running Apps, wiring modulation and demodulation such as Gigabit Ethernet, MoCA, HPNA, G.hn and HomePlug, as well as WiFi signaling, and WiFi routing management. The video codec needs to be decoded, and within a single home resized for different devices. There needs to be storage space for both commercial and non-commercial video, music and images, and there needs to be instant format conversion between devices. The TV set itself needs innovation on the UI, with things like Search exported to the cloud, and so do other video capable devices. Video conferencing standards (or Skype) need to be supported, including real time video encoding. 3D and Full color has to be supported somewhere and on TV sets there is a lot of processing intelligence needed for power saving, for instance controlling LED switching, but also things like the adding of intra frame effects for smoothing of lines. And being ‘green’ in any part of this process ‘ cutting down power for any kind of processing, will also be a core management job. Security is a given and in the modern set top (whatever form it takes) there will be multiple layers of security, conditional access systems that decode and re-encode in DTCP-IP, as well as authentication, device registration and dynamic water marking. Of course getting video EPGs to show both traditional pay TV service and internet held content and DVR content and VoD stored content, and to provide internet or OCAP (tru2way) interactivity at any point along the way also requires processing power.

Real IPTV opens up other jobs, including decoding multiple Picture in Picture streams, handling multicast joins, including precise buffering and I-Frame storage. Fast channel change in IPTV requires communication with central servers or routers, and in cable it requires faster channel change protocols using neighboring QAM channel pre-processing. The list is almost endless because it leads to the automation of the entire home. Going back to Sigma, it has included Z-Wave in its reference spec for a set top, part and parcel of home device control technology.

The truth is that some of these jobs are ‘owned’ by TV manufacturers. Others are currently owned by home gateway specialists, but don’t have to be, and others still by existing set top vendors and their customers at pay TV operators. And each of these is prone to add function from other segment. If Broadcom adds MoCA to a set top chip, does that make MoCA part and parcel of the set top? Or does it remain separate?

Where each of these jobs take place is often a decision made by an ‘encroaching’ manufacturer. A set top chip maker may add MoCA but it will add it to the set top, while a HomePlug chip maker might add set top capability but put it in the plug. A DVD cpu maker might add internet interactivity to the DVD player, and a TV maker may add CableCard decryption and App processing inside the TV.

If the job remains small, as it so often is in cable, the simple tuning to a QAM signal, then the set top can become just a chip, as the job becomes larger – more work transferring between file formats, effort of transcoding, management of security keys, and in IPTV, the process of joining and leaving a Multicast, complete with some memory for buffering, then it is harder to replace them or move them.

If you add to that things like intelligent cabling – whether that be a full LAN such as ethernet, or Gigabit ethernet, or something simpler, but nearly as fast, like MoCA or HPNA, these functions can reside in chips, but they create a better bill of materials (cheaper) if they are ALL on one chip – an SoC. That chip will then be the heart of a set top, or, as in the Sigma announcement, that could be in something which looks like a HomePlug adaptor. As we see more applications and a more intelligent environment we see more powerful SoCs. How far can SoCs go? Will they take in ALL these jobs in one device? Probably that’s not economic, but many of them CAN merge and where it is economic, they will.

There are two clear reasons for one encroaching on another. When one of these jobs is far more sophisticated than a neighboring task, the neighboring task could easily be subsumed into the more sophisticated device. But the success of that depends largely on who pays for that device and who controls the service that it delivers.

The TV set could have everything in it, but consumers would find it a disincentive for pay for all of that function if they don’t plan to use it. Operators only want to pay for technology that differentiates them and will always push a device which is NOT part of the TV set.

The BIG move here is that WiFi functionality needs to extend to the TV and commercial video security needs to extend all around the home, so making your home gateway a license server and putting everything through that and giving it cable or satellite tuner capability, makes more and more sense.

Which is perhaps why companies like Pace have acquired businesses like 2Wire. But this doesn’t always happen at the device level, it also happens at the component level. That makes all of those questions about what will happen to the set top unanswerable, because everything is going to happen to the set top and it’s a matter of who wins in the end in each dimension ‘ component suppliers, equipment suppliers and operators. It is likely the set top will be spread around the home, but then again so will all the other devices we have talked about.

So last week when the CE4200 had a major win at comcast’s Xfinity. One reason for that is because the operator wants to control the running of apps, and a more sophisticated HD User Interface, as well as blend both cable TV and internet video. So it’s the operator’s decision about where the intelligence sits ‘ so it makes for a bigger and better set top.

The CE 4200 has about 3 to 4 times the processing power of prior SoCs, which is why, just before Christmas, Broadcom added the BCM7422, a chip with more than twice the processing horsepower of previous generations of its set top SoCs, and this will also deliver full HD resolution 3DTV.

Sigma last week added a new device to its chip range the SMP 8670 media processor, which can be used to put HomePlug AV into a device, a new, very fast version of HomePlug. Net result is a reference design, where the plug is the set top and the wire coming out of it is not power but a simple HDMI signal.

Other news from last week was that Time Warner Cable is working with Motorola on the DCX3600M, a home gateway which translates up to 6 cable TV signals and a DOCSIS signal and sends any of them around the home, mostly using WiFi. It has lots of new jobs to do, for instance it decrypts and decodes 6 TV streams, and can send them to a DVR or to an iPad over WiFi, but to do this it must re-encrypt on the fly. So it needs all of the extra processing power, but as yet it is unclear what chip drives this, though we would bet on an Intel.

It takes some imagination to come up with new jobs that need doing in the set top, and then it takes time to bring them through standards bodies to market, but there are no end to the processing jobs that people will come up with. Every time we increase the density of the video, say from 720p to 1080p, we increase the processing load by about 100%. So the function of the set top will live on, and probably remain outside the TV, while processors on TVs will likely move further towards TV services – UI, and apps, which run on the TV. But if you want apps to look the same on any TV, the natural home is back in the set top. But in turn much of the set top job could move backwards, towards the home gateway so that you only need one per home.

However not every pay TV operator agrees with this philosophy – for instance satellite DTH suppliers like DirecTV have no reason to work with the home gateway, since they have no way to bring broadband to the home, so it instead takes everything off a satellite signal and sends it around a MoCA connected multi-room DVR – this is a home gateway but just for TV, and not broadband as well. So call it a set top, if you will. Eventually it may communicate through the home gateway, but since it doesn’t control that, it won’t migrate to the same device.

The same applies to Google TV and Apple TV. They only want to usurp the role of bringing internet video to the TV and they rely on broadband already being in the home, and as such, they are strategies that rely on being separate from the TV and also separate from the home gateway, although Google would be happy if someone implemented Google TV in a gateway.

So in short the set top won’t go away just yet. It might shrink and migrate in two key directions, one further away from the TV, another closer to it. The key thing is that companies who currently lead the creation of such devices will change – Motorola has been slipping badly for the past four years, but has a neat new set of products and features and since the next step is to get TVs and phones to work together, Motorola has a head start here being in both. Broadcom is now challenged because TVs and set tops need to run apps, and Intel leads that charge, while Broadcom wants to move WiFi and set tops together into the home gateway.

Gaming consoles have very powerful processors, the PS3 in particular, about 100 times more powerful than an old Intel Pentium – it can manage anything that’s thrown at it, and Sony is retrofitting 3D, but these are mostly the jobs that smart TVs should be able to do, and while some set tops will go away in favor of gaming consoles, it’s not yet the time for gaming consoles to go away in favor of some set tops. For the PS3 or Xbox to replace other set top roles it would need special tuners to work in Cable and satellite TV, but IPTV could use games consoles more or less as they are. This has been possible for some time and Xbox for Mediaroom has been available to operators for years, but we have to remember that the games console is usually about as expensive as a set top and is subsidized by games. If games were not played on the PS3 it would have cost around $850 (at launch). So it only makes sense to use it where there is both gaming and an IPTV set top requirement together. However when it is used for gaming, it usually cannot also be used on another second TV set simultaneously. So games consoles have tended to be used for second IPTV set tops in the home, not for the main sitting room device.

So expect lots of things to say they are set tops over the coming years and for the set top to be predicted as going away ‘ but it is the commercial positions of the respective pay TV leaders that keep it where it is, not the technology.