Battery technology has so far dismally failed to keep pace with the advances in storage density and computational power that follow Moore’s Law, and as a result has become the single biggest impediment to innovation in the otherwise blooming mobile industry.
The main stumbling block has been failure to increase significantly the density of electrical energy storage as enabled by rechargeable battery technologies, notably lithium ion which currently dominates from wrist watches through smartphones and tablets to electric cars. For the latter it has been a particular barrier, given that at most electric cars have a range of 100 miles and even then confined to unacceptably low levels of performance compared with their fuel burning counterparts.
This failure to increase densities significantly, has meant that batteries continue to account for a significant proportion of the weight and volume of both portable electronic devices and electric cars. This has made it difficult to extend smart phone technology to flexible wearable devices because the batteries would have to be capable of bending, since they cannot be shrunk to the size say of a pin head.
But recently significant progress has been made on both these related fronts of density and bendability, although not likely to reach commercial products in the immediate future. The developments on the flexibility front will most likely come to market first, because they involve technologies already demonstrated in the lab.
Until now the constraint for bendable batteries has been that the technologies proven to have at least reasonable electrical storage density are based on inorganic metal compounds that are inherently inflexible in their normal forms, while more flexible organic alternatives such as carbon nanotubes lack the capacity. Attempts have been made to advance on both these fronts, on the one hand making metal compounds bendier and secondly creating organic alternatives that can store more electricity.
Now most researchers have largely given up on the second front and concentrated on making inorganic metal based compounds more flexible. For example a team at Rice University in the US reported in April tests of a flexible battery comprising nickel-fluoride electrodes layered around a solid electrolyte, without the lithium found in nearly all commercial batteries today. This was reported in the Journal of the American Chemical Society, describing an electrochemical capacitor (temporary electricity store) about a hundredth of an inch thick but capable of scaling up for devices either by increasing the size or adding layers.
This is promising in so far that it can yield a thin flexible battery capable of being manufactured at scale and with acceptable life, still capable of charging to 76% of original capacity after 10,000 charge-discharge cycles and 1,000 bending cycles.
However greater excitement has been caused by an announcement just made of a wire-shaped lithium ion battery by a Chinese group, reported in the journal Angewandte Chemie. This uses existing proven lithium ion technology, but combined with composite yarns made of carbon nanotubes, which enables them to weave into light, flexible, elastic, and safe textile batteries with a high energy density. This is the first time lithium ion batteries have been produced in wire form, introducing the possibility of incorporating them in wearable devices such as bracelets, or even within specialist clothing. In a sense it combines the inorganic metal and organic carbon based approaches.
Meanwhile a major advance relating to electrical storage density itself has been reported from Michigan Technological University. Radical progress on this front would to some extent make work on flexible batteries redundant, since there would be no need for them to bend if they were vanishingly small. The Michigan team has not actually advanced density itself but laid a foundation for that to happen by developing a device for monitoring activity of lithium ion batteries at the atomic level. It has long been suspected that dramatic improvements in electrical storage will only be made by optimizing the process at the atomic level, not least because just about everything has been tried at the level of bulk materials. This after all is how biological life has evolved, optimizing processes such as photosynthesis right down to alignment of individual atoms and molecules within the critical reaction centers.
The idea here is that capacity of batteries is determined by the number of lithium ions that can travel between the cathode and anode at a given time and this is constrained by the damage this process does. In order to optimize the process of lithium ion movement it has to be observed in real time in full atomic detail, which has now been achieved through the latest electron microscopes using a technology called AC-STEM (aberration corrected scanning transmission electron microscope). With AC-STEM it is possible to incorporate a nano scale version of a lithium ion battery within the electron microscope, in this case using an electrode constructed from tin oxide (SnO2). The key observation from this approach made so far is that the lithium ions travel between the battery’s electrodes in specific channels, which may suggest that if the system could be engineered at nanoscale these channels could be made denser without increasing wear and tear, providing the ion trajectories could be precisely controlled. These are early days, but at least researchers now have the means at least to observe what is going on at the critical atomic level and may soon have the ability to start manipulating the process at that level too.