Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 August 2006

Sweden civil rights groups have a date with Apple over DRM

Sweden is one of the most outspoken Scandinavian countries on the subject of civil liberties, and Apple’s closed DRM system Fairplay, for its iPod, has clearly got the collective Swedish nose out of joint.

Swedish consumer rights groups are now going to sit down with Apple to explain Apple’s position and see if there is any middle ground.

In June, the consumer agencies of Sweden, Denmark and Norway all wrote to Apple saying that it is unfair that consumers in those countries cannot have free use of products that they have bought, i.e. music that is Fairplay protected on an iPod.

This all blew up over the legislation that is still struggling its way into French law, which included clauses that say that interfering with copy protection systems is against the law, even if no copyright abuse is taking place. This is a position devised in 1997 by the US Patent office to deal with global piracy, which was enshrined in both the US Digital Millenium Copyright Act and the World Copyright Treaty, signed by 179 countries. Every time it is debated as it goes onto any statute book, Apple appears to be in the firing line because its DRM is so widely used and so restrictive.

Apple says it is open to listening and might change some of its practices in Scandinavia, but hasn’t detailed any such changes yet. It is likely that they will be minor alternations, as it has steadfastly refused to open its DRM.

The aim is to talk first and decide if there is a legal case to answer later, and if there is and the talks go nowhere, Sweden rights groups may well try a legal test case, which in our view would be unlikely to succeed.