Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 June 2006

There’s more than one way to do Picture in Picture says Optibase

We said when we visited last year’s IBC Conference in Amsterdam that if the rest of the IPTV market had not caught up with Microsoft, at least in its capabilities for picture in picture and mosaic interfaces, by the time the next IBC came around, then it would be game over for the entire community.

A full three months early and encoder company Optibase is touting a new picture in picture capability in a totally different manner from other encoder companies Harmonic, Tandberg, Scientific Atlanta and Motorola which were developed based on doing all the work at the encoder, compressing multiple and separate sized streams of each TV channel.

Optibase demonstrated a system at GlobalComm last week and said it is still working on it with IPTV system and set-top box vendor UTStarcom to bring true Picture-in-Picture capabilities to IPTV services, and it has no idea of when it would be ready to ship, but it claims to have attacked the problem in a way that doesn’t rely on additional hardware at the Telco headend.

The Optibase and UTStarcom PiP solution works on the client side set top box opening up two or more channels at once, choosing the channels they want to see and how they want to see them. The service is not limited to certain channels or sizes that have already been pre-configured at the head end, as with previous IPTV PiP options.

The way most encoder companies have managed this is for more processing power to be supplied at the head end usually in the form of DSP chips, and new images of each channel in quarter sized screen and in thumbprint size being produced at the same time as the full sized channel. This doesn’t really need much in the way of extra hardware, and the set top just has to position multiple feeds on the screen, but once those sizes are selected, that’s all you can have.

This has largely been seen as the way ahead, with any system working at the set top thought to requiring more bandwidth to get the channels there and more processing power once it arrives to resolve two full sized channels at the same time, and to then shrink them to fit.

Optibase said its system allows quad splits (screen split in four) locating PiP in different corners, resizing the screens, plus the ability to do a video mosaic of up to 16 video feeds on one screen.

Part of the system’s capabilities is down to the increased compression that H.264 codecs have given Optibase, which allows a TV service to be delivered in about 2.5 times less bandwidth than with MPEG 2, but on its own this couldn’t be enough.

“This announcement represents an evolutionary step in set-top box technology and IPTV service offerings, where IPTV operators can introduce more options for services that match those of competing providers,” said Adam Schadle, president of Optibase. “With Optibase and UTStarcom’s solution, users can have every channel on PiP, matching the level of functionality that consumers expect. This is a fundamentally different approach to PiP and provides a stepping stone for future developments.”

It may well be that this will only work on the bandwidth rich environments that UTS Starcom is used to working in, where in some Asia Pacific countries 50 Mbps lines are commonplace, but bandwidth wasn’t mentioned in the announcement.

“As our set-top box technology has evolved and become more advanced and powerful with the addition of the latest browser, middleware technology and chipsets, we can enable rich Internet applications and more complex set-top box based applications such as true PiP,” said Brian Caskey, Vice President Worldwide Marketing, UTStarcom Inc. “This approach to PiP can give users more control over the channels that are available to them.” We’ll try to get Optibase to explain this in detail soon.