Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 February 2014

Sports broadcasting will slowly drift to direct Internet delivery

Premium sports and TV continue to draw closer together and depend even more on each other but with signs that with the growth of OTT and Internet video transport, a new model will emerge, at least for distribution through direct to consumer models. So far this is confined to the lesser sports and markets, such as the Netherlands and Chile for domestic football. Meanwhile major pay TV operators or networks have, if anything, strengthened their hold on premium sports through new deals, in some cases running for many years, suggesting that a full transformation in the sporting rights market will be a long time coming.

There are other seismic regional developments in sports broadcasting, for example in Canada where cable TV operator Rogers Communications snatched rights over 12 years to National Hockey League (NHL) games from the sports network TSN in a $5.2 billion agreement. This was significant in that until now Canada has followed the US model of sports broadcasting, where rights were controlled by just a few at most major networks, confining pay TV to downstream distribution in a purely retail capacity.

In the US TV has been dominated by commercial networks from the outset, originally by ABC, NBC and CBS, and later joined by Fox, with pay TV operators then emerging as distributors rather than primary rights holders in the case of sports. Canada had been similar until pay TV operator Rogers’ NHL coup.

Generally Latin America has also gone with the US model as rights have been dominated by TV networks such as Rede Globo. However the situation is not quite so clear cut in Latin America, since satellite pay TV operator DirecTV held lucrative rights to the 2010 FIFA World Cup.

Australia on the other hand has adopted the European model where sports broadcasting is dominated by pay TV, often through exclusive deals. Yet at one time Europe was less market oriented than the US, with sports TV established there by Free To Air (FTA) public service broadcasting, sometimes without advertising, like the BBC, other times with some ad support. Then commercial FTA broadcasting came in to seize at least some of the prize sporting assets, outbidding public counterparts. Finally, at times varying between countries, pay TV operators came in with still deeper pockets, funded by powerful global media moguls like Rupert Murdoch and gained larger market shares on the back of sports and to a somewhat lesser extent movie rights, with original TV series production well down the list, if now making a comeback through Netflix in particular.

Although most of Europe has followed a similar course there are substantial differences between countries. The UK was one of the first countries to see pay TV emerge, with BSkyB having been going over 20 years and becoming the dominant pay TV operator with 11 million customers, around 70% of the market. By contrast Germany is a fairly recent convert to pay TV in general and there Sky Deutschland has only 3.5 million subscribers, despite now having total control of live rights to domestic Bundesliga football matches. Until recently most key football games were available FTA there.

The other principle difference between the US and European sports broadcasting markets lies in the source of revenue. In the US, economies of scale made it viable to generate massive revenues through advertising, sufficient to fund rights payments, although of course backed up indirectly by carriage fees or direct sell through, from pay TV operators. In Europe on the other hand the subscription model has dominated, with advertising a secondary source of revenue. This distinction has had a major impact on the premium sports themselves. On both sides of the pond TV has come to dictate schedules so that matches and games may take place at times inconvenient to paying spectators at the gate and not ideally suited to optimum sporting performance, like late at night.

But in the US the primacy of advertising has introduced timeouts designed to coincide with commercial breaks, rather than say having a longer interval in the middle. This has not happened in the case of football in Europe, where commercial breaks are confined to before and after the matches as well as during half time.

In most markets, including Europe and the US, collective selling by leagues tends to predominate, perhaps as a way of countering the power of TV by exerting joint bargaining power, but also ensuring that the revenues generated filter down to some extent to the smaller teams or clubs, in that way acting to preserve some degree of competitiveness, which in turn is in the interest of all parties.

Collective rights has served premium sports well in revenue terms at least, transforming some clubs from often quite small scale local businesses into global brands. This is reflected in the earnings of top players, which in real terms are over 100 times greater than they were half a century ago, exceeding $20 million a year for the highest paid European footballers for example. TV has boosted leading individual sports, notably boxing, tennis and golf, as well, but to nowhere near the same extent as the top team sports, although these vary between countries. In Europe and Latin America football of course is biggest, while in India cricket has leapt to become a major earner, and in the US the big three of baseball, American football and basketball dominate, followed by hockey. The two big exceptions in Europe to collective rights bargaining are Portugal and also Spain, where Primera Liga clubs negotiate independently with rights holders, with the effect of concentrating even more power and revenue with the top clubs, here mainly Real Madrid and Barcelona. But even Spain is considering moving to collective rights bargaining in order to make the league more competitive and so start matching the English Premier League in its global TV reach.

More recently, stimulated by the growth of the Internet and increasingly widespread distribution OTT or via rights agreements, TV has also promoted sports that previously generated viewing figures too low to be viable for distribution. This includes a variety of minority sports that can now attract a scattered continental or even global audience and also activities such as fishing that are popular, but do not make riveting viewing for most people. The Canadian World Fishing Network, first launched in 2005, is now available through several US pay TV operators including Verizon FiOS and Dish Network.

TV has also helped create new sports suited to the medium, or at least organize previously intermittent events. An example is the Extreme Sports Channel now distributed to 60 countries in 12 languages.

The proliferation in number of sports channels has given increased time for popular sports at a local level that collectively add value to a TV network and generate some local advertising. In the US ESPN, NBC Sports and Big Ten Network all show collegiate basketball games for example. There is likely to be big growth in local sports broadcasting, enabling audiences to watch games they cannot attend or pick up highlights of those they have missed after the event.

Sports has been the leading driver of innovation in pay TV, both in terms of technology and business models, and this will continue to be the case. This does not mean all the models and technologies are successful, for sports propelled HD and may prove the ‘killer app’ for ultra HD, but there was also 3D, which has so far proved a dismal flop, especially for sports, and been abandoned by a number of broadcasters and operators. In the case of business models, sports brought on subscription pay TV and is now at the vanguard of new avenues such as ‘mobile first’ and ‘pay TV lite’.

‘Mobile first’ is the idea that people without a pay TV sub can be brought into the fold through low cost packages, available only to small devices and then be lured into more expensive packages on the big screen. ‘Pay TV Lite’ is also OTT but different in that it may also be available over broadband networks at higher quality, in the understanding that its subscribers may never graduate to a full package. Indeed ‘pay TV Lite’ is likely to converge with traditional pay TV as broadband quality improves, and this is already happening. In the UK for example BT’s broadband subscribers can currently watch English Premier League football matches on large computer displays or quite easily hitch up from their big screen TV and watch in HD, supposedly 1080p.

The BT Sports case highlights the continuing inflation in sports rights costs, which are growing at around 14% annually, compared with 4% for pay TV as a whole, according to Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications. But there is a danger this is creating a bubble that will either burst, or at least trigger some high profile failures or withdrawals. BT Sports has admitted it is unlikely to recoup the $1.2 billion it spent for three years of EPL rights from increased broadband subs over the period or subs to non-broadband subscribers plus carriage fees. It is gambling on making the money up from future subs or pay per view fees, combined with advertising and carriage fees, but meanwhile the way things are going it will pay even more to amass a sufficiently enticing collection of sports programming.

There are plenty of past examples of broadcasters or operators coming unstuck as a result of overpaying for rights, such as Setanta Sports in 2009 and earlier ITV Digital, which went bust in 2002 unable to pay the EPL the $500 million it had agreed in rights.

Among other emerging trends that are worrying for pay TV is the OTT direct to market model now prevailing in Chile and the Netherlands. In Chile, Canal del F’tbol (CDF), the owner of the TV rights for the Chilean football league, struck a deal with multiscreen content delivery technology vendor Elemental Technologies in October 2013 for streaming across the Estadio CDF subscription VoD online platform. This service currently involves payment of a monthly fee to watch live football matches from Chile’s soccer league via connected TV sets, PCs, Macs or tablets. CDF is now planning to use the channel for distribution of Campeonato Nacional de Futbol Profesional Petrobras and Copa de Chile matches to viewers in Chile and ex pats all over the world, without having to worry about rights in different territories since it is the owner of them.

In the case of the Netherlands the decision by the top football clubs in the premier division, called Eredivisie, to go it alone, was taken after failure to obtain a sufficiently good offer from a broadcaster or pay TV operator. Accordingly the channel Eredivisie Live was launched at the start of the 2008-2009 season with full live rights to all matches. This channel is now 51% owned by Fox International Channels Benelux, with the football clubs retaining a 49% share along with TV production company Endemol.

Such a move would not appeal yet to the major leagues in the UK, Spain and Italy, largely because it would mean an end to inflated rights prices paid by the big pay TV operators. But it will happen more in future when the latest round of rights deals expire, since the current level or rights inflation is surely unsustainable.

In the end the sports themselves should end up making at least as much money since they will be able to maximize their reach and not be confined to the customer bases of particular pay TV operators which hold the exclusive rights.

Already we are seeing rights becoming fragmented in leading markets such as the UK, where BT and Sky share the EPL and in turn making the content available OTT via third parties such as Vodafone in Sky’s case. This trend will continue and the question will be when major sports events become available at the time pay per view, without even requiring a day pass. That has already been tried in the case of some sports such as boxing and at the time rejected, largely because operators can make more money by hitching customers to long term subscription packages. But that model is already starting to unravel and will continue to do so.