Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 September 2011

Two doors open for Mobile broadcast TV at IBC ‘ very small doors

At IBC this week, the DVB Project, through Peter Siebert, Executive Director, told us that ‘it had received a lot of interest in DVB-T2 Lite,’ something that is being seen as a way to revive interest in Europe in broadcast mobile TV to the phone.

Be that as it may, the Lite version of DVB-T2 isn’t only about mobile TV, though we are having some difficulty working out what else it could be used for. Siebert pointed out that DVB-T2 itself already, ‘allowed multiple modulation types, and timeslotted signals, but the new Lite 1.3 release allows a different number of carriers,’ in different parts of the signal.

This effectively allows mobile TV, as the more carriers, the weaker each signal and using modulation like 256 QAM is fine for antennas on a roof, but if you, for instance, used the same modulation and aim it at in-building penetration, you get a signal that the most sensitive antenna in the world cannot hear.

The entire debate about picking up DVB-T signals on a phone in Germany over the past few years came about because it used 16 QAM for its DVB-T implementation. The new 1.3 version of DVB-T2 lets you use a ‘robust’ modulation for an indoor TV signal and you could easily pick that up inside a home with a moving target like a smart phone.

But like all of these techniques (On Faultline we once followed a total of 18 separate methods for getting a TV signal to a phone) the problem is getting handset vendors to include the requisite chip logic inside the most popular devices, or mobile operators deciding they would commission ‘TV’ oriented devices which have the extra $10 or so Bill of Materials on board to pick up broadcast TV. We await the arrival (or not) of low power DVB-T2 Lite chips on the market, with bated breath.

Which brings us to another announcement made this week, not actually at IBC, coming from the very disappointed French community, which still wants to see broadcast TV on a phone, backed by Orange, Alcatel, CNES (the French space agency), DiBcom, Mitsubishi, Teamcast, INSA-IETR and Telecom Bretagne.

DiBcom is a leader in DVB-T chipsets, Alcatel had its own DVB-SH satellite handheld technology that used both satellite and base station parallel transmissions to create a mobile broadcasting system using Mobile Satellite Spectrum. Orange has had multiple experiments in mobile TV, and has a huge number of TV channels clogging up its 3G base stations using streaming over cellular.

The thrust of their highly technical research paper, which they say they will follow up with another later this year, is that MBMS, or rather the extended version for LTE called Extended MBMS, the multicast services layer in LTE, and DVB-NGH, the next generation handheld DVB protocol, designed to replace DVB-H, the protocol that never truly got off the ground, can effectively be merged.

What the French are after here is a set of protocols which are entirely controlled by the cellular operator so that it can deliver something exactly like cellular streaming, with 40 or 50 channels, using a tiny slice of LTE spectrum, working alongside cellular streaming.

Orange once told us that it would have to move to broadcast mobile TV by the end of 2008, or its 3G network would grind to a halt with TV signals. It has managed to ameliorate the pressure by moving early to the higher levels of HSDPA, which allows for the delivery of more data, and by putting a restrictive policy in place for watching TV over cellular which blocks new viewers at each base station in favour of voice calls, when it is full.

The biggest concerns in the past were that TV broadcasters were expected to benefit from broadcast Mobile TV and few cellcos could see what was in it for them ‘ so business models are the issue. The simplest business model out there is re-harvesting spectrum that has already been used for Cellular Streaming TV services and then once again begin marketing existing TV services.

One of the best bets for that was always some kind of use or reserved space in existing 3G and 4G spectrum, for instance using MBMS in the 5MHz unpaired data spectrum allocation of the major 3G licenses around the world. The only problem with that is that it required either a modification to existing cellular chipsets, to accommodate MBMS, or anything like it.

If people can find a reason, another reason, any reason, for putting such capabilities in chips already, then there is no question that cellcos will be hit up for some extra BOM for adding the capability to handsets. If it’s there for another reason, perhaps related to App Store data delivery, then free to air TV programming or paid services from cellcos or both, could be delivered without straining the network. That has always been Ericsson’s approach and it was saying, four or five years ago that its systems would automatically switch on MBMS in handsets ‘ but as far as we can see, that never happened.

The paper written by this cluster of French players is called Project M3, which stands for Mobile MultiMedia and is funded by ANR ‘ the National Research Agency and says the reason that someone has to find an answer to this is because data traffic carried by mobile networks, will multiply by two every year through 2014 with the percentage of that data which is video, shifting from 35% now, to 66% by 2014.

Because this has the potential to saturate 3G ‘unicast’ networks it is looking for a compromise between the DVB Project ideas and MBMS.

The paper repeats what we have always known about mobile video ‘ that the cellular network is ill-equipped in its current form to delivery video to smart phones. It is even less well equipped to deliver it to tablets in a variety of larger form factors each requiring more and more data. And WiFi is just not going to hack it in video delivery, because people are not always within reach of WiFi. In other words despite the fact that mobile TV failed, cellular networks still need some relief from video carriage.

So something has to be done and this group sees a synthesis of 3GPP eMBMS and DVB-NGH mobile broadcasting standards, as the basis for a common broadcasting specification. Without going into the immense detail of the paper it concludes that a system based on the current eMBMS with extensions which integrate more time interleaving, reduced sub-carrier spacing, and a system optimized for downlink-only, could produce a unified system, but warns that relevant use-cases and realistic business models still need to be agreed before such a system could be either standardized or deployed.