Last week we looked at how video gaming has evolved from its origins to the present day. Now we’ll look at what the $62 billion industry comprises, before looking at where it seems to be heading and the most likely changes in the pipeline.
Video gaming has never been so pervasive. Every web browser, every smartphone, all the games consoles, even set tops ‘ these are all the devices that a consumer can use to play games today, and it’s a list that is likely only to keep growing.
And the types of games played are incredibly varied, ranging from colorful Tetris imitations, to increasingly photo-realistic sports simulators and first person shooters ‘ the former more prevalent in web browsers and mobile devices, with the hardware-intensive latter found on the likes of consoles and PCs.
The most obvious difference between the two flavors is the business model, with the more casual games embracing the freemium approach (see last week for more detail) while the consoles and PCs stick more closely to the traditional business model of selling the platform and the individual games to the consumer for an upfront fee.
But that’s not to say that there aren’t paid-for games on the mobile side of things. On the contrary, developers frequently offer an advert-free version of a game for a small fee, and the micro-transaction model of paying small sums for exclusive items or character ‘skins’ (clothes, hair colors, etc.) shows no sign of going away.
Micro-transactions have also been embraced by the larger publishing houses in the consoles and PC spheres, with the likes of Electronic Arts and Activision frequently supplementing their titles with additional downloadable content (DLC, formerly referred to as Expansions). For a fee, these DLC packs add new levels, weapons and abilities to the game, which are crucially not available to gamers who still pay the full retail price at launch. In order to have access to every feature of a flagship game at launch, a gamer may have to pay the standard $60 for the game itself and anywhere between $5-60 for the DLC.
In recent years, the gaming media and public have become increasingly hostile to the practice of selling ‘zero day’ DLC and pre-order exclusives for games ‘ which flies in the face of the traditional approach of releasing a game and sometimes following it up after a year or two with one or two DLC expansions to extend the life of the game, or else with a full-blown sequel, pending financial success.
Due to this practice, the business model for the largest console and PC game publishers has created a market for games from independent developers, often financed through crowdfunding websites. Prior to the advent of crowdfunding’s popularity, it was much harder for an indie-dev to publish a game without the support of one of the major players. Now, indie games are frequently in the top ten lists of bestselling PC games, while slowly gaining entry into the console markets. Arguably the biggest indie game of the last decade is the phenomenon Minecraft ‘ which many non-gamers are familiar with. This is a title that successfully transitioned from PC to consoles.
These indie games often fill niches that their backers feel are not being served by the larger developers ‘ largely due to the huge amount of money invested in the development of each iteration of ‘Call of Duty’ or ‘Battlefield,’ with advertising budgets frequently eclipsing the development costs. The tens and sometimes hundreds of millions of dollars spent per title seems to encourage conservatism at the expense of innovation. A game like Minecraft ‘ colorful, child friendly, non-linear in terms of its gameplay, open ended, a gigantic ‘sandbox’ for you to play in ‘ would not have come from the big players in the industry due to their conservatism, and Minecraft has gone on to become one of the bestselling titles in history, while the likes of Call of Duty have become the butt of many jokes and the targets of a lot of resentment due to their increasingly unfriendly pricing tactics of micro-transactions and DLC.
And so it’s a strange circumstance that in the more serious flavor of video gaming that a crowdfunded game project presents the fact that you actually have to pay for it as a selling point ‘ such is the level of resentment for what freemium games have done to what was a vibrant industry that is now stagnating under the weight of free to play, day-one and pre-order DLC, and wave after wave of franchise installments at the expense of new titles coming to market. But the same argument can be made about the overwhelming selection of games in the mobile app stores. Gaming feels increasingly like a game of finding a needle in a haystack.
The video gaming industry as a whole is roughly split into two distinct strands ‘ mobile gaming and what we’ll term static gaming. As our naming scheme suggests, mobile gaming is gaming on the go, on devices that let you play regardless of location. This predominantly incorporates offline games played from local storage on the device, but could also include purely cloud-based gaming using an internet connection (more on that later) as well as traditional games with an online element.
Static gaming is the opposite of mobile. This term will be used to describe gaming that takes place on hardware that can’t easily be moved around in a daily routine i.e. consoles, desktop PCs, set tops, smart TVs. As we discussed last week, static gaming has the longer history, as mobile gaming has only really taken off after improvements in hardware brought the experience up from the likes of Snake and Tetris to games that can offer a console-like experience.
Traditionally, the console and PC experiences have been much more technically complex than their mobile counterparts, but the newer entrants into the static gaming ecosystem (low-computational power smart TVs and set tops) have warped the view that static games are guaranteed to be more visually impressive and immersive experiences than mobile gaming. You can now play Angry Birds on a smartphone, Apple TV, Roku, TiVo, Xfinity X1 ‘ the list goes on.
Amazon’s new Fire TV net top appears to be selling itself as a genuine alternative to a console, with the backing of an Amazon-owned gaming studio that is developing exclusive games for the platform, as well as its $970 million purchase of Twitch.tv ‘ a web site where viewers can watch others play games and participate in live chats. Although we doubt that the net top is going to steal market share from the established players, the gaming element could be the difference between the purchase of an Apple TV or the Fire TV.
But despite the ubiquity of smartphones and the improved mobile gaming experience, the latest generation of consoles appear to be performing well in the market ‘ with Sony the clear winner in the early stages of the latest console war.
Sony has just announced that its PS4 has sold 10 million units worldwide, jumping from 7 million sold in April. It’s also rolling out version 2.0 of the console’s firmware which will introduce the Share Play feature, which allows a user to invite a friend to join their game online even if the friend does not own their own copy of the game ‘ otherwise known as cloud gaming.
The requirement to use this service is only that the friend is a PlayStation Plus subscriber ‘ Sony’s $10 monthly subscription for online gaming on the PS4, which includes access to a changing selection of games each month and cloud storage features. There are still a number of unknowns regarding other restrictions, including whether only digital purchases will count or if physical discs will be included too, but this service moves gaming from the home into the cloud.
This is actually a very similar mechanism to one that Microsoft intended to introduce with its own next gen console, the Xbox One. However, a bungled launch announcement process, combined with the decision to bypass physical disc sales in favor of digital distribution of game licenses tied to individual user accounts, meant that the Xbox One’s game-sharing functionality was pulled before it ever arrived.
In its original vision, a user would have been able to share their library of games with friends and family members on the condition that the console would phone home to an authentication server daily. If the connection couldn’t be made, the games would be unplayable to the user. In the prerelease news cycle, the gaming press focused more on the need to phone home or face being locked out of the console than the new ability to share one game with many friends. Combined with Microsoft’s ill-advised decision to premier the console to the world as a media center for the living room instead of as a primarily gaming focused machine led many journalists to suggest that Microsoft had lost its way. In comparison to the straightforward PlayStation 4, the Xbox One with its all-seeing Kinect eye that could follow users was a step too far. Consequently, Xbox One sales have rapidly fallen behind Sony’s machine.
This has led Microsoft to scrap the mandatory bundling of a Kinect with the Xbox, and to slash the price of the console by $100 to bring it in line with the PS4. Initially declaring that the Kinect was integral to the Xbox One experience, this backpedalling has led many stock market analysts to float the idea that Microsoft will eventually offload the Xbox decision ‘ an idea that they believe is given credence due to new CEO Satya Nadella’s regime change, which also saw Microsoft axe its Xbox Entertainment Studios which was established to produce video exclusive content for the platform. Every revision Microsoft has made to the Xbox One has been to refocus it towards purely video gaming, a priority Sony never really deviated from. Microsoft somewhat bungled reinventing the wheel.
Microsoft’s new console is only shifting 60,000 units a week ‘ half the amount that Sony sells. So while the number of PS4s in the wild is now upwards of 10 million, Microsoft still won’t release up to date sales figures. We know it has shipped upwards of 5 million units to retailers as of April, and has also just secured a distribution deal with the Chinese government which allows 5 million of the consoles into the country at a price tag of $600. Whether this can help the console leapfrog the PS4 remains to be seen, but it seems that a conservative estimate puts the number of Xbox One’s in consumer homes at around 5 million.
Microsoft has also to counter the fact that flagship titles available on both consoles routinely perform at higher frame rates and resolutions on the PS4 thanks to its more powerful hardware. Poor sales and lower performance could be the thin wedge-end of a developer exodus to Sony in the long run ‘ especially as upgrading the hardware design would most likely compromise the performance of previous games that have been coded to run on the exact hardware quirks of the console. This makes it very tricky for Microsoft to simply upgrade the platform’s performance without endangering its existing content library.
But this generation of consoles could well be the last of their breed. Their business model has depended on selling a console, often at a loss against the Bill of Materials costs and making profits over the life of the console, through software (game) sales. Cutting out the hardware would drastically improve the margins, and moving to a cloud gaming and streaming model would allow the companies to provide much less expensive hardware, if any at all, and perhaps even move to a subscription model such as Netflix ‘ or the cloud gaming brands OnLive and the recently acquired Sony subsidiary Gaikai.
All that is really needed for this Share Play experience is a solid internet connection, a game controller pad and a screen. But this model of monthly subscriptions to play games via the cloud is one that could prove the death knell for consoles. Both OnLive and Gaikai functionality is available in smart TVs, and the local processing requirement for this kind of system is much cheaper to integrate than something like a console or PC ‘ that is to say, that this approach could make video gaming a screen/hardware agnostic experience.
The rapid improvement in the potential quality and performance of mobile gaming has come about because mobile hardware has improved rapidly over the course of the last few years. Future advances in cloud computing and streaming could easily put the mobile gaming experience on par with static versions. The basic premise of cloud gaming is that the physical and graphical computational processing and rendering is performed in the cloud before being sent to the mobile device ‘ thus removing the hardware constraints and requirements from the device and moving them almost entirely into the cloud.
The benefits of these platforms are, however, entirely dependent on the quality and latency of the internet connection between the cloud and the end user device. Given the well-documented trouble that Netflix has had providing its customers with a reliable stream for its content, cloud gaming as a viable mass market product is currently hindered by the bandwidth and latency requirements, and apparently the whims of the ISPs too. These requirements could also prove a bottleneck on cellular connections or even through WiFi connections on public networks.
If it can provide a satisfactory experience, cloud gaming is poised to be revolutionary for the entire industry. Both the cloud-gaming services have received favorable reviews, with only occasional problems with latency and frame rates. Graphical quality was limited to a 720p resolution, with some of the faster paced games suffering from poor video compression. But if the technology and internet connection improves, could this model signal the demise of hardware and the rise of the cloud gaming experience?
That question will be answered in the last installment at this look at the video game market. Next week we will look at gaming’s wider impact on other markets, including Amazon’s move to buy Twitch.tv, the emergence of the subscription model, new approaches to hardware, and likely future trends in the industry.