Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2006

The heart of gaming may one day be the mobile handset

Two things have happened in response to the article we published two weeks ago ‘The heart of entertainment must one day be the mobile handset.’ First off we got lots of junk mail from techie people that read a copy of the article on a news web site, saying that we must be crazy to think that, and secondly we drew applause and comment from Mike Yuen, Senior Director, Gaming Group at Qualcomm.

The thrust of the less supportive comments were that ‘we don’t want all our portable devices functions in one single device,’ with the implication that this is a stupid idea. Faultline analysts were around when the PC was first launched in 1980, and watched it swallow up the typewriter and the word processor, while suppliers kept maintaining that the PC would never be good enough to compete with them.

The PC has gone on to become many things, a home entertainment center, a music player, a portal onto the internet, a bank teller machine, a security controller, a cash till and countless other things.

The handset is set to become our personal identity, our payment and authorization device, a way of keeping track of where we are, and what we spent our time doing, a communicator, a portable portal onto the mobile web, a music player ‘ in fact all the things that a PC became, plus something more personal, including a remote control for the TV that just happens to ‘know’ where all your content is.

Yuen added the dimension of gaming to our analysis and makes a pretty good case that gaming is on the verge of being conquered by the mobile phone as well.

First he points out that gaming is growing faster than other forms of entertainment, and we cannot argue there, and that we stand on the edge of a full-blown console war between Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo.

But Yuen argues that this is not really a global market yet because 80% of spending on video game hardware and software takes place in the United States, Europe and Japan, with only minuscule amounts coming from the rest of the world. Again that’s something we can’t argue with.

He worries that the increasing prices of successive generations of consoles means that the third world and other, only slightly poorer parts of the world, are really waiting for a gaming experience that is cheap enough for their operators to subsidize, in a handset, and talks about a good enough console or GEC for regions such as India, China, Latin America and Russia which make up a huge number of untapped gamers.

The numbers actually support this. Around 200 million gaming consoles are being used today and perhaps as many as 200 million PCs have gaming played on them regularly. By comparison if a gaming architecture can be enhanced on the phone cheaply enough, then more like 2.5 billion people, or 38% of the world’s population will own a cellular handset by the end of this year, which makes it a more far reaching platform for deploying and playing games.

Over the next ten years he expects to see around 800 million people in these countries achieve the kind of financial stability to be considered middle class and therefore good consumers, and the argument goes that they will have never heard of the PlayStation, the Xbox 360 or Nintendo’s Wii.

In a far shorter time period the applications processors and screens will develop to be good enough to offer PlayStation 1 class games with gigahertz class processing. In effect chips are advancing so that the Smart Phone of today in the western world, will be the processing basis of the phones subsidized by operators, in the next few years, in poorer parts of the world.

This continual higher resetting of the minimum baseline of technology in phones is what will fundamentally drive these devices to become the mass market computer of the future, as well as a viable GEC in emerging markets.

Yuen also believes that the wireless format lends itself to episodic game development, so that publishers can develop a level of a game, put it out there to get revenues, and then use the money to develop the next level, etc.. keeping down their cost of development from the $10 million to $20 million they are rapidly becoming on today’s gaming consoles.

The phone can of course become “peripheralized” with a USB or wireless USB port allowing the attachment of video game controllers, keyboards, and a mouse, effectively turning them into computers. But here he must run right into the full might of Intel, whose lifeblood is at stake and which is developing palm sized full PCs, which of course will have phones put in them at some stage.

Yuen points out that India is a prime example of the potential for the GEC, and demographically representative of many other emerging markets. India, has one billion people, but an installed base of just 200,000 video game consoles. High import duties conspire against low pricing and much hardware is sold through black market retailers, and much software is pirated on ‘chipped’ devices.

Though there are 50 million PCs in India, only four million of these are in households and only one million are used for gaming. And once again much of the software is pirated. So essentially India is a market of over one billion people with virtually no games revenues.

Yuen’s argument is that handsets have always worried about security and are perfectly well equipped to offer downloaded games with cellular delivered secret decryption keys. For consoles to move towards being online devices this means more investment is needed in telephone lines and other communication infrastructure, plus more expensive consoles. And this point we have argued ourselves, no-one is going to put fixed lines of copper in the ground any more not when mobile voice will erode any voice revenues that were previously guaranteed.

So India can’t become a second hand market for the PlayStation, and it suffers from piracy, even if it offers a cheap enough $80 PS2.

Already the PS2 is down to around a $120 and it will descend to the point where it is cheaper than a handset, but not to the consumer that gets a free subsidized handset. And anyway, consoles still have this inherent piracy problem.

And given that India is now the world’s second fastest growing wireless market behind China, with customers signing up at the rate of 5 million per month, this is the perfect platform to target for gaming.

Already there mobile gaming is ahead of console and PC gaming by a factor of two and once the GEC (good enough console) picks up momentum, the wireless industry, in the form of Nokia’s new N-Gage in every phone initiative, and Qualcomm’s gaming group that Yuen heads, will chase and expand this opportunity once they get a reasonable revenue base to protect.

We have some problems with this scenario, because it posits that the handset makers can integrate games, but doesn’t allow for the other way around. Obviously Sony Ericsson is in a great position to integrate Sony games, and continue to lead the way in this area, if it decides to try, bringing all that Sony software to the party.

Secondly companies like Apple and Microsoft are heading unerringly towards both handheld gaming devices and the cellphone, so they can be part of this convergence too. And although that doesn’t defeat the arguments, it adds a corollary, which is that someone like Nintendo could integrate its gaming, which is built around an IBM chip, by the inclusion of the same chip into a handset (what about all that Nintendo handheld gaming content on an iPod phone from Apple using either an Intel or IBM chip ‘ scary or what?).

Apple and Microsoft both understand the requirements needed in a general purpose operating system, which can turn its hand to any task, and they are dangerous rivals to be entering a market, even for a company as confident as Qualcomm. Microsoft has already made a fight of the console market and we know it is heading for a merger between its Zune MP3 player and a handheld gaming device. Last stop the phone.

Qualcomm itself has never really courted the low end handset markets of India and China, at least not in the way that Motorola and Nokia have, and their chip supplier in Texas Instruments, but there’s nothing to prevent that from changing.

However the recent release of Qualcomm’s Snagdragon architecture, which can offer an application processor for a non-handset device, seems to suggest that Qualcomm is looking in another direction ‘ instead of integrating more on to a single device, it seems like it now has an architecture where it can make devices which are NOT handsets, such as gaming consoles.

Granted the Snapdragon might become that common architecture for gaming with both non-handset and handset versions ‘ but then Yuen’s points about piracy go out the window, if his company offers a device which doesn’t have its own secure network element in-built for gaming distribution.

Perhaps Yuen’s time frame is right, and this is a ten year war, and along the way there will be all sorts of hybrids, mobile TV dedicated devices which are NOT handsets, merging with gaming devices which are not handsets, and finally the entire multi function device coming together.

Now before we get the same long list of comments about ‘I’ll never give up my Xbox, PS3, Wii, etc.. to play games on a tiny screen,’ we must understand that the capability to play games on the move, will also be accompanied by the capability of playing out those same games on a nearby large screen. The point before about video, is that the handset is becoming powerful enough to drive a High Definition TV, and the same is true in gaming.

So you CAN play the games on the move, and then slot the device into a docking station attached to your TV to play full screen, or better still, have them wirelessly connected and just using web services to ‘discover’ each other.

If you add the fact that the handset is gradually becoming the universal remote control, as well as a device that records your activity, and acts as a payment vehicle, some form of gaming aspect is almost inevitable.

Perhaps in this future, the PS3 acts as the home hub for gaming, but it accepts remote commands from a handset and can upload some games to it, and allow it to act as a controller, and perhaps the large drive on the gaming console or a DVR can act as an automatic back up for the handset.

And the beauty of all of this is that no-one has to buy one, they simply have to sign a contract with a cellular operator.