Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 December 2011

To lose one UK set top CEO may be regarded as misfortune’.

It seems a fairly poor return for helping guide Pace to become the largest set top maker in the world, but Neil Gaydon, departing CEO at Pace says that the decision to leave this week was as much him not wanting to commit for another 3 to 4 years, as it was the series of misfortunes that have beset the company’s share price over the past few quarters.

For our money the share price fall from £227 in February to £63, to below a third of its value, was a massive over-reaction. This was a company growing and profitable and clear of real problems, but a single US customer decided to cancel a large order, which hurt its first quarter, and then supply chain problems created by acts of God ‘ the Japanese Tsunami and the Bangkok floods ‘ further slowed the business.

What that created was a need to have a strategic review, basically take a long hard look at the company, and we’re sure one of the issues was make sure that it was not susceptible to single points of failure by further distributing manufacturing. Gaydon looked at this with the chairman and suddenly realized that it would require another three to four years to carry out and after 16 years at the company decided to call it a day. Ironically his successor is the head of Pace Americas, Mike Pulli, ostensibly the man who was responsible for the first of these quarterly hiccups. It’s not likely to assuage the shareholders.

It’s not like any of this has really upset the Pace revenue engine. It will have revenues of $2.3 billion for 2011, develop profits of $141 million, after losing orders that it was unable to fulfill because of the floods and dropping just $9.5 million from its profit forecast, and having a small effect on cash flow, and yet the company is valued at a lowly £213 million ($328 million) on the UK stock market, partly because Pace cannot say for sure when the hard disk drive problems associated with the flooding will be over and says that in all likelihood a further $35 to $50 million will be lost from the margin in the first half of 2012.

The truth is that Pace has stood the test of time and has been massively undervalued throughout its history, more a factor of the conservative nature of the UK stock market than anything else, and the fact that Pulli will continue to operate out of the US suggests to us that it may eventually move its HQ there and try to become a US company, with the type of valuation that this offers for technology companies. Gaydon told us that he was planning to lie in the sun for a few months, and practice guitar, before considering a new role.

Coincidentally, IPTV and OTT UK set top specialist, Amino Technologies, a company with barely 10% of Pace’s valuation, but also public in the UK, has also parted company with its CEO, Andrew Burke on the same day.

Amino has just slid from slightly loss making last year with revenues for 2010 of just £44 million, to making a profit for the year to end of November. Revenues have risen from £26 million two years ago to what is on track to be around £52 million this year. But once again conservative British Investors value this company at practically nothing. It has £14 million in the bank and a valuation of £22 million, so the business itself is just worth £8 million to them, even though it is doing £52 million in revenues. In the US this would be worth something around its revenue, so about 6 times as much.

Burke’s tenure actually ends on a high note, a return to profit expected when the numbers to November come out, with a record revenue and a strong cash position. The company had tied up all of its cash supporting the Cubovision devices for Telecom Italia and now that has paid off, a year later it has cash of £14 million. The company has a Europe wide lead on Intel based set tops and is one of the first to get its hands on the new Intel CE chip, due shortly.

It would be insane for Amino to have deliberately lost someone of Burke’s caliber, who also pioneered BT Vision, and who has driven the company to grow, rather than remain relatively obscure. So perhaps it was his own search for a bigger challenge, or a company that could attract more sensible investors. The existing COO Don McGarva will take over as CEO.

The Pace share value went up 5% on the news of Gaydon’s departure whereas Amino’s share price would go up if any one of us went out and bought a handful of shares.