It’s going to be a long time before music fans will pay for copy-protected music CDs, following Sony BMG Music Entertainment’s recent fiasco. And, it’s Sony, not the Sony BMG Music joint venture that Sony has with Bertelsmann or Bertelsmann itself that’s getting the bad press. Articles critical of Sony management for letting the catastrophe occur mention Sony chairman and CEO Howard Stringer but not Bertelsmann chairman and CEO Gunter Thielen.
It’s not the Sony Music company. It’s the Sony BMG Music Entertainment company, but consumers and press alike seem to be attributing the nightmare entirely to Sony, which only owns 50% of the outfit. Headlines like “Sony Sued over Controversial CDs” don’t communicate that the German-based Bertelsmann is equally responsible for the copy-protection fiasco.
The latest attacks come from the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EEF), a California-based consumer group, and the Texas attorney general, which last Monday sued Sony BMG Music Entertainment. The claim is that the software Sony BMG Music uses to copy-protect some of its CDs is actually spying on consumers. The Texas suit calls it “illegal spyware.”
The foul-up promises to be a lawyer’s dream. At least six other class actions have also been filed.
The Texas lawsuit seeks damages of up to $100,000 for each violation. “Sony has engaged in a technological version of cloak and dagger deceit against consumers by hiding secret files on their computers,” said Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott. “Consumers who purchased a Sony CD thought they were buying music. Instead, they received spyware that can damage a computer, subject it to viruses and expose the consumer to possible identity crime.” Ouch!
Sony BMG Music used XCP (Extended Copy Protection) software, developed by the UK firm First 4 Internet, on around 52 music CDs, of which about two million copies have been sold in the States. XCP installs software on the user’s PC if and when the CD is played on a PC. The installed software, unfortunately for users and for Sony BMG Music, makes it possible for hackers to access the PC and cause damage. In some cases, the software allegedly installed itself before the CD owners were shown an end-user license agreement.
The Homeland Security Department specifically instructs consumers not to install such software from audio CDs.
Sony BMG posted a public apology on its Web site. It recalled the copy-protected CDs for replacement with restriction-free versions and, as a bonus, with MP3 copies of the tracks also. The Web site said, “Ultimately, the experience of consumers is our primary concern… Going forward, we will continue to identify new ways to meet demands for flexibility in how you and other consumers listen to music.”
Sony also made uninstaller software available to remove the misbehaving files. However, the EFF’s lawsuit claims that some of the uninstallers are flawed and could make the PCs more vulnerable to hacking.
The XCP software does not affect portable or non-PC CD players such as those consumers connect to their stereo systems. It does, however, prevent tracks from being played on iPods. Sony is in a struggle in its Japanese home market to prevent Apple from dominating Japan’s online music business with iTunes and the MP3 player market with iPods. At this point Sony is in second place in both categories.
There have recently been some disagreements between Sony and BMG over who should run Sony BMG Music. The management malfunction that allowed the copy-protection snafu will no doubt focus some executive minds.
Sony BMG Music’s booboo is the Katrina of copy protection. All the music companies lose on this one, however, because of the flood of negative publicity that’s been generated.