Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 September 2011

The Emperor’s new clothes are woven with OTT Tablet strategies at IBC

The International Broadcasting Conference or Convention is becoming more and more like Lourdes ‘ companies, instead of people, journey there for the cure to whatever ails them. And in the broadcast markets there’s a lot of ways for companies to get ill right now, but perhaps a bewildering number of ways for them to get well.

The question is always which bandwagon to jump on or to avoid. In the past there have been many of these, such as IPTV, middleware, new approaches to VoD, and Mobile TV. But this year there are at least three ‘ Tablets, OTT and the core driver ‘ Broadcast Catch up , as well as many other underlying themes like electrical power constraints and device integration.

You can tell those who are about to jump on a bandwagon. They always ask more questions than they answer. Faultline this year was beset at the end of each technology briefing with ‘What do you think is going to happen?’ And that takes up perhaps more time than the questions about their particular business .

People are attracted to and talk about the companies at IBC which appear to have a God given certainty about them. Some are certain because they have made a major announcement, like Liberty Global and its Horizon set top, initially for UPC in the Netherlands. The suppliers behind this project have grown ‘ it was NDS, Intel and Samsung at the start, now more have jumped on this particular bandwagon ‘ Kit Digital and its UK subsidiary ioko, local App store provider Metrological Media Innovations and of course conditional access provider Nagravision, not to mention thePlatform, a US company with its mpx content management system and even Yahoo’s TV widgets got a mention. There are MoCA and Celeno in there, even the company that built the web site got a mention (we won’t mention them here). This is a glorious bandwagon of certainty running through the show ‘ and everyone talked about it, though not all in glowing terms. We are personally unsure about it. (See separate story)

Other companies not asking questions are those pulling in money hand over fist. One such company was Irish software integration specialist S3, who several years ago met us at the show and did nothing but ask us questions ‘ now it confidently tells us about the set top service testing market, its space on the Broadcom chipset and how many set tops are returned as broken when they are perfectly okay (See item next week). This is a company that has found its niche, away from the limelight, but at the sharp end, where the money is made, in simply making things more reliable.

So back to those three themes ‘ Over The Top video, and how every product can now offer this; Tablets and how every piece of content can now be viewed on them, and broadcast catch up TV and how well it is doing. You have to be very careful, because these subjects, though massively interlinked, are not the same subject ‘ they are different.

‘If you don’t have an App on a tablet, you’re dead’ should have been the name of the show. Last year it was perhaps better named as ‘Tablets are coming and we’re in the front of the queue.’ Over The Top is one way of getting there, Broadcast Catch up, especially HbbTV, is what all the pay TV market is running from.

Last year’s news – social viewing, recommendation systems and cloud search are all still on the agenda, but those particular bandwagons have been discussed, climbed upon and failed to make anyone rich yet (although most of them have not truly been implemented in the field yet) and so IBC visitors are more comfortable with them.

Over The Top however was a watchword for the show and when people asked us about OTT was were unsure of what to say ‘ after all we’ve been talking about it since 2002, so what’s new? For instance if you are a software player, and you live in the stack in a DVB-T box which delivers a free service, OTT could mean taking a version of the broadcast signal and transcoding it and exposing it to WiFi and getting it to a tablet. Of course the internet is not involved at all, there is nothing to go over the top of, unless it’s the broadcast signal, and there are no irritating security issues to overcome, no conditional access to convert from. Companies like the UK’s Ant has something like this, and it’s not the only one. But Ant and other rivals still have to convince people to load their software stack, and here is the problem.

A broadcaster doesn’t pay for that stack, and what does he get out of it? They will have their own route to the tablet, offering catch up services, why allow an eco-system partner to steal their thunder? The device makers can either accommodate it or can work around it. The hybrid catch up set top makers (HbbTV) can embrace it, because it may sell more boxes, but are they actually going to pay more for it?

So it’s not over the top and it might not make anyone any more money. So what’s the point, apart from the fact that consumers love it? And that’s the concern throughout the show ‘ is Broadcast catch up really going to eat enough lunch from pay TV to make pay TV operators move to OTT services, or is this all about tablets? Consumers loved Mobile Broadcast TV, but no-one can make any money at it and we all moved on. Yes you have to get signals to a tablet today – somehow, but someone still has to make money. Yes you can go over the top of the internet, but someone has to make money. Pay TV operators can do many things in the name of churn reduction. Broadcasters can only make money if more programs are being watched ‘ whether that’s OTT to a set top, PC catch up or the provisioning of a full scale widget platform for running Apps.

Broadcom this week bought NetLogic for $3.7 billion. It offers chips that can build networks which can deliver video fast. It also has chips that can inspect IP packets and determine if they are video or not, faster than almost any other device. Companies like this can make money from the spike of video traffic over the internet ‘ but others do not have so clear a case.

But each one costs a lot of money. So even for the wonderfully celebrated Horizon box revealed by Liberty Global, that money has to lead the company somewhere financially. Of course it might not all be costing the operator money, as some device benefits, some chip and SoC improvements, would normally lead to lowering of costs, and instead of accepting the lowering of costs, it can opt to keep the costs the same, and do more with the money. But any way you look at it this it is expensive. Intel chips are expensive in electrical power consumption; Samsung is expensive because it can only make money on large volumes of set tops, NDS is expensive because an additional layer of software is being added, Nagra is expensive because it has to collaborate with its arch-rival at NDS and it hates that. And all the OTT content will cost UPC more money.

The Horizon box, in the end is a pretty open and straightforward architecture. It will lead to more customers being unable to do without UPC TV. But this is the equivalent of supplying a brand new Xbox or PS3 to every customer and porting your set top software to it (oh yes Microsoft did exactly that) . UPC can include it in a two year, slightly more expensive customer contract. The customer may hardly notice the price increase, and they may opt for it in droves, but where is the extra revenue? For many operators there would be none, except perhaps churn reduction.

And here is the gamble ‘ UPC will research an entirely new paradigm of box, it will put out a new UI, it will integrate the function of tablets, with more data about the program you are watching, the system will only be ‘aware’ of what you are watching on your TV because it phrases that question through the Cloud back end, not because there is any interaction with your set top. The device will use an unknown brand of chip, well unknown in this space ‘ and not only will it take on all that uncertainty, but it will introduce more options to NOT watch the TV, by adding 60 new TV Apps now and more later.

No wonder that group wandered around the show with such certainty ‘ a keynote from the CEO of UPC, an NDS stand that you couldn’t breathe on, with everyone asking about ‘new’ TV. There is a new advertising paradigm in there somewhere, but until 1 million or 2 million of these boxes ship, that can’t make any more advertising revenue, so that may never happen.

And the Horizon box is so complex that the other company we met who was utterly confident, tiny Irish S3, was immediately brought into mind. A story ran earlier in the week that S3 has forecast that Pay TV operators around the world are facing rising costs driven from deployments of OTT and hybrids which will triple from $3 billion in 2011 to $9 billion by 2014. This is without the Capex costs of the upfront capital, this doesn’t count installation support but it DOES include all the follow up costs such as extra time used at call centers, replacement of faulty set tops and the truck roll associated with that, even the creation of FAQs on support web sites. So UPC is not only faced with paying the upfront costs of Horizon, but also all these invisible costs. Where will all that money come from? Even a decrease in churn because customers are tied in irrevocably is not enough. Which is why so many people at IBC were scratching their heads and wondering what UPC was doing.

Suddenly a complex OTT strategy might have the UPC help desks curing ailments in tablet devices, PCs and smart phones, using unconnected support tools and integrating with partners as erratic as YouTube, Facebook and Twitter.

So will this actually prevent TV churn at UPC? Well probably not. At least the Horizon box probably won’t. Typically the top 10% of customers buy into something like this box over a two year period ‘ and given that it will only exist in a small part of its footprint, perhaps half during that time, and given that only half of UPC customers are in fact on digital systems, it can only be something like 400,000 customers over that period. And then it may even slow down because other territories have even less digital cable lines and some of those are in countries suffering economically.

So when you examine this, it is more about using a wonderful TV platform to seduce customers to upgrade from analog to digital. From there they can be sold triple play, and their ARPU will rise dramatically, not purely for TV, but for the entire cable offering.

The fact is that if UPC was to be close to 100% digital then it might want to take on the considerable technical security challenges of letting every device in the home, including tablets, get TV by unraveling the signal from a conditional access system at the set top. But that would leave this particular operator UPC, in a mess. It doesn’t mean that this is not the right strategy for Comcast in the US however.

So this is not actually about OTT, it is a new business strategy for a company which is hell bent on digitalization, and this strategy is being dressed up as OTT. The tablet route is from remote servers, very similar to the way Sky Go works. So it has ticked that box, there is content direct to a tablet. At present it is tied to a home, just the way those TV Everywhere strategies of Comcast, Time Warner Cable and Cablevision take full TV services to the tablet, but only when it is in the home. It uses the same authentication services in the same way, which is why some of that VoD technology has been imported from the US.

In other words UPC has invented a strategy for itself, which other cable TV operators cannot copy, or at least not copy exactly ‘ partly because they may lack the deep pockets of Liberty, partly because they don’t have the content renegotiation skills to target tablets, but also partly because they have different problems.

In a way you have to applaud UPC for creating so much excitement for what is purely a digitalization acceleration strategy, and that will probably be borne out when it announces pricing and what kind of TV customers are allowed to get Tablet services.

In the DLNA world another customer might use DTCP-IP streaming protection to move content to a tablet, they might use the RVU Alliance Remote User Interface standard to create a similar experience on tablets and set tops and PCs.

At the show Pace was talking about a first implementation of that RVU standard, and yes it was all submerged under a very sensible discussion about operators wanting to be able to have a flexible framework, install a platform in order to present one business model, but to be flexible enough to make a change if that model doesn’t work. But of course the discussion ends up, at this particular IBC show, dressed in OTT and Tablet delivery, and to some extent in the catch up TV phenomena that Pace customers are trying to insure themselves against.

The same is true of virtually every company we spoke to ‘ content protection companies such as Viaccess, Verimatrix and Irdeto have the problem of hardening devices either in software, or through the core SoC chip so content can either go OTT or round the home more cheaply or to get onto a tablet. Encoder companies like Envivio, the same, talking about innovating to create 10 or 20 different streams which can go to different devices ‘ Over the top, and to a tablet, to a phone, to a zapper.

Middleware companies like Minerva and VoD companies like Edgeware are talking about delivering in parallel to a tablet, from the cloud. Everywhere the same language is being used. Even the DLNA studiously avoid talking about how to protect content to a tablet ‘because it’s not its turf’ and directs us to DECE Ultaviolet for finding out how content formats and secure containers support the models – OTT and Tablets. But the main announcement at the show for DLNA was the delivery of premium video to multiple devices, with ‘effective DRM as a pre-condition’ but at least embracing Quality of Service and Trick play, potentially on tablets.

Even Entropic which is one of the main chipmakers behind MoCA, although obsessed with the war for next generation home networks ‘ real technology ‘ still has to speak also about its success in being included in the Horizon project (OTT and Tablets) in between beating on Powerline technologies like HomePlug and G.hn, and WiFi.

There were companies which did not have to address OTT or Tablets, but they were few and far between. Celeno has been included in the Horizon project, so is only attached to that by association, but really had on show a client 3 x 3 MIMO client chip which can plug into a USB port and support WiFi from its gateway chips in zapper or other devices.

And that is perhaps one of the other core debates of the show, this process of terminating conditional access in one point in the home and then sending on signals to other secure devices using DTCP-IP, so that the home can share the benefits of a single TV service. Obviously we wrote last week about Broadcom’s full band capture, which is one way (great way) of solving the tuner problems associated with this process, but also the merging of the concept of the set top or whole home DVR and the home gateway. Pace and AirTies both had such a Media Gateway on show. While Technicolor pointed out that what these two companies have is a Home Gateway and multi-room DVR separately, but placed in one box, and what Technicolor is planning, is all of the above running off a single processor, using half the power.

And that finally brings us to one of the other great name drops of IBC, that of electrical power and the European regulations on power. All chip makers, set top makers, gateway specialists, were all hyper aware of the 2013 and 2014 regulations for power usage in devices. Celeno used power for one if its criticisms of rival Quantenna ‘ saying that offering 4 x 4 MIMO, as Quantenna does, leads to an extra power amplifier on the chip, leading to 25% more power consumption for no real gain. We’re not saying that we accept this argument, only that power may well be one of next year’s IBC bandwagons.

But for now we see this IBC leading the industry into the kind of system complexity that the handset industry has had to deal with for the past decade, and which it is only just getting to grips with and leads us to that old tried and tested adage, ‘Complexity leads to cost,’ which leads us all the way back to S3 and how it rubbed its hands at the prospect simply because it makes money out of testing video services and devices. The less they work, the more money it makes.

If you could have found the perfect product at IBC to reflect the marketing prejudices, it would have been a tablet app showing TV, with a new class of security either software only or a new SoC core. It would have the same interface as a new revolutionary TV UI, and it would have used less power in video mode that in App mode. It would have a new cloud based search and recommendation engine and its video would be driven by a codec which re-sizes precisely for its biggest screen size. Oh yes and it would have had social networking built in.
Oh well, perhaps next year.