House of Cards cost Netflix $100 million to fund and because it has a major OTT video business, most estimates say that it has already pushed about that amount of money back into the business from it. So we’re not entirely sure how the business envisaged by AT&T and The Chernin group, which seems to be funded at around $500 million for now, plans to go about competing in the OTT video market, but that’s one story floating around this week.
How will that happen? Will it require a financial leg up from AT&T? Does it need to turn that $500 million into say’ $3 billion, in order to have any chance at all?
If its efforts so far are anything to go by, then it is unlikely to achieve very much ‘ so far the 2006 start-up Crunchyroll is one of the company’s few investments, which offers Anime and Manga video from Japanese TV, for sale online in the US.
CEO Peter Chernin has already tried to buy Hulu for $500 million, so we know exactly what he sees as being able to work ‘ TV programs that are already out there, being delivered through a license, over the open internet. In other worlds Hulu all over again. Crunchyroll is little more than a trans-national version of the same. Hulu itself has content that has already been sold internationally, which makes this kind of cross national fertilization out of the question for Hulu.
Chernin is a shrewd operator and ran News Corp for a number of years under the chairmanship of Rupert Murdoch. He knows where all the content is buried, and how much all of it costs. But the challenge for him is to get his hands on content that is not deriving all of its revenues from conventional routes to market, which OTT delivery would upset.
If you offer a new partner a $100 million for some content, then it just doesn’t work for him if the rest of his clients either a) insist on paying less or b) stop carrying it AT ALL and pay nothing. That’s the conundrum of all OTT start-ups and the only way that Netflix got around this was because initially it already had a business and secondly its online delivery was thought at first to be just a novelty and unlikely to work. And then it still almost fumbled that ball when it adjusted its pricing from online for free to online costs a mere $8.
Amazon did much the same thing, slowly offering online video as mostly free as part of Amazon Prime, a free delivery promise that was probably throwing off lots of spare cash, and which could afford it.
In order to compete with a company like Netflix, Chernin needs access to content, he needs an existing service in place with all the organizational bells and whistles of billing and delivery infrastructure and a sales or promotional process. He at least needs a major customer base. And he needs to be able to acquire content for the same price as Netflix and yet offer it for less than Netflix. The price of entry into this market has gone far higher than anyone expected and it is way more than $500 million.
We don’t think for a minute that AT&T will part with any money in the manner than Verizon has already, and is contemplating further, chasing content. But what it may have done is offer a relationship to Chernin so that he can boast that he at least has a route to market through the AT&T mobile service. There could be some kind of equity participation for AT&T if and only if such a service takes off, and we’re pretty sure AT&T would reserve its right NOT to allow the service full home page access to its apps, phones and privileged access across its network, if it doesn’t think it would work out.
And given that Chernin has sold part of his operation to private equity group Providence Equity Partners and that he has the founder of China’s YouTube equivalent Youku (since merged with Tudou) on board, he sees the deal as more of a global content, US network tie up, a way of bringing content from China and other countries to the US.
This looks weak and it really looks like he’ll end up with a series of ex-pat content deals for the Chinese abroad. We would never expect Chernin to fail to make money, but we would also not expect this particular deal to upset the OTT applecart in the US ‘ however it develops.