French consumer electronics group Thomson is in a fight over royalties surrounding the patents of MP3. It has received suits in the US from Audio MPEG and in Germany and Italy from Sisvel Spa, the Italian MP3 patent licensing authority that acts for France Telecom, Philips, and IRT (Institut fur Rundfunktechnik) who both own some of the MP3 patents.
Thomson owns other patents that are contributed to MP3 and acts as the licensing authority for the Fraunhofer Institute in Germany (another co-inventor of mp3) and Coding Technologies from Sweden which has helped develop MP3PRO, an advance on MP3 and also for Agere Systems, which helped develop MP3 Surround, another advance on MP3. Thomson has been licensing MP3 since 1995.
What began as a negotiating tactic seems to have blown up into a full scale legal action with Thomson’s renegotiations continuing past the due date for a new agreement and Sisvel resorting to surprising legal action.
Now Thomson has filed counter suits with the German Federal Patent court and in the US and also in Sweden.
The patents are used in MP3 players, DVD players, CD players and digital set-top boxes and customs officials have now impounded some Thomson products because the Thomson license fee lapsed in 2005.
Thomson sounded mostly embarrassed about the situation and it looks like the two sides will now go into a huddle and settle a new royalty agreement to diffuse the situation. Clearly is was just a disagreement over price.
In the end we reckon that virtually no money will change hands because Thomson manages more patents than it pays royalties on.
Thomson is clearly moving the onus further down the line by increasing its own MP3 licensing costs, and has had a reaction from Chinese and Taiwanese MP3 chip makers, upset at a royalty rise to $0.75 per MP3 player.