Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 November 2006

The future of mobile TV will not be pointed out to us by economists

A report published this week by Nokia, and compiled by the London School of Economics makes a nonsense of every survey conducted about mobile TV and of virtually all the decisions taken so far by mobile TV operators.

Wherever we have talked to mobile TV operators they have made one thing clear. That it’s called mobile TV because it is just like the TV, but on a mobile. There has been virtually no innovation in the business model, no changes in the programming or the timing of the programming and no thought given to what consumers would really want if they knew what was possible. Instead they are given what they will recognize, TV unchanged, but smaller.

We have publicly said that it will take about two years after the launch of each mobile TV service until operators begin to experiment and start innovating at the service level.

But this report, attempting to think outside of the box, and entitled ‘This Box Was Made For Walking,’ concurs with what we’ve been preaching at Faultline, that there will be widespread disruption of content provision and in particular of how advertising works. It highlights interactivity and personalization as the key elements.

But there is a key word in there ‘ultimately.’ It says mobile TV will ultimately give way to a more personal and private TV experience than that of traditional broadcast TV. It fails to place a timeframe on that process.

There is a quote from Harri M’nnist’, Director, Multimedia at Nokia, endorsing the research. But here’s a question for you Harri? DVB-H is now being optimized to be received by non-handset devices, and a new OMA DRM version is being created to protect content on devices that cannot interact.

By offering a service to devices that cannot interact, both the personalization and the interaction are potentially compromised. Making the Nokia supported DVB-H perhaps not quite personal or interactive. Of course when this technology is on a mobile phone, which also has the two way cellular channel, more or less everything that is possible on a two way IP network is possible, specifically interaction with programming and advertising, and some level of recording of personal choices.

The report also finds itself captivated by the current fad of user generated content. But it doesn’t take a genius to realize that UGC really IS a fad. It’s long term usage patterns are not established and people are already getting bored with the effort of creating the content in the first place. The report cites Current TV, as having 30% of its programming consisting of user-generated content. But this is a citizen journalism site, and most of the content is created by unpaid, but professional journalists. That is a trend that we can relate to. More people will make video in the future, but they will find interesting ways to turn it into a business, with a very low outlay, the price of a mobile phone and a handycam.

Of course mobile users will soon be offered devices that can take and store video, and create it in better ways, with zoom and edit facilities which are not there today.

Other ideas in the report are quite novel. The five second advertising spot is obvious, but mobile TV services are being brought to market with the traditional 30 second spots. We have to think about how long people have to view mobile TV, and if it’s on a 30 minute journey on the way to work, delivering 6 adverts that are each 30 seconds long, would take up 10% of the journey time, and the device could easily be switched off or switching to instant messaging or mobile internet. Advertising innovation has to go at least that far, but preferably these services will offer advertising that is context driven (car adverts in car programs) or better still localized. At the extreme end of the spectrum we should have full addressable advertising across multiple platforms, with people who are looking for a car getting car ads and everyone else getting something different (because of their searches on a browser and because of demographic information into how long they’ve had their car and how often they buy one).

Advertising engagement is far better when the advert is relevant and my 16 year old son asked the other day what was the point in advertising insurance in programs he watches? And he has a point.

You might even fill in a form which said what type of adverts that you are likely to ‘hate’ or likely to ‘listen’ to and opt into a type of advertising. But the report never suggested this level of personalization. Also why can’t you opt to have no advertising at all and pay a little more, or store content on a DVR on the phone and fast forward through the ads. Another idea that the report never brushed.

Nobody to our knowledge had conducted a survey into what the right format and length is for a mobile advert, so at least coming out with the 5 second spot, was a good thought, except that it came from this idea that mobile users are ‘snacking,’ consuming content in tiny fragments of time and flipping through channels.

This, in our view, is a complete misnomer. Snacking happens on unicast video when people are looking for something short because of the concentration it takes to watch something with that low a resolution. The length of program will go up when the resolution is clearer and there are devices such as miniature built-in projectors, that make the viewing far easier and these are coming.

The report predicts that mobile TV programming will be a combination of original content from broadcast television and new content made specifically for mobile. We have to disagree fundamentally with this statement.

Let’s start off by taking it far further. There will be MORE mobile TVs, at some stage in the future, than fixed TVs. As such, most content will end up being made for the mobile. But we don’t thing it will owe anything, to shortform, snacking culture.

So we don’t think it will be shorter and more concise, nor do we see movies broken into ten parts for broadcast in digestible chunks, which the report put forward as ideas. It is clear that a 25 GB hard drive or 25 GB of flash memory will fit into a device in the next three years and that the processing power of the device will be sufficient to drive a High Definition TV screen. At that point the portability of the device means that it is not just for viewing TV programming, but for carrying it. The emergence of terabyte class home servers that can transfer films to handsets in seconds, will mean that TV sized TV will be copied to the handset, both in terms of the screen resolution and the viewing length, so expect 110 minute feature films that are watched in bite sized chunks, but not cut up for you by the operator.

Other things that the report points to are user interactivity in the plots of reality TV shows and game shows, which is fine; more user generated content; and new formats including talking heads and close ups, and less wide screen formats; mobisodes and visually spectacular image-orientated programming; local content and it says that we should look out for new prime times, which is old news with travel to work viewing, lunchtime viewing and the normal prime time.

What this says to us is that simulcating of existing TV programs is ALL wrong, but this is exactly what operators are planning to do. In the lunchtime prime time, at present they will be seeing children’s programming and housewives chat shows and at least delayed previous night TV is what’s required so people can catch up with what they’ve missed.

The problem with reports of this type is that people that are not specialists in the world of the technology often miss things that are possible now, or impossible any time soon. Their ideas are all good, but they can’t put a value on the cost of getting them done.

But then again this was really about attaching the not inconsiderable name of the LSE with Nokia’s efforts to get operators to think outside the mobile TV box, o it wasn’t about Nokia setting its strategy based on LSE thinking, it was about marketing really.