It seemed bizarre enough that Telecom Italia planned to reverse its strategy of the past two years, of integrating fixed and mobile operations more closely, and separate the two, but the news, acrimoniously leaked by the government, that sale of the cellular arm was on the cards, arouses even more astonishment.
At a time when even the companies that rode to fortune on being mobile-only, unencumbered by fixed lines’notably Vodafone’are scrabbling for wireline broadband partners, in order to join the convergence race, Telecom Italia seems to be sacrificing its head start over many players in this market in the interests of pleasing shareholders with debt reductions.
It aims to concentrate its growth efforts on becoming a media company and content distributor, but appears to have forgotten that content will no longer be just about IPTV and fixed lines, but also about being able to deliver the quadruple play, embracing mobile networks.
Despite widespread speculation, however, it is unlikely that the Italian move, however it plays out, will halt the pace of convergence in Europe and elsewhere.
This is not just a telco matter of course, one of the companies moving rapidly towards a quadruple play is the News Corp empire of Rupert Murdoch, one of the suitors for one or more elements of Telecom Italia, though also, more oddly, rumored to be in talks to sell its US satellite TV arm, DirecTV, to Liberty Media group.
With the likes of Murdoch looming, established giants need to respond quickly, and Vodafone has followed up its recent German fixed/mobile plans with agreements in the UK, with BT, and Italy, with Fastweb, to offer converged services. The latter deal makes it even clearer that Telecom Italia needs to think very hard before bucking the convergence trend too hastily.
Recently, it seemed that the whole telecoms world had reached a consensus on fixed/mobile convergence and quadruple play – everybody needed them. Wireline operators had to gain mobile capabilities quickly, hence the US cablecos’ deal with Sprint Nextel; broadcasters had to access converged networks, and so we see News Corp/DirecTV embarking on a complex web of deals; and wireless-only carriers either needed to enhance their networks sufficiently to deliver fixed services too, or find a cellular partner.
Even the stalwartly non-wired Vodafone is now moving rapidly, if belatedly, to launch converged services in its most pressurized markets, with the UK and Italy added to the list last week. So why does Telecom Italia want to buck this apparently unstoppable trend and sell off its cellular arm in order to concentrate entirely on fixed line IP triple play?
What could have been a straightforward, if incomprehensible, transaction has been turned, in true Italian style, into a murky and politically charged dispute that may, in itself, ward off potential bidders, and has already cost the company’s chairman his job. Last week, Prime Minister Romano Prodi and other government ministers slammed the plan of chairman Marco Tronchetti Provera to split fixed line and mobile operations, and spin off the latter, because they fear this will lead to the sale of one or both to a non-Italian buyer or buyers. The mobile group, analysts estimate, would fetch about €35billion ($44.5 billion).
This opposition and an acrimonious public war of words led to Tronchetti Provera resigning this weekend, to be replaced by well respected former senator Guido Rossi.
However, while the government opposition and shareholder confusion at Tronchetti Provera’s reorganization, which signaled an abrupt reversal of his formerly enthusiastic convergence policy, could have severely limited his freedom of action in exploring strategic options for his company, the telco is now left with a new chairman and no clear direction at all.
The government is likely to have a heavier influence over Rossi than his
predecessor, even though the European Commission has warned against the government vetoing a possible foreign sale of any or all of the company.
EU internal markets spokesman Oliver Drewes said: ‘As a very general remark, I can make the observation that golden shares as such have no place in the internal market. We will watch closely future developments for possible market violations.’ But it is unlikely that Rossi will simply undo the reorganization plan and put the telco back on its former track – break-up and mobile sell-off is still very much on the cards as the company struggles with its €41bn ($52 billion) debt mountain.
On Wednesday, Prodi’s office said the prime minister was ‘surprised and worried’ by the mobile spin-off plans, and disclosed private conversations with Tronchetti Provera, in order to show that sale of key Telecom Italia assets was very much on the cards, contrary to earlier statements by the telco, which had said the split of fixed and mobile operations was not designed to make it easier to sell parts of the company.
‘We have no intention to sell, we just want to add more flexibility, both operationally and financially,’ Tronchetti Provera had previously stated. The impact of Telecom Italia’s decision on the world of quadruple play is further complicated by the emergence of Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp as a possible buyer for the mobile unit or the whole telco.
Not in itself surprising – it is clear that the Murdoch organization is increasingly interested in the mobile and telecoms markets, as its recent acquisitions, but shocking when coupled with news that the world’s greatest media tycoon is considering selling out of the US satellite sector. Talks with Murdoch were one of the key issues disclosed by the Italian prime minister after his conversations with Tronchetti Provera, with a potential deal that could include the merger of News Corp broadcasting unit Sky Italia with Telecom Italia. Previously, both News Corp and Telecom Italia had said that they were only negotiating a potential content sharing deal.
Only two years ago, Tronchetti Provera was urging investors to back a strategy based on fixed-mobile convergence. In recent months, though, he has argued that the main focus should be on strengthening Telecom Italia’s internet content offerings and now plans to divide the operator in three – the mobile arm, the fixed network owner, and the fixed customer base and content operations.
Part of this strategy is to build up the internet business further on an international scale, as indicated by this week’s announcement that Telecom Italia would buy AOL’s German unit from Time Warner for €675million ($855 million). This is fine, except that content alliances and investments need to be related to both the mobile and fixed networks, and sacrificing the most profitable and high growth part of the company, the cellco arm, would show that Telecom Italia had learned nothing from its UK counterpart BT’s sale of its own cellular arm, which became O2 – a move that has forced BT into ever more complex and uncertain moves to try to gain a credible wireless offering again, including its expanding relationship with Vodafone.
Meanwhile, News Corp is apparently indulging in strange behavior of its own, conducting talks with Liberty Media, apparently about the Murdoch organization selling its controlling stake in US satellite broadcaster DirecTV to Liberty, in return for Liberty’s 19% stake in News Corp.
This would be a shocking volte-face for Murdoch, who acquired DirecTV after a long battle in 2003, and has shepherded the company to become a serious contender with the US cablecos for the television and, now, the emerging triple play market.
DirecTV is said to be close to a partnership with broadband wireless operator Clearwire to add wireless and mobile capabilities, and a broadband return path, to its satellite services but it is operating in a slowing and highly pressurized US satellite sector, and one where it has to face the cablecos and the triple play plans of the large telcos, AT&T, Verizon and BellSouth.
As well as News Corp, Time Warner and General Electric were revealed by the prime minister’s office to be in talks with the incumbent telco. Another possible option could be a private equity deal like the €13bn purchase agreed for Danish incumbent TDC by a consortium of Apax Partners, Blackstone Group, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, Permira and Providence Equity Partners.
Sale of the entire Telecom Italia group, notwithstanding government fury, would make far better sense than separating its key units. Despite progress in IPTV and other areas, a mobile-free Telecom Italia would be a rump organization that would find it hard to compete outside its own territory or even against converged players in its own borders – especially with that competition stepping up as Vodafone ties up with Fastweb. For Telecom Italia Mobile (TIM) itself, sale to a larger group would certainly be advantageous.
TIM has 29m lines in Italy (40% market share) and 22m in Brazil, where it is number two in the mobile market, but it is being dwarfed by the steady march of the multinational majors – Vodafone, T-Mobile, Telef’nica, TeliaSonera and Orange ‘ which are set to sew up the European and, to some extent, Latin American markets between them. But TIM’s interests would still be better served if the acquisition kept it coupled to its parent, adding a fully converged platform, in one of the most advanced all-IP markets, to the purchasers’ footprint.
However, the telco is under intense pressure to pay off debt, which totals €41bn, and sale of TIM would go a long way to achieve this, even though it would reverse a converged strategy that the chairman himself ushered in – last year he bought the 44% of TIM that Telecom Italia didn’t already own for €20bn. He also needs to boost the share price, which is half the level it was when he took over the helm in 2001, and while the converged company will surely generate more shareholder value in the medium term than a fixed-only organization, in the short term, media assets are generally valued on a higher multiple than telco assets – hence the insistent focus on redefining the company around media content distribution.
Stock market semantics do not a successful operator make though, and it is clear that sell-off will deprive Telecom Italia of the chance to provide its content to mobile networks.
And analysts doubt the ability of the telco to shift substantially into media. In a research note issued last week, Morgan Stanley wrote: ‘It is hard for the media tail to wag the telecoms dog’ and said that media was ‘too small’ to counteract downward trends in fixed line telecoms.