TiVo will be with us for some considerable time to come following its first quarter results and the effect that its legal settlement with Dish Network has had on its figures. But despite TiVo announcing its best ever financial quarter, the stock still only has a market cap of $1.1 billion ‘ barely up since the settlement was announced, when Dish promised to pay TiVo some $500 million for patent rights.
TiVo CEO Tom Rogers, said, ‘This has been a memorable quarter for TiVo. The recent historic half billion dollar settlement with Dish Network highlights the significant value of our intellectual property and creates a recurring high margin licensing revenue stream that greatly enhances our financial profile.’
But the company also has new Europe-led momentum, which includes guarantees from pay TV providers who collectively have access to more than 10 million subscribers.
‘We believe these deals, along with our arrangements with Comcast, Cox and also DirecTV, give us the opportunity to drive significant subscription growth,’ added Rogers.
That can’t actually be seen in the company’s subscription figures, which show that it is down to 1.96 million subs, with 753,000 of them supplied by broadcasters or pay TV operators. The company lost 58,000 TiVo direct subscriptions, but lost only 30,000 which go through operators. While this IS a slowing down of subscriber losses, TiVo once boasted 4.4 million subscribers back in 2006 and until it actually turns the corner and begins adding subscribers, investors will see it as a volatile business. From a year ago when subscribers were at 2.5 million, these were split 1.1 million through operators and 1.4 direct. TiVo seems to be acknowledging that its future lies in working with pay TV operators.
TiVo says that there are larger and larger contributions from new distributors and lower legacy churn at, for instance, DirecTV.
Service and technology revenues were $38.8 million, compared to guidance of $36 million, but is down from the $43.2 million in the same period last year and $41.4 million sequentially. TiVo net income was $139 million, compared to guidance of a net loss of $35 and a net loss of $14.2 million in the year ago quarter. This was entirely due to litigation proceeds of $175 million in the quarter. The company now has $351 million in the bank and more to come from the Dish settlement.
Rogers continued, “The agreement we reached with Dish Network represents one of the largest technology patent settlements of all time and is further validation of the strength of TiVo’s intellectual property. In combination with the previously collected damages of over $100 million, the total monetary compensation to be paid by Dish Network for use of our DVR Time Warp patent will exceed $600 million.
Rogers also said, ‘ We believe this settlement sets a precedent regarding the strength and enforceability of our intellectual property to others in the industry, especially AT&T, Microsoft and Verizon with which we currently are engaged in patent litigation, and we intend to continue to aggressively defend our intellectual property from infringement.’
TiVo was at pains to point out that it has scored another litigation win with the Microsoft retaliatory action stayed in the Northern District of California pending review of the Microsoft patents at the Patent & Trademark Office which at Faultline we believe will be absolutely fruitless for Microsoft. TiVo also won a stay in an AT&T counter suit against TiVo. All of which suggests that TiVo will cut its legal bills this quarter somewhat and may have more settlements down the road.
TiVo says it has more pay TV partnerships in the wind which will lead to a growing footprint around the world and has recently cut a deal with Comcast so that its Xfinity TV On Demand content can be viewed on a TiVo Premiere set-top.
Rogers also said that he believed the recent retail cable VoD-access deals with Comcast and Cox have the potential to materially augment sales, because they are removing installation hurdles and providing marketing support.
He also said that TiVo had adjusted its consumer offers and that this meant it could spend 60% less on marketing in the quarter compared to the same period last year.
Financial guidance says that for the second quarter TiVo anticipates service and technology revenues to turn the corner and be up in the range of $46 million to $48 million with a net loss between $25 million to $27 million. The guidance includes licensing revenue from Dish, but clearly not very much of it.