Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2005

The Long Tail begins its Long Goodbye

Even Faultline, which has been pointing out the idea for the past two years, had to bow to the originality of the expression ‘The long tail’ coined by Wired editor in chief Chris Anderson last year.

Now it appears that the expression is causing more irritation than enlightenment, as every business plan looking for funding has taking up the cry and misused the expression, according to a piece in the NY Times.

The concept is simple. If a bookshop had 10,000 different titles it would waste huge amounts of shelf space on titles that hardly sold. But if an online service has the same number of titles, it finds that it sells at least one of everything in stock most months. This is caused by the bigger reach and especially the smaller overhead of keep a film, or MP3 track in stock on an online service.

The initial examples all came from the observation by Anderson that even the oldest, most obscure tracks on music services were downloaded regularly, despite the fact that the physical CD’s have been out of production for some years.

Faultline has argued that the same thing will inevitably apply to film and TV services and that by putting 1,000s of films available on file download film services, or on VoD systems, their usage will rise substantially. And when we saw this explained as the ‘Long Tail,’ we immediately began using the expression.

It appears we are not the only ones, although some have not been using it quite so accurately, and apparently Google used the concept in its own IPO presentations.

The result is that venture capitalists have been complaining that the concept is used wrongly to explain ‘why we are cool’ and the original meaning has been diluted to the point where few can remember what it is.

It would be a shame to see this expression used wrongly to the point of it being lost, because it is a genuine difference between atoms and bits (to use Nicholas Negroponte’s contribution to understanding being digital). Atoms of course take up space, and the more copies of something you need, the more space you take up. Whereas bits or binary digits take up a tiny piece of disk memory and can be duplicated at will. Which is WHY people do not stock a ten year old CD, but why they can stock a ten year old MP3.