Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 April 2006

TiVo gets huge upsurge on EchoStar win, DirecTV extension

We believe that when all the dust settles on the matter of just who owns what intellectual property in the digital video recorder space, that TiVo will either be worth in excess of $2 billion or it will be out of business.

The two related stories this week seem to imply that the outcome will be the former, as EchoStar lost, what must only be considered the first round, in a legal action to establish TiVo as a bona fide patent holder in the underlying technology of DVR. Long term client DirecTV underscored this by agreeing a three year extension to its commercial agreement with TiVo, with what appears to be a deal that includes the rights to use DVR technology in its own products.

The valuation of TiVo jumped 32% and then settled to a mere 20% gain after a few days, valuing TiVo at around $736 million as we write this, close to its all time high valuation which was around two years ago, before DirecTV began designing its own hardware for use with its satellite TV service.

While commercial terms between TiVo and DirecTV remain a secret, one thing is clear, and that is TiVo will be able to continue to supply its existing DirecTV customers with its DVR services, and that means it has preserved two thirds of its existing revenues, as long as customers continue to want the service (which most appear to).

In addition, TiVo and DirecTV agree not to assert patent rights against the other and it also extends their existing advertising relationship.

It will be a long time before TiVo can cash in on the court victory against EchoStar, but the jury decided that the Dish satellite TV service owner did look at patented TiVo technology and then went on to deliberately design its own version of the same technology. Initially a $74 million payout has been ordered by the jury and up to three times that amount could be awarded in additional payments in compensatory damages, if the judge decides that the actions of EchoStar were a ‘willful’ infringement.

If that full amount were paid out to TiVo in the end (and as we said even if it is, it will be a long time into the future) that would amount to almost $300 million, and yet this week its share price rose by only $124 million, suggesting that it is not yet all in the price, nor are any other gains that the company might make on the back of the litigation.

Of course EchoStar will appeal, but TiVo will now knock on the door of any company that has yet to pay it patent license fees, and those answering will be unlikely to ignore that request, now that one jury has come down on the TiVo side. This could include Motorola, and potentially Cisco’s Scientific Atlanta, both of which offer DVR capable devices without paying TiVo a penny in patent licenses.

Motorola is open about getting its patent permissions from ReplayTV which has reeled from each of its near corporate death experiences without ever making very much money, and which is now trying to license its DVR patents to software suppliers to place on PCs.

The exact source of Scientific Atlanta’s rights to DVR technology are less well understood with various software companies, including Metabyte Networks and Keen Personal Media, contributing to its early releases as well as a widely held belief that it has access to the ReplayTV patents too.

The truth is that the early legal spats between TiVo and ReplayTV really never resolved anything and if TiVo can hold onto its hard fought intellectual property, then it should be able to go cap in hand to these very large organizations and ask for a royalty, and expect to get it.

In Motorola’s case this is already planned, and it should shortly be coming out with new DVRs for Comcast that include TiVo capability, whereby it intends to make the TiVo service available as a software upgrade to the already installed base of certain Motorola DVRs already deployed. There is no record of TiVo asking for, or getting a royalty or DVR technology from Scientific Atlanta, but its lawyers must be considering an approach after this victory.

The relationship with DirecTV is more complicated. There was only one line in the announcement of the extension of the TiVo deal, that mentioned that it covered intellectual property, which presumably covers the new NDS designed set tops which are supposed to replace the TiVo design for DirecTV customers, but these have been delayed and delayed and still are not ready to support High Definition programming, says TiVo.

TiVo’s early life was a constant legal battle over DVR technology rights. It had a legal action with StarSight Telecast, a Gemstar company, eventually resolved with a cross licensing deal; another with ReplayTV and it sold licenses to many consumer electronics companies, including Sony, Thomson and Humax, and this has resulted in TiVo having to defend itself against threats to these companies in the US, from companies such as Pause Technology and Command Audio, who claimed ownership of the basic DVR technologies also.

Other DVR technology providers that TiVo might target for DVR patent royalties could include set-top box manufacturers Pioneer and Pace and also those offering software only versions of DVRs, from companies such as Microsoft, Aptiv, and Digeo.

It is largely anticipated that both Sony and Microsoft are planning to incorporate DVR technology into their video game consoles, as well as the prospect of Apple introducing DVR software any week now, and while Sony continues to hold an existing TiVo license, there is no record of one being held by Microsoft for its Xbox 360, or by Apple.

TiVo said, ‘TiVo is pleased that the jury found that TiVo’s pioneering time warping patent is valid and that EchoStar has been infringing on our intellectual property. TiVo is particularly gratified that the jury found that EchoStar willfully infringed on our patent and the consequences their actions had on our overall business. This decision recognizes that our intellectual property is valuable and will ensure that moving forward EchoStar and any others that want to use our patented technology will be required to provide us with compensation.’

Now TiVo intends to seek a permanent injunction against EchoStar’s DVR products, which will almost certainly lead to EchoStar settling at some future stage, out of court, and beginning to pay a royalty not only on its home based DVR, but also on the portable DVRs that it supplies from French company Archos, another DVR technology supplier that pays nothing to TiVo.

This would mean that TiVo could be in a strong position, over the next three years, as DVR function drifts onto mobile handsets, to extract a royalty from handset makers in what will eventually be a device market extending into 100s of millions. And that’s a gravy train that would make TiVo considerably more rich than any one of these other potential deals.

TiVo now holds more than 87 patents with 138 more patent applications pending.

Meanwhile EchoStar points out that ‘the Patent Office is in the process of re-examining TiVo’s patent, having determined there is a substantial question concerning the validity of the patent.’ Which we think is largely wishful thinking, and we would expect TiVo to soon leaves its litigious years behind it and step up as much as an intellectual property play as a service business.