Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 October 2015

Turbulent times as GEO HTS satellites revolutionize economics

Something we have been saying for a while is that it’s tough to plan for the satellite industry, and now a revered satellite research company is saying much the same, if for somewhat slightly different reasons.

This is NSR or Northern Sky Research, which said one of its recent studies showed that there will be a massive impact from GEO HTS system in the coming few years on the industry’s economics. Now this needs a bit of explanation.

A GEO HTS is one that is in a geostationary orbit, but which can support lots of tiny spot beams, which reach an area the size of perhaps 100 kilometers in diameter, as opposed to continent wide footprints which Geo satellites support today. This creates the equivalent of small cells for cellular, in that the same spectrum can be used from the satellite in another spot beam, in a non-overlapping region. Collectively these satellites can deliver over 100 Gbps across all of their spot beams, using up to 300 transponders.

A concrete example might help. When High Definition video satellites went up for DirecTV on the 2005/7 timeframe, in order to give the US local channels, they had to use up spectrum to deliver 1,500 HD channels, so the price was high. Now you could use the same spectrum over and over again in spot beams to deliver different local markets and perhaps cover the entire US in about 25% of the spectrum. That means DTH delivery of next gen UHD technology, would come at almost no extra cost, even if it remained needing 4 times as much bandwidth, and with HEVC and other codecs, it is likely to use just twice the bandwidth.

When we say cost, we mean to the satellite company and this means that a satellite company with HTS options on new satellites can go after business that would usually go to an existing satellite, and offer a much lower price, raiding non-HTS satellites of business and soaking up more and more capacity.

NSR said “We are starting to see the impact that GEO-HTS payloads can have on revenues. Thaicom sees over $100 million per year from IPSTAR. YahSat’s revenues per operational satellite metric exceeds $100 milllion, and Avanti sees more than $40 million revenues per satellite at just a 20-25% fill rate.”

Overnight this changes the economics of putting up satellites, and most of all changes the return on investment that a satellite company can expect, and that means it will be more willing to spend capex, but only if it delivers HTS returns. Debt markets will suddenly look more favorably on what was usually a taboo, high risk market, with too low a return.

NSR is advertising its Satellite Operator Financial Analysis which is now in its 5th Edition. The result has been faster capex cycles, lower backlogs, and falling revenues per transponder.

There is currently a massive rethink going on at satellite operators, who all want to put up HTS satellites, and need the right locations for them. It is worth putting all your satellite eggs in one basket, putting up a single HTS satellite instead of 3 FSS (Fixed Satellite Service) satellites, and still end up with more capacity. FSS bandwidth costs over $100 million per Gbps in space, but new HTS satellites HTS can supply 1 Gbps in space for around $3 million, a 33 to 1 ratio.

No wonder companies like Intelsat are trying to dump assets like there is no tomorrow, in order to free up cash to invest more heavily in HTS. Last week it said it would shed assets to pay down as much of the $14.76 billion of debt it has, as it can, as its share price has halved over the year to date.

Intelsat’s debt dwarfs that of others in the industry, SES holds around $4.44 billion, Telesat $2.75 billion, and Eutelsat has a comparatively tiny debt of $55.35 million. Private equity firms BC Partners and Silver Lake acquired Intelsat in 2007 for $16.5 billion, when the company was already burdened with more than $11 billion debt, and it looks like business has not gone as well as they would like, hence the assets sell-off.

But as their rivals put up more HTS satellites, Intelsat will come under increasing scrutiny, and financial pressure.

We would argue that OTT services will exacerbate this problem. As OTT video is watched more frequently, especially on portable devices, this will mean that time available to watch linear TV will fall, and greater use of DVRs and nPVRs will emerge and make this worse. The result will be that poor content gets watched less and less, and slowly the better content is crushed into fewer and fewer channels, which other channels are closed. Putting together UHD phase 1 content (4K) into channels will have the same effect – better content put into fewer channels. The net result will be that revenue for carrying video, which makes up over 50% of many satellite operators’ revenues, will fall, as less channels are delivered DTH.

When you combine this with the fact that a single lost channel to a satellite vendor often means losing a contribution feed, a distribution feed AND a delivery feed, as well as the arrival of HTS capacity, there will be a pricing crunch in satellite and overcapacity.

What will make up for this is the suitability of HTS streams for two way traffic, which means it can be used for things like cellular data backhaul and consumer broadband – but only if you have HTS capacity.

Is there still value in having 30 traditional transponders on a satellite, a few orbital slots away from one that has 300? The book value of each FSS satellite which has 30 transponders is currently $250 million. This could fall to 10% of that amount over a few short years.

In 2014 the revenue of the Big Four (Intelsat, Eutelsat, SES and TeleSat) declined by over $200 million, so this is a factor that favors new market entrants, who do not have all that FSS baggage.

Contradicting the backhaul story, Ericsson this week issued a forecast that predicts traditional cellular backhaul such as microwave technology will soon support multi-gigabit capacities and remain in pole position through 2020 and puts satellite backhaul capacity way behind microwave (wireless fiber) and fiber, saying 65% of all cell sites will be connected by microwave except for China, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan which have existing deep fiber investments.