This week, the long awaited bid by Telefonica for control of Digital+ has materialized, the DTH player which also controls the Canal+ channels in Spain. If this deal goes through it will give Telefonica, already dominant in Spanish broadband, a 61% stranglehold on Spanish pay TV, a move almost certain to run into regulatory problems. Reports say that Prisa has been quick to accept the bid.
Most European countries have specific laws preventing the creation of a monopoly through merger, from a situation where there was no monopoly previously, but from a Telefonica point of view, this moves seems to make perfect sense, as it does for the current owner Prisa.
Telefonica already owns 22% of Prisa’s Digital+, which is both a satellite platform and which offers the same Canal+ programming over other OTT partners, as well as local football rights, which are currently re-sold to all the other pay TV platforms in Spain.
A year ago there were 1.72 million satellite TV customers on Digital+ and yet during 2013 Prisa lost 99,000 subs, falling to 1.62 million, which Telefonica thinks is a good idea to add to its 672,000 Imagenio IPTV customers in Spain.
Globally Telefonica has been in love with this idea of offering triple or quad play services and while the great bulk of its revenue still comes from its huge mobile empire on both sides of the Atlantic (Latin American and select European countries) its TV has been very lopsided.
It currently has 3.3 million pay TV customers globally, but does not have a system in the UK, where it is strong in mobile, and in Germany it has just closed down its pay TV operations, having acquired as Alice TV from Telecopm Italia, and then watched them fall from 75,000 customers two years ago to 41,500 in the last quarter of 2013, when it gave up the ghost and closed the service down. At Faultline we forecast Alice TV’s closure as early March 2013, but the service lingered on while Telefonica tried to work out what to do with it.
Telefonica IPTV services in the Czech Republic have got back into growth in the last quarter of 2013 up to 156,000 subscribers, but both there and in Spain the numbers have been up recently after dramatically down periods, as the company turned to the now Ericsson owned Mediaroom to rejuvenate its video services, and its well-publicized Global Video Project, for preparing and distributing video globally across all of its services. In the fourth quarter of last year (first quarter results are out in a few days) Imagenio TV in Spain jumped from 609,000 customers to 672,000, well below its heyday when it approached 800,000. Today this represents a 17% market share, and if Teleconica adds the 44% plus market share of Canal+ and its DTH platform, it will overnight leap to over 61% market share in pay TV.
It will also inherit one of the largest European deals for Cisco set tops, Digital+ having agreed an exclusive 5 year deal with Cisco during 2012.
Historically the Spanish regulator has approved such merger deals on the nod, where Teleconica is concerned, and will likely on this occasion and may point out that Ono has recently been acquired by the global multinational Vodafone, representing a real threat to Telefonica, and use that as justification. However we would expect the local regulator to be pushed back into line by the European Commission if it goes ahead and approves the deal and for any approval to be reversed.
The offer that is being published by Spanish newspapers is €725 million for the 56% of the TV platform owned by Prisa, the other 44% shared equally between Mediaset of Italy and Telefonica.
The truth is that it is tough to see what else Prisa can do. This represents a move out of pay TV, and dropping 41% of its total revenue and getting back to content production and radio. This group witnessed a 17% fall in advertising in 2012, and just a small rise in 2013, and last year had a VAT of 8% for pay TV services more than doubled, killing what little consumer enthusiasm there was for pay TV. Prisa lost €648.7 million on a revenue of €2.7 billion, due to impairments taken on the TV business.
So Prisa certainly wants to get out of a business that has caused it financial harm, but selling to the largest incumbent telco, a dominant quad play operator, is not something we can see getting approval. The regulator is not obliged to help it find a better answer to its predicament, but is merely there to act in the public interest, which probably means blocking this deal. This deal has been talked about for a few years simply because of the existence of this ‘put’ option for the remaining shares, which was built into the original purchase of 22% of the shares. But that option has never been past Regulator scrutiny, and of course this will have to get past both the telecoms regulator and the financial regulator, and eventually the European Commission.
What kind of abuse could Telefonica go in for if the deal goes ahead? There is a danger that Telefonica may decide not to share soccer coverage with rivals, and could pull much of the mainstream Canal+ content from rivals too, including the full channel suite that it offers to Jazztel, a company that Telefonica has already wronged by pushing it out of the IPTV market due to market control of ADSL wholesale pricing (there is still a complaint out on this), forcing it to become one of the first linear OTT service providers in Europe, in order to survive.
Both Vodafone and Orange are jointly pushing out fiber throughout Spain and Telefonica is going head to head with them on that front, and if it has a content edge, it could achieve payback on its Capex far faster.
Vodafone would almost certainly hit the same kind of regulatory problems as Telefonica if it tried to buy the Canal+ channels and Digital+ DTH platform, although Orange has a small enough pay TV market share that it might pass regulatory scrutiny in Spain.
If the local regulator does give the go ahead then the deal may go through and have to be unwound by the European authorities after that fact, something that weak regulators often think works as a ‘fait accomplis’ but turns out to create a lot of problems.
This comes just as DTT broadcast TV is beginning to take a back seat in Spain (see separate article in this issue).