The Mexican government is currently deciding whether to approve Telmex’s bid to acquire a 51% stake in Dish Mexico. Rival broadcasters Televisa and TV Azteca are calling for a probe into the proposal.
The newly formed telecom regulator IFT has announced that it will investigate a possible alliance between Telmex and Dish, which will decide whether such a move would comply with the terms of Telmex’s license ‘ which does not allow it to provide pay TV directly.
The IFT is also expected to declare America Movil, Televisa and Telmex dominant forces in their respective markets, due to their monopoly market shares. That ruling would subject them to tougher scrutiny and compliance from the regulator.
Telmex has 55% of the fixed internet market in Mexico, and with sister company Telcel it controls 70% of the mobile market. The OECD estimate this costs Mexican consumers $25 billion per year in higher service prices.
Telmex has had an agreement with Dish, since 2008, to print a single customer bill for shared services. Currently, Telmex bills and collects the service to 51.9% of Dish Mexico’s customers. This agreement has provoked anger from rivals in the market, and has been called a ‘disguised merger’ that lets billionaire Carlos Slim access the domestic TV market by the backdoor.
Eduardo Ruiz Vega, director of Regulatory Compliance Grupo Salinas (the owner of TV Azteca) says that the relationship between telco Telmex and Dish in breach of the Telmex license. He claims that the two ‘are the same company’ and that the agreement is anti-competitive.
Telmex owner Carlos Slim wants to make clear that Telmex has other billing agreements with Teleton and Socia Aguila, subsidiaries of Grupo Televisa, and TV Azteca affiliates Media Game and Azteca Web.
Slim has provoked angry responses from broadcasters in Mexico, who object to the billionaire’s expansion of the fixed-line Telco. Slim is the owner of America Movil, and Telmex is the fixed-line unit of the company. Thanks to the billing agreement with Dish (via Dish owners MVS Comunicaciones and EchoStar) the telco is now able to offer a triple play package to customers ‘ something the rivals vocally object to.
The two largest broadcasters in Mexico, Televisa and TV Azteca, have objected to Dish including their free-to-air channels in its service, following a change in the constitution that required the satellite broadcasters to provide the free-to-air channels on their pay TV platforms. Televisa claims that this will cost them $105 million in sales this year.
Neither Televisa or TV Azteca draw much attention to their own attempts to provide phone and internet services to Telmex customers, or that Televisa’s Sky satellite offering has been losing ground rapidly to Dish, which is charged at about half the equivalent price of Sky.
They also do not mention that between them they enjoy around 96% market share in free to air TV, and the very public disputes that have taken place in recent years. Mexican journalists frequently take the view that the smears and personal attacks are little more than marketing tactics.
Telmex is also said to be considering competing directly with Dish, if it is not able to acquire the 51% stake. It declared that ‘if convergence is achieved and Telmex is allowed to offer pay TV services, we will be a new competitor in the market for all operators.’