Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

Thinkbox twists BARB data and ‘voila’ ‘ Isn’t TV doing well?

There is a report out this week from Thinkbox, suggesting that the TV as a device and in particular linear TV services, are still representing 98.5% of all viewing. Be careful not to be taken in by this report, Thinkbox a paid apologist for UK TV, originally pulled together by most of the vested interests in broadcast TV – Channel 4, Five, GMTV, Sky Media, IDS, ITV, Turner Media Innovations, Viacom Brand Solutions. Since then internal wrangling has meant that IDS is no longer a member.

The key claim that research issued this week by Thinkbox makes is that 98.5% of TV was watched on a TV set in the UK in 2013. Now we ALL know that’s not true, purely intuitively, so all that remains to be seen is how this TV apology group has lied using statistics.

The data comes from BARB, Broadcasters Audience Research Board and if you go to its web site and look up Weekly viewing figures, you see that kind of shape you expect everywhere, mostly showing TV viewing decline. So in this interpretation, black really is White.

The 2012 line of viewing hours per week is higher throughout the year than 2013, for something like 43 weeks out of 52. So 2013 viewing HAS to be disappointing. In 2014 so far, the average TV viewing hours per week is closer to 28 hours than last year’s 30. Anyone who is not biased, stupid or corrupt knows that tablet viewing is on the surge and that PC and Smartphone viewing is on the surge and this is having some impact. There were around 50 pieces we found that just repeated the Thinkbox party line (perhaps we should call it the not-think Box).

We spent 20 minutes in the office talking about how to spell the world ‘denier’ you know those people that ‘deny’ something that is shown to be obviously true, like people who think we did not land on the moon, that Darwin’s theory of evolution is entirely wrong and that car fumes do NOT cause global warming. We found that the dictionary has no such word and we realized why ‘ people that deny the march of time never have a voice for very long ‘ so no-one has to call them anything, because they rapidly become irrelevant. Turns out that a denier is a unit of weight to measure nylons ‘ go figure.

So we will re-iterate our thoughts at Faultline. The TV is rapidly dying a both a linear service and a device. There will be no replacements for second and third TV devices in the US now, and in Europe shortly, as people will instead find they can buy a tablet and it has many other applications. We also feel that over time the rate at which large TV sets are replaced will slow, due to fewer points of differentiation and enhanced viewing experiences on the tablet and PC.

Which perhaps explains why in December, on Boxing day in the UK more people accessed the BBC iPlayer on tablets than computers for the first time and by New Year’s day there were 11 million program requests from iPlayer (from all those tablet Christmas presents).

So when Thinkbox tells us that only 1.5% of TV viewing was on screens other than TV sets, we have to point out that by TV it obviously means TV programs being broadcast now, rather than TV programs that are being watched in catch up ‘ it must do because otherwise the numbers do not compute.

Otherwise what about the more than 2 million Sky Go viewers that have popped up in the last few years, or the millions of iPlayer requests or the 2 million TiVo customers at Virgin?

Presumably the 2 million Netflix customers are also being put down as watching TV? And yet this programming is not being shown on UK broadcast TV. Perhaps Thinkbox counts it as viewing on a TV set, supporting the Thinkbox view that everything is watched on a TV? It’s hard to tell because it does not break out its calculations.

The point is that Thinkbox didn’t think to release its methodology and we challenge it to do so, so that people can examine what’s really going on in UK TV viewing instead of having this pre-digested pap thrown at them.

Thinkbox said that the average viewer watched just over 3 hours, 55 minutes of TV a day during 2013, that commercial TV increased share of linear viewing from 66% to 68% (so even less for its broadcaster members).

And the number of adverts we all watch went up (that is, not down) by 1.6% over 2012; up by growth of 10.4% over the last five years. How this is measured while the number of DVRs rises, especially Sky Plus, FreeView, Virgin TiVo boxes and the new YouView DVRs, is patent nonsense. Hands up if you are the ONLY person that has one of these, but does not skip adverts?

The rise in tablet and smartphone viewing went up from 1.2% last year to 1.5%, Thinkbox said, amounting to 3 minutes 30 seconds each day via devices such as tablets, smartphones and laptops (or just over 3 half-hour TV shows a month).

So that 11 million people viewing on New Year’s day is going to come as a huge surprise because it will be about a month’s worth of non-TV viewing, happening on the first day of 2014.

Instead Thinkbox said that TV viewing remains strong with the average viewer watching 12 minutes more TV a day in 2013 than ten years ago. But it fails to mention that 10 years ago we had 4 analog channels, a fraction of the pay TV customers and Virgin was two US bankrupt cable companies.

And Thinkbox’s reason that viewing was down on 2012 was because we had such good weather in 2013 (so the first quarter of 2014 will surely have HUGE viewing figures, since it has rained every day). It also said there were no significant sporting events in 2013, so once again, viewing figures for the first quarter of 2014, with the Sochi Olympics will be astronomical ‘ except that BARB shows them to be down on 2013, despite these two facts. The World Cup perhaps will saving the 2014 viewing figures as far as Thinkbox is concerned.

BARB has taken to measuring TV viewing on a TV set that takes place between 8-28 days after broadcast. If this viewing is included in the total it adds an extra 2 minutes per person per day, taking total daily viewing to 3 hours, 57 minutes. Still down.

Instead of claiming that the TV set remains at the heart of viewing, Thinkbox should employ Faultline to help them understand that TV is not a device, it is a concept of how programming is made, delivered, paid for and consumed, and that the tablet is their friend, not their enemy, and its members should embrace it.

But vested interests cannot help themselves. Nielsen has repeatedly changed the way it adds up its viewing figures, so that it can manipulate the number to rise higher, not fall lower in its US figures. The truth is that this is the golden age of TV series making ‘ ten years ago we had only just embarked on $1 billion series like 24 and Desperate Housewives, and yet today there are more $1 billion TV franchises than ever before. This is because the Movie Industry has turned to global appeal from US appeal, and creates repeat monster blockbusters that rely more on CGI than acting and which can never show China or Russia as the bad guys anymore, because that’s their biggest audiences. US actors, writers and producers have swarmed into TV like never before, to its benefit.

However their next stop is to swarm into ‘original productions’ for Netflix, Hulu Plus and Amazon and You Tube, and it will be hard to see that as TV. Unless Thinkbox wants to twist the facts.

And the BARB figures are strong for pay TV. The average person watched 2 hours, 33 minutes of commercial TV a day. And claims that Time-shifted TV viewing only accounts for 1% of TV. Well I can confirm that my household has not watched an advert since we got TiVo, so we must be one in a hundred.

Additionally says Thinkbox, 81% of all timeshifted viewing is watched within two days of recording, and 47% of it is seen within 24 hours of it being recorded. So basically the ads are still relevant is what it is trying to say.

It also says that BARB’s figures suggest that the growth in the amount of TV that is recorded and played back is slowing down. What from 100% to 98%?

At the end of its release Thinkbox says that BARB’s figures do not yet include TV viewed on devices other than TV sets. What? I hear you ask.

So those figures are supplied by Thinkbox’s notably unbiased UK TV broadcasters, which shows perhaps why this only comes out at an average of 3 minutes, 30 seconds.

And the last straw is that Smart TVs are of course good news for the move away from tablets and smartphones, since some content that was NOT viewed on a TV will be viewed on a Smart TV, so back on the TV. Thinkbox knew all along that the tablet and smartphone was only a fad, and everyone is coming home to the TV.

Lindsey Clay, Thinkbox’s Chief Executive, is quote saying, ‘New screens are making TV even more convenient for viewers and creating new opportunities for advertisers. But, the more we learn, the clearer it becomes that the TV set will remain our favorite way to watch TV ‘ especially as on-demand services become more available on the best screen.’

We all like to embrace the status quo, it makes us feel comfortable, but the person who wrote this release needs help understanding that TV is changing dramatically for the better, and this is to be applauded, not ignored.