The rise of the cast dongle spearheaded by Google’s Chromecast is the one notable recent market development in the streaming device market, raising the question of its likely impact on established pay TV. The aggregate market for devices connecting TVs to online content has remained stubbornly flat over the last year, according to the annual ‘What’s TV Worth’ study from Hub Entertainment Research.
This flatness applies to most of the usual suspects, including Roku boxes and Apple TV, as well as the big three in games consoles of Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo, and also Blu-Ray players, with a little variation either side. But Google’s Chromecast stands out as the big riser, followed to a lesser extent by other dongles capable of casting content to TVs from PCs, tablets, smartphones or sundry connected devices.
Google itself first alluded vaguely to Chromecast sales in March 2014 when SVP Sundar Pichai announced that ‘millions’ of the devices had been sold since the July 2013 launch. The actual total was more like a million or two, for while accurate data is elusive we have no reason to dispute greatly the estimate from Parks Associated that total sales over the first year till around early July stood at 3.8 million. This would put Chromecast neck and neck with Roku over that period, also at 3.8 million, leaving Apple TV trailing in third at 2 million.
These figures are driven largely by the US, with Chromecast only arriving in Europe this year. Early signs are that Chromecast sales are taking off nicely there if less explosively than the US, with 100,000 units sold in the first two months in the UK, according to various comments we have heard.
Apple TV will be able to claim for some time that it has the largest installed base of connected TV streaming devices, but that is largely because it has been going the longest, accumulating 20 million sales since its launch in 2007. Roku comes in the middle here, having sold 8 million units since its launch in May 2008.
Apple TV is the biggest recent victim of Google’s assault, although as those Parks Associates’ figures indicate, selling now at a significantly lower rate than in its heyday, a few years ago when Roku offered the only meaningful competition. It is clear now that the dongle poses the greatest immediate threat to these more expensive devices with which it is in direct competition.
After all Chromecast costs $35, little more than a third of the $99 for Apple TV. This does not spell doom for the likes of Apple and Roku themselves in the connected device market, since they too will come out with dongles if that is the way the wind is blowing. In fact Roku already has with its HDMI TV dongle launched in March 2014, priced at $50 so as to offer some competition to Chromecast without cannibalizing its existing box sales too much.
One sub plot here concerns the extent of dongle usage. It was Parks Associates again which came out with a study suggesting the percentage of Chromecast owners that use the device at least once a month to stream video declined from 78% to 73% from Q3 of 2013 to Q1 of 2014. This spurred Google into action with a counter claim at its recent I/O developer conference that the number of minutes of usage of a 7-day active device had increased 40% since Q3 of 2013.
This is clearly comparing apples with oranges, since Parks was looking at monthly usage across all Chromecast devices, while Google zoomed in on those that were online within a given week. Google would not say whether or not the devices it was following constituted just a subset of the total, which would be the case if many people had disconnected their Chromecast sticks completely after an initial flurry of enthusiasm. We think this discrepancy is something of a red herring, since the whole point of the dongle approach is that by offering a low price tag it will entice people to ‘suck it and see’, so that even if only a half of purchasers end up being serious users Google would be well pleased.
The bigger question is the wider impact on pay TV, with one school of thought being that it will be devastating. The real threat comes from OTT in general rather than the dongle in particular. The dongle itself may actually come to the aid of operators by enabling them to come out with compelling entry level offerings that exploit their existing premium programming. This is already being done by Orange with its OrangeCast, giving subscribers access to IPTV as well as OTT content from an HDMI-attachable cast dongle.