Are unlimited data plans driving mobile-first streaming or are the rise of OTT video services driving the popularity of unlimited data plans? Either way, so-called unlimited packages have made limiting mobile data usage a necessity for MNOs, with Comcast the latest to be the bearer of bad news for mobile streaming fanatics.
The Xfinity Mobile MVNO venture, piggybacking on Verizon’s network, will soon be reducing video quality from 720p to 480p when streaming content via mobile data. Of course it tries to use WiFi offload most of the time. Once unlimited Xfinity subscribers exceed their 20GB monthly data caps, download speeds are restricted to 1.5Mbps and upload 750Kbps, while streaming over WiFi will remain unchanged as standard. In addition, “if you have the unlimited data option, your speeds on any device connected to a personal hotspot will not exceed 600Kbps,” Comcast told customers.
Comcast says new video throttling regulations will help keep the overall price of mobile packages low, which really means reducing the network fees it pays to Verizon. Comcast’s cap ironically comes as net neutrality is guided, bloody and bruised from the doors of FCC headquarters – a repeal which specifically banned throttling but attempting to hide the facts by calling stream restrictions “network management” processes, is not fooling anyone.
“To help you conserve data, we’ve established 480p as the standard resolution for streaming video through cellular data. This can help you save money if you pay by the gig and take longer to reach the 20GB threshold if you have the unlimited data option,” Comcast said in an email to subscribers. This is pretty much exactly what T-Mobile did in the US and had companies like Comcast wagging a finger at it.
As it stands, subs can ask Comcast for an upgrade to stream 720p resolution content without incurring additional charges, until later this year when “720p video over cellular data will be available as a fee-based option with your service.”
There will of course be pockets of frustrated customers, but Comcast has justified its video throttling, claiming almost 50% of content streamed by Xfinity Mobile users is already in 480p resolution. Xfinity Mobile may only be a year old, but it would be interesting to see how demand for higher resolutions has changed, if at all, in such a short time frame.
Verizon has been throttling mobile streaming down to 480p since last year, yet it’s T-Mobile US we consider the trendsetter here, launching its disruptive Binge On streaming platform back in November 2015, allowing subscribers to stream content from popular OTT services without denting data caps, for no extra fee. It reduces video down to 1.5 Mbps when streaming content higher than 480p over its LTE network, which T-Mobile has dressed up as “video optimization” when this is really just a fanciful name for throttling at the network edge.
We last counted 24 services on board Binge On, although over 100 have been reported, including Netflix, HBO Now and Hulu, although the initiative came under fire in early 2016 after allegations it was throttling all HTML5 video streams. Now most major MNOs are throttling all video streams so rights groups such as the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which attacked T-Mobile, have little left to stand on.
Binge On also gives T-Mobile the power to reduce the data footprint of video on the service, setting a maximum for the density of the video that is carried in Binge On over cellular, and also to manage the on-device policy for offloading to WiFi, which happens wherever possible. T-Mobile has zero rated all services and carries the cost of the video data that travels across its network.
As Faultline Online Reporter noted a few months ago, just prior to Xfinity Mobile’s first birthday, the major MNOs weren’t exactly fretting about the entrance of Comcast onto the mobile scene, yet its growth has been steady with subscribers exceeding an estimated 1 million today. The service is projected to close in on 3 million subs by Q3 2019, according to New Street Research.
An unlimited Xfinity Mobile package costs $65 a month for consumers who are not subscribed to its broadband services – and $45 a month to those who are. AT&T and Verizon also have Charter’s Spectrum Mobile and a 2019 MVNO launch from Altice, using Sprint’s network, to think about.
A similar uncarrier model has been rolled out over in India by disruptive MNO Reliance Jio, for its free yet comprehensive video service, so when Jio customers hit their 4G data caps, data used after this is throttled down to 128Kbps, reducing overage charges. It should go without saying that the act of throttling OTT video content on mobile networks will spread like wild fire.
480p may not be the prettiest, but on small smartphone screens the pixels are plenty. Carriers even claim most consumers can’t tell the difference between 480p and higher resolution content.