IBC was the stage for some lengthy debates regarding the future of UHD as a format for content and broadcasters. While there were several dissenting opinions, the general consensus was that UHD TV was on the way, but that the standards had to be adjusted to incorporate High Dynamic Range technology.
The world of UHD is rife with confusing acronyms. Full HD uses a 1920x1080p resolution, with frame rates between 24 and 60fps, a bit depth of 8 or 10bit, and the ITU Rec. 709 color space. UHD1 has a 3840x2160p resolution, with a maximum frame rate of 120fps, a bit depth of 10 or 12bit, and the ITU Rec. 2020 color space – a significant increase from Full HD in all areas. UHD2 uses the same specs as UHD1 but differs only in its larger resolution of 7640x4320p.
The confusion arises from the marketing terms that have been introduced to sell premium TV sets. As Paul Gray from DisplaySearch put it, “4K panels were simply released into the wild, without planning and without content. It was possible so they did it, and marketers loved it.” 4K derived its name from the 4096x2160p resolution, but the term no longer denotes the 4096 (4K) horizontal pixels that it used to, and has instead become the go-to buzzword for consumers, but a rather confusing industry term.
As such, 4K was framed as UHD1 Phase 1 in the SMPTE panel; representing the awkward transition from HD to UHD. As such, 4K is most commonly found with a 3840x2160p resolution, a max frame rate of 60fps, bit depth of 8 or 10, and the Rec. 709 color space. As you can see, the only metric to have increased between 4K and Full HD is the resolution.
And this is a problem, as it is the other parameters that make the most difference to picture quality. An interesting discussion took place in a panel on the latest UHD technologies, in which Pierre Hughes Routhier from Technicolor took the audience through a number of demos to show the differences between footage shot in UHD but delivered in a number of formats. The results were a little surprising.
The demo footage focused on a snowboarder making his way down a slope before jumping onto a rail and sliding down it. Key details to look at included the trees in the background and the snow thrown up by the jump.
The Technicolor team found that the key to a better picture was in the refresh rate of the picture and not the resolution. As Routhier put it, shooting fast footage in UHD, but at a slow frame rate just results in “very high definition blur.” While UHD resolutions are better at capturing detail in a slower or static picture, if the frame rate is not high enough, all that extra detail is lost in the viewing.
Consequently in the snowboard video, 2160p30 is inferior to 720p60, simply because of the extra frame rate in the HD video producing less blur. Similarly, 1080p120 produced a less blurry picture than 2160p60. Even when the frame rate is the same across the board, 2160p60 is only very slightly better than 1080p60.
Routhier’s main takeaway was that all the extra detail that can be captured by UHD resolutions will be lost if the frame rate does not increase too. He also lamented the fact that 1080p120 had been dropped from the DVB phase 1 discussion, as he felt that this would have been a major improvement over UHD at 30 or 60 frames per second – a tradeoff between capturing the light of the picture (in the noise and focus) and the motion (the blur between the frames captured).
After Routhier came Takuji Soeno from the Japanese Broadcasting Corporation (NHK), who presented the latest progress on the company’s 8K UHD2 systems – which captures footage from a SHV camera that then pushes 144Gbps of data along ten optical 16Gbps cables to a new camera control unit. The numbers were certainly impressive, but it remains to be seen how quickly 8K can make it into the consumer sphere as anything more than a niche product – given the slow rate of adoption of 4K/UHD1.
NHK also plans to launch Channel 4K over satellite broadcast in 2015, which uses the 4K marketing tag but has the full 60fps and 10bit Rec. 2020 color depth that is currently missing from some of the 4K streams available from Netflix (which provides a mix of 30/60fps, and Rec. 709/2020 in its delivery). The satellite broadcast would push 35Mbps to the home, and the target for the cable and IPTV launches are for end-of 2015. 8K satellite channels are planned for 2018, and NHK is targeting the 2020 Tokyo Olympics as the culmination of their 8K rollout.
High Dynamic Range (HDR) was also a frequent point of discussion, with many speakers calling for its inclusion inside the UHD standards for UHD1 Phase 2 – meaning that the ITU should decide on the HDR spec very shortly. Dolby’s DolbyVision is expected to hit the market in Q4 2014, with Amazon and Vudu also among those in the running to launch HDR content in 2014. The next generation of Blu-ray, expected to arrive in 2015, will also support Rec. 2020 and HDR,
But there is no doubt that 4K is on the up. The DisplaySearch forecast put China at the top, with the Chinese “absolutely driving the market,” and leading the adoption curve for most new technologies. 4K will account for 9% of all TV shipments in 2014, and dominates the premium segment thanks to “megapixel marketing.” 4K panels currently sell at a 20% premium in China but are quickly converging on both the retail price and BOM of 1080p sets – with panels larger than 55-inches representing the bulk of the market, and panels sub 45-inch almost non-existent.