There are psychological reasons why, until now, none of us, none of the cognoscenti who dreamed that mobile broadcast TV could become a reality in Europe, who have since abandoned coverage of the subject, have been very slow to acknowledge that the dream is back on. It is back on courtesy of an extension to the DVB-T2 standard called DVB-T2 Lite ‘ but we have mostly ignored it this path month or so, because it is hard to get excited by it.
Faultline witnessed the emergence of DVB-H and the hope that surrounded it, with Nokia pioneering it and then subsequently deserting it. The journey of DVB-H is strewn with corporate corpses, or at least companies that have severed their links with DVB-H or perished ‘ with Nokia and Technicolor’s now sold off Thomson Grass Valley company perhaps the best known and smaller outfits like IP encapsulator specialist UDcast, French software house Expway and Irish and US video software specialists S3 and Packet Video and even Qualcomm’s fated MediaFLO, which chased a similar topology.
We had a great time from 2003 when the dream started to come alive until 2010 when DVB-H was well and truly buried, at first believing in it and then slowly criticizing and following the downfall, not just of DVB-H, but of all technologies which required the building of a new, extra network to deliver broadcast mobile TV to handsets and portable devices like Tablets.
The only systems that have actually worked were in the hands of broadcasters and required no new spectrum and no new transmitters, just a single extra cheap digital exciter, some devices and some marketing ‘ delivering mobile TV signals in a slightly new format, within the existing TV signal ‘ which has been ISDB-T in both Japan and Latin America. Korea with its T-DMB technology actually built a new network and has 20 million regular users, but it was a unique network and that and a few remaining DVB-H sites in Italy and places like Finland and Vietnam are still switched on. And of course there is still great promise for ATSC M/H in the US, Canada and Mexico, which like ISDB-T relies on a broadcast signal having a mobile signal buried in it.
Why, we asked back in May 2008, was the DVB-T2 standard being rushed into daylight, abandoning a key part of its brief, to accommodate a mobile TV signal, in order to bring HD signals to isolated DVB-T systems which had sprung up all over Europe and in about 20 other countries around the world ?
So it was with great disillusion that when DVB-T2 enthusiasts told us in July this year that DVB-T2 had a standards extension, that we always knew was possible, added for mobile broadcast TV, we yawned instead of jumping up and down with excitement ‘ this surely would be fumbled by the various operators, no devices with specialist chips would be brought to market and cellular operators would laugh with disdain as they had at DVB-H2, better known as DVB-NGH (next generation handheld), which never even got completed as a standard for lack of interest.
NGH never had a chance, because DVB-H, had never found enough fans and even fewer users. It was a simple and honest mistake and back in 2008 the real reason that DVB-T2 never had a mobile option added to it, was because some misguided national TV broadcasters were still trying to partner with European cellcos and bring DVB-H to fruition. They didn’t want a mobile version of DVB-T2 to get in the way and confuse things. Instead it has just meant losing 3 years.
Faultline wrote a requiem for the DVB-H technology in 2008 in a piece entitled ‘DVB-H hanging on by its fingertips’ and again in 2010 asked, ‘Is DVB-H the one case where Euthanasia is justified’
At that time we counted a live system in Africa, in Kenya, Nigeria, Namibia, and a Government mandated system coming in South Africa, a live service in Vietnam, one in Latvia, as many as four promised in the Philippines which all slowly lost momentum and died, a Doordashan trial running from 2006 for four years in India, and trials which seem to indicate that services would happen in Indonesia, Ireland and in countries as diverse as Libya, Malaysia and Poland. It’s a poor showing with the UK, France, Germany, Spain, Portugal Austria, and most of Scandinavia, Benelux and much of central Europe all glad they never went down the DVB-H route or have tried and pulled out of a move that might have cost someone close to $500 million or more for each country depending on how it was deployed.
But now it all appears to be on again, albeit with no fanfare this time, early in the test phase and with multiple TV to Tablet strategies that cellular operators far prefer, mostly aligned to WiFi last stage delivery, but with LTE networks slowly heading to the point where they are robust enough to deliver a decent streamed experience over cellular for an order of magnitude more customers than 3G video streaming managed ‘ once those LTE networks are built.
The BBC began an internal trial immediately in the UK, just a single transmitter from a single rooftop at the BBC R&D’s South Lab opposite the TV Centre in West London using the new DVB-T2 Lite. It’s a 4 Mbps signal which holds a mobile signal inside it, in bursts.
The DVB-T2 Lite standard had barely been approved, but finally Europe has a standard for broadcasting mobile signals that makes sense. It is in bursts so that it will save about 90% of the battery used for radio, by switching it on and off,
It is built into an existing transmitter network and just needs an extra digital exciter the same as ATSC M/H and ISDB-T One seg, and already there is a trial that emulates the UK’s existing HD DVB-T2 multiplex in the UK with an additional mobile signal.
The BBC has modulator and receiver designs, currently based on Xilinx FPGAs, which can be used to validate the standard and can be licensed to manufacturers interested in developing products for mobile applications. The same approach also works for radio delivery and data, not just video.
The way this works is that the mobile signal is given more power for the fraction of a second it is on, so that it can reach mobile, indoor targets, and the standard is flexible enough for this. This cannot interfere with the HD TV signals because they are out of step ‘ time interleaved if you will. The BBC system uses 32K carriers and about a 1 Mbps signal can be achieved, that’s pretty good video, slotted between the existing HD TV channels and this can be used for video, radio or data on mobile devices. We reckon two or three mobile video channels could be supported by such a system.
There will, of course, eventually be fairly cheap chips designed that can pick up DVB-T2 signals, and these will be able to pick up those modulated in this way too, but they will initially not be low enough power for mobiles. Who exactly is going to put them in a handset or tablet? Increasingly mobile devices are made globally, and although Europe is probably a big enough target that if broadcasters get these signals out there, they will be able to find manufacturers that will include such chips on their devices, and maybe, just maybe, cellular operators who will subsidize such devices into the market.
If it happens, and we emphasize if, it will take a long time. Each broadcaster has to see the merit, each multiplex has to have the capability added and each country in Europe has to decide it’s worth doing. It does mean messing about with the existing DVB’T2 signal slightly. But really these portable signals are less and less likely to catch on. Batteries on handsets are under pressure still, but on tablets, they are now stretching to ten hours constant usage, and have enough oomph to take the DVB-T2 signal directly. Increasingly business models are being put together whereby tablet owners watch TV from WiFi, and just need a WiFi signal. This week Hauppauge Digital has completed an iPad App where the user plugs a tuner into a USB port on their PC and then the PC sends out a WiFi signal a for a tablet to pick up with the TV channels on it. WiFi signals may not be the best way to get TV to a tablet, but if everyone in the WiFi community works hard enough, it may become the de facto method. Of course that doesn’t help when you are on the road and really away from your free home WiFi and have to pay at hotspots or are completely out of reach of WiFi. But to predicate an entire business model on these few occasions may not be enough to introduce widespread DVB-T2 Lite mobile signals.
The technology will be on show at IBC next month and we will go along and have a chat with the team and see if anyone can convince us to get as excited about this technology, as we all once were about DVB-H.