Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 July 2006

Thomson lifts lid on digital cinema piracy defense techniques

According to MIT’s Technology Review, Thomson has a plan that will block piracy from camcorders being used to re-film blockbusters movies from inside cinemas.

The system works by inserting extra frames that are invisible to the naked eye, but which are picked up by a camcorder and are reproduced. These extra frames can either contain text such as the world ‘Illegal copy,’ which then show all over the film or obscure the scene.

We have always been skeptical that camcorders used from the front row of a cinema were creating any of the huge piracy claimed by the US Motion Picture Association of America, but the MPAA is fairly convinced this is the worst form of piracy it faces. It targets films at their earliest point in the release cycle and has the potential to cause most harm.

We would have thought that handshakes and poor visual and sound quality would have ruined this approach to piracy anyway and that the analog hole once DVDs are released and piracy from within film organizations, were far more dangerous.

Thomson explained to Technology Review that its technology involves inserting “artifacts” — extra frames, flashes of light, or pixelated grid patterns — into a movie during its digital-processing phase, before it’s shipped to theatres.

The entire process is built around doing things that a human brain cannot pick up, but a camcorder can. Thomson is working on a number of techniques and says that the most promising so far is the use of extra frames with the words “illegal copy,” inserted. The defense will only work with high speed digital projectors.

Film projectors work at 48 frames a second with 24 frames each flashed twice. Camcorders take a series of instantaneous snapshots collecting many more frames per second than human eyes. A camcorder could theoretically be set to avoid the frames with writing on, but a system which randomly changes the frequency of such frames can then be built to defend against this workaround.

Of course the re-digitized file from the camcorder could probably be manually cleaned of the ‘illegal copy’ frames, but might leave the file jerky with some frames missing. A bit like the handshake from the original recording.

Thomson said it is also working on playing ultraviolet over the screen to wash out camcorder pictures, but this can be beaten with a series of filters
Again Thomson is trying out things like varying the wavelength of the interfering light form, to beat simple filtering.

The Thomson work is just at the research stage and no time frame for introducing the technology has yet been suggested.