John Legere who runs T-Mobile USA is always fun, but he is not always right, and this week’s blog by him is designed first and foremost to convince regulators that the merger between T-Mobile and Sprint is in the public’s interest. Faultline Online Reporter would back him 100% to bring down prices and do things for the average Joe in the street but saying that he will offer fixed wireless broadband throughout the US is stretching things just a tad too far.
The Legere blog is how it should be done. When Comcast listed the benefits that would ensue if it was allowed to buy Time Warner Cable – no-one believed anything it said – mostly because the statements all ran contrary to the way the company had behaved in every prior year. It was much the same when AT&T said that it should be allowed to buy T-Mobile in 2011. The benefits that were supposed to ensue all ran against the grain of how AT&T had been run up to that point.
Legere said in his blog that the merged company would build a network which will offer wireless at an average speed of 444 Mbps and peak speeds of 4.1 Gbps across two-thirds of the country. This would involve capex investment approaching $40 billion in the next three years alone.
Given that in 2018 the two businesses are planning to spend around $18 billion in capex chasing 5G, that $40 billion over three years is actually a reduction in capex, not an increase. Capex has been rising at both T-Mobile and Sprint from $7.8 billion in 2015 for T-Mobile to $10 billion to $11 billion last year. But that level of investment is in line with the current spend of AT&T and Verizon and they also have a fixed line business to support. So this is in line with what Legere has already been doing. At Faultline Online Reporter, we have been arguing that the capex surge required to complete 5G is unlikely to be repaid and could make 5G impossible to build out.
Legere also argues that this will force AT&T and Verizon to invest at the same rate or better, which of course they will. But they already have to, and they have been resting on their capex laurels for a few years in order to be able to afford this. He raises the specter of rival countries – think China – going ahead in 5G, and promising if the merger is allowed, that won’t happen and reminds us all that the US took a lead in 4G, and that lead has continued through its lifecycle, creating more influence in the technology – this is also true.
He says it is this which has resulted in the US leading the global mobile economy and giving rise to Uber, Snap, Venmo and Instagram. Of course, the stakes are far higher with 5G, because this could be the last wireless network that is ever built (if indeed it is ever finished).
The sub-text to this argument is that alone T-Mobile and Sprint would definitely have struggled to make the capex investment needed for 5G and would have become basket cases in the process. Certainly we cannot see T-Mobile buying a content business in the way AT&T has bought Time Warner, and leverage that to gain subscribers – so the only advantage it could shoot for was to build a superior network.
Much of the rest that Legere claims is true – that it has helped end 2-year service contracts, simplified rate plans and reconstructed unlimited plans. There is no need for the Uncarrier to change its spots – it will continue to behave unlike AT&T and Verizon and will now be on a more secure financial footing. He claims the cost of 1 GB of data will plummet – well no change there, it has been plummeting for a while – he says renowned economist Dr. David Evans concludes that increased competition from the merger will lead to a decrease in the cost per GB of 55% and to a 120% increase in mobile data supplied. On the other hand, WiFi will continue to remain free at many points of use.
The T-Mobile plan calls for the creation of 3,000 jobs in year one, rising to 9,600 jobs by 2021 and the new T-Mobile will add at least 600 new stores. But it does not mean he will not lay off people who do similar jobs in the two merged companies.
He is also right when he says that wireless is no longer a standalone industry, and that companies like Comcast and Charter are making incursions, so mergers need to happen to create new entities which offer wireless, video and broadband (he forgot to mention content).
As he warmed to his task Legere said that by 2024 his network would reach 90% of the country and offer mobile broadband at 100 Mbps, which is enough to rival fixed wired and wireless broadband – claiming that nearly half of the US population (some 48%) either have no in-home broadband or have to choose from just one provider. His argument is that cellular 5G, not counting fixed wireless, will compete with fixed, wired broadband. It won’t.
This is the part of John Legere’s story that you should not believe. T-Mobile and Sprint have the poorest fixed line assets of any of the US cellular operators and while they might just acquire enough backhaul to make this happen, by that time multiple 1 Gbps fixed line operators will have been in the market with an offering for 4 to 5 years and 2 Gbps and 3 Gbps will be with us by then – figures likely to dwarf a mere 100 Mbps and new applications are more likely to require this type of speed – most of it delivered over WiFi, with WiFi moving on another level through the 802.11AX standard and beyond. Cellular data would remain rich man’s data in the sense that those who could afford unlimited plans might not bother linking up to WiFi when they are in-home and on a portable device. We saw this as 4G emerged, all over the US and Europe – people who could not afford broadband using cellular on a laptop and we will see this again in 5G.
But the pledge from Verizon and AT&T, to be in the market offering 5G Fixed Wireless alongside the wireline providers at 1 Gbps by the end of this year is to be taken as a far greater threat to wireline providers and T-Mobile will almost certainly struggle to get a similar job done. Which is why it should have sought out a merger with Comcast or Charter or both in the first place instead of this deal it has done with Sprint. His reasoning for not doing this is that they are hated by their customers, while T-Mobile in the US is loved. This is of course true, but changes little.
We are not saying this is a good reason to disallow the merger, but Legere has to lay his hands on a ton of backhaul, preferably fixed line backhaul, and this may have to be done through partnerships – which brings us back to the major cable providers – before he can provide a viable alternative to wireline. He may be forced to simply go and lay a ton of fiber – something that will continually knock a hole in his capex budget, if he chooses to go down that route.
Finally, he says the merged company will be the fourth largest ISP by 2024, presumably after Comcast (24 million), Charter (23 million) and AT&T (16 million). Verizon is currently fourth (7 million) and not too keen on pursuing fixed wireline, instead putting all its cards on an untried fixed wireless offering, somewhat akin to Clearwire. So if T-Mobile manages to up its game in fast wireless, it will almost certainly be taking market share from the current number four, Verizon, unless it bucks its ideas up.