Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 August 2014

TiVo has its day in the financial sun ‘ but needs to shift to the cloud

We have been preaching from the TiVo bible for as long as we can remember, since before DVRs were widely installed among pay TV players, and so now, just as the entire world is poised to go to cloud based content, Tivo’s numbers are probably the best they will ever be and over the next few years the momentum that the company has built up through legal actions and solid operator deals, could well begin to wane.

But as of now, it can finally enjoy its day in the sun as its value has jumped past the $1.6 billion that represents its 52 week high share price and as the business begins to show consistent profits. TiVo haters will be saying ‘it’s about time’ but the turnaround is as much down to the Tom Rogers’ astute vision of how to partner with the right type of pay TV players, as it is to the original DVR technology and its patents.

Faultline always backed it because ‘someone’ deserved the credit for inventing the DVR, and it was genuinely a consumer god-send that made watching TV, an experience that had begun to become unbearable, bearable once again. TiVo seemed the most likely candidate and so it has proved.

But that valuation is still misleading, as it has $800 million in cash and securities and so the enterprise value is still just $800 million, albeit far better than early valuations for TiVo that had the enterprise value, at some points in its history, as negative, the whole being seen as worth less than the cash it held.

TiVo has responded this quarter by agreeing to give away $350 million of that cash, in share buy backs, with $100 million coming out this year and a further $250 million spread over the coming two years. Buying your own shares and cancelling them is often the preserve of the most profitable companies, who say they cannot find anything better to do with their money, as it concentrates more and more value into the remaining shares. It is also the preserve of cash rich companies, grateful to sustaining shareholders.

Neither of those is the case with TiVo, which with a net income of just $9.3 million on revenues of $111 million for the quarter, has still to blast through the barrier of returning more than 10% of its revenue in profits. Ok, technically it has done this before, but only on the back of court awarded patent payments. And its shareholders could never be considered supportive throughout its troubles, or at least not many of them.

But if you ignore things like the Cisco-Motorola litigation proceeds then a comparison with this time last year would see TiVo improve EBITDA by 73% to $29.9 million, resulting in the net income figure we mentioned.

The revenue breakdown shows that the all important Service & Technology element rose to $86.6 million, up 13% year-over-year, and that its own subscriptions are now up to 4.8 million, a 33% year-over-year increase, and an all-time high. This is the revenue that most people trust for a feeling of how TiVo is doing. Hardware sales are not really expected to make a profit for TiVo and Technology revenue have mixed up in them both willing licensees and those mandated by court actions, so effectively it has pushed forward some of the litigation proceeds.

The service revenue is all about charges per customer to deliver the TiVo service as more and more customers sign up with existing pay TV players, mostly cable operations (but some IPTV), as well as new operators signing to take TiVo as well as consumers doing deals directly with TiVo.

One case where TiVo has to sign up its own customers is with Comcast, and it said that it has reached another significant agreement with Comcast, whereas its devices can be used, with conditional access decryption taken care of using CableCARDs. TiVo also said that Comcast and TiVo will work together on a future non-CableCARD solution, presumably for its Xfinity OTT delivered content.

In total its MSO revenues grew 37% year-over-year and a new cable company in Canada’s Cogeco has selected TiVo for its advanced service including multi-screen, much as a handful of the smaller US cable operations have, such as Atlantic Broadband, Cable One, Grande Communications, Suddenlink, RCN, Midcontinent and GCI, as well as Virgin, Ono and Com Hem in Europe in the UK, Spain and Sweden.

Rogers talked about cutting costs even further last quarter, including reductions in R&D, and this quarter is the second one where service and technology revenues reached $86.6 million, just below the middle of its forecast range. Much of the cost reduction has come from the winding down of TiVo’s period of intense litigation, which seems to be behind it for now.

Another recently announced deal was with EnTouch a small cable supplier in Houston and TiVo says that it has a pipeline of similar deals about to begin producing even more cable subscriptions.

“Cogeco, which chose TiVo over the prior IPTV solution that was in development, has over 800,000 television customers in Canada and over one million television customers when including Cogeco’s US subsidiary, Atlantic Broadband. Deployment is expected to begin early next year. The strong reception that TiVo continues to see with Atlantic Broadband led to the deal.

Back in January TiVo announced it would acquire personalization software specialist DigitalSmiths in a $135 million transaction, and this has opened up the idea that it can provide the software to major tier 1 operators, without forcing them to use the TiVo UI. So far it has no further news to offer about revenue developments from that quarter, but it did point to further technical developments such as implementing Haxe, a multiplatform programming language, which it said increased the processing performance on its TiVo Premiere boxes by over 30%.

Finally TiVo said that it would keep the rest of its cash pile, over and above the share buy-backs, to look for more acquisitions. TiVo has talked previously about a Cloud DVR implementation, which was conspicuously absent from this presentation and it will be important as we enter the cloud era that TiVo delivers on this promise, otherwise the next generation pay TV innovators will be companies like ActiveVideo, which already has an established cloud presence, and which has offered to partner with TiVo in the past.