Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 November 2014

Why the time is right for a Chinese Netflix

While everyone tries to come to terms with Xiaomi, a Beijing company they’ve never heard of, overnight being the third largest phone maker in the world, according to last month’s IDC phone tracker service, it turns out this company is not standing still counting its bank balance. Now it wants to invade TVs and movies.

While US newspapers all think Apple and Google have the clout and cleverness to do such a thing, why has it never occurred to anyone that a Chinese business, might do the same?

Xiaomi only sold 17.3 million phones during the past quarter, compared to Apple’s 39.3 million and Samsung at more like 78 million, but Xiaomi grew its market at 211% and overtook Lenovo, which now boasts the once proud Motorola, and LG in the bargain. The “other” list also includes such notables as  Huawei and ZTE, two more Chinese businesses who have also been in the top 5 over the past few years.

But there have been a succession of failures among phone companies to get to grips with video content, which is strange, since Apple’s relationship with content is what rocketed it to its huge US smartphone market share. Apple has since failed to repeat its iTunes success by creating real TV channels of its own, while Samsung doesn’t really even have a unified music content option, having said at least 10 years ago that it would go to war with iTunes, a move that has never materialized.

In a way these businesses see the failure that is Sony, a company that bought into both record labels and US studios, as a stern warning that stepping outside of your comfort zone can have harsh consequences. On the other hand given that these segments are what keeps Sony alive, perhaps such diversification is to be encouraged.

So we should at least pause for thought when we hear casually reported by Chinese media, that Xiaomi will invest $1 billion in acquiring TV content, a figure which is not too un-adjacent from the spend which Netflix used to kick-start its own OTT ambitions.

Faultline would like to share some other observations about the global movie industry to help us interpret this. We have talked many times about the way in which Hollywood movies have changed, from taking 80% of their revenue from the US and 20% from the rest of the world, to a point where they now takes 20% from the US and 80% from the rest of the world.

Strangely this is as a direct result of piracy, with an appetite for US movies being acquired as far afield as China, by the process of pirates taking such movies, translating them and putting a local language voice-over on top of the audio in about a 24 hour turnaround.

These US movies, once translated, and bypassing the Chinese censorship rules, finally made sense to the local community. Previously imported US movies through the official channels had the life knocked out of them by clumsy and over-ambitious censure.

But while suddenly the cognoscenti from 1.3 billion people had the movie bug, there was still the problem of censorship to get around. Hollywood had to continue with its production values and continue to promote some form of moral code, but it needed to do it without overt sexuality, without stars that only US people recognized and it had to change its habits and  never make the bad guys Chinese, or Russian or even Korean. They could be Latvian at best, because there are hardly any people in Latvia to upset.

The result has been heavy CGI dominated movies like Godzilla and the Transformers while all the US writing and acting talent fled to work in TV, where they have built complex, repeat format, TV series, which run for 10 years like “24,” and “Desperate Housewives” and “Lost” which have become the templates for future gargantuan TV series.

The latest OTT delivered original content versions of this, such as “House of Cards,” “Breaking Bad,” “Orange is the new Black,” and even “Game of Thrones” are now the common fare of Western TV.

But not all of these are ripe for adoption in the BRIC countries, not least because the actors in many of these stories are complex characters, driven by sociological forces only found in Western Society. OK, House of Cards is about the US political power base, which means it is NOT about the Kremlin or Beijing, but the same corruption can be espied in every government, so some of these translate. But despite the fact that Game of Thrones it not even about this planet, most post-agrarian societies are not yet ready to cope with the sexual themes it contains. In short there is precious little that translates from US TV to Chinese, or South East Asian society. And that has created a vacuum.

What is set up now is the perfect situation for China and surrounding economies to take control of regular TV series, which reflect the everyday problems of mundane life in those countries – complete with home truths, local frustrations and pitfalls which they recognize better than US versions of the same.

China is set up perfectly to create a YouTube or a iTunes or a Netflix that reflects common aspects of life in those societies, which are largely different from the US and Western Europe.

In the same way that Baidu set up in opposition to Google, and Huawei set up in opposition to Ericsson and Alcatel, and Youku Tudou set up to buffer China from YouTube, and AliBaba set up to offer a rival for eBay and Yahoo! and others, the scene is set to build a new Netflix around a device and $1 billion might be enough to do this.

$1 billion in China probably buys what $10 billion buys in the US and that would certainly be enough.

Local coverage sees this as a race to control video programming in China. But it is broader than that and who better to understand this region than a company that has attracted the phone buyers of China and its neighbors even when up against the might of Korea and Apple. The move comes after Alibaba Group executives recently met with Hollywood executives to discuss co-financing movies.

If movies are to be “bigger” than the US, their themes should be dictated by the target communities and what better way to provide influence than to share the financial risk?

Already China is the world’s second-biggest movie market behind the US. The next step is that it should become the world’s biggest movie producer and then begin the process of exporting its talent, the same way that Hollywood has done in the past.

This is what happened with the TV set – China became the biggest importer of TVs, then it became the biggest consumer of CRT TVs, then it took over LCD TV sales and today UHD devices sell more in China than anywhere, and more of them are made in China. Meanwhile China has been the biggest exporter of TV sets for close to 20 years.

There is a big distinction here, in that Hollywood has done a great job of switching to movies with global appeal, while US TV cannot really do that, it would need to invest in a lot of foreign actors, acting out movie themes which were made in the US 50 years ago, and that wouldn’t work. So it’s the turn of Asia Pacific.

We know that Xiaomi is planning an entry into flat TV manufacture, and Sony, Samsung and LG have all tried to provide content direct to these devices.  Xiaomi might sail into Samsung’s territory on the back of original Chinese content, and offer it to both device types, including smartphones and the tablet. Samsung’s failure to chase content these last ten years, may well prove to be its Achilles heel.