Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 May 2006

TiVo dresses up deal as Upfront after Interpublic endorsement

We’re not quite sure just how TiVo’s ad sales can be said to be anything of an Upfront, but that’s what a multi-million dollar deal with Interpublic is being billed as this week.

The Upfront is an annual sales get together in New York to sell advertising on the new seasons’ potential big hit TV series, including both established and new candidates. Something like $15 billion in advertising, one quarter of the year’s take, is sold in two separate Broadcast and Cable Upfronts each year.

The idea is that a new TV series that has yet to establish itself may sell its advertising off cheaply in order to be sure it is earning money, and when it turns into a monster hit, the advertiser has something of a bargain. It’s a nice thought, but TV advertising continues to be top of the pile, in our view, many years after it should have been devalued, and the biggest miracle is that advertising agencies and their clients continue to interest people in the upfront process at all.

There’s one way for the Broadcasting upfront to continue to be $9 billion or better, and that’s to include within it all of the internet advertising that is sold side by side with the TV adverts. That’s pretty much what is set to happen this year, with CBS, Disney, Discovery and NBC all saying that they have wonderful new digital media add-ons to their TV broadcast sales.

“No longer is content just for the television screen,” said Jeff Zucker, CEO at NBC Universal, part of General Electric.

“We’ve put a ton of thought and a ton of effort into the digital world,” Zucker said in his Upfront address this week “We want to be your digital partner.”

VoD also promises to get itself included in a least the cable upfront, with an entirely new revenue stream to count into the upfront total.

But for TiVo this is all artificial. Upfront is a mentality with the advertising agencies and they buy in seasons, so even though TiVo’s new voluntary viewing of advertising is all year round fare, it is being bought in the same frenzy as the upfront, and being announced as such.

The deal is just a discount for Interpublic companies which include Initiative, Magna Global, and Universal McCann and some specialist agencies, in return for promised volume. No doubt that volume will also be included in the final upfront figures, anything to continue the illusion that US broadcast TV is healthy. But it isn’t.

We might just as well include the pre-booked video based revenues of AOL, Google and Yahoo for the coming quarter in the upfront, even though these are the enemies that are diluting the effectiveness of TV by dragging video onto the internet platforms that are already threatening to take TV’s crown as the leading advertising platform on the planet.

Right now internet advertising is only expected to grow around 30% to $15 billion this year globally, whereas TV is already $60 billion of advertising revenue in the US alone. But TV advertising measured in real terms is shrinking in the US and only growing elsewhere, in places were TV penetration is rising.

Tom Rogers, President and CEO of TiVo said, “TiVo offers an interactive advertising solution that enables the consumer to pause television and engage in a branded advertising experience, without missing even a second of the TV show a viewer is watching. We are excited to expand our long-standing relationship with Interpublic and look forward to capitalizing on their intellectual capital, experience and relationships in the future.”

From TiVo’s point of view the news was seen to be good, shifting TiVo’s share price higher by a few percentage points, in what has been a long term recovery since it crashed when it first announced that DirecTV would stop pushing its DVR, last Summer. Since then it has renegotiated some continued TiVo involvement at DirecTV and TiVo has cut a deal with Comcast for more advanced DVR advertising and it has won a patent infringement legal action against EchoStar, all of which has served to right its share value.