While the UK newspapers go on and on about the Hargreaves Report out this week, which focuses mostly on changes to the UK copyright law, Faultline immediately picked up on a core single recommendation ‘ the setting up of a Digital Copyright Exchange ‘ something he says needs to happen before the end of 2012.
What is a Digital Copyright Exchange? Or more to the point, what would one look like and who would use it? It is something that Faultline suggested in 2004 when internet delivery of content was not only possible, but happening on a large scale, even if mostly it was through illegal P2P networks like Kazaa and Napster.
And since then we have watched and waited and tried to understand why such Exchanges have not emerged. They are used to trade oil and gas, to swap financial assets, why not film, music and games. Perhaps it will indeed take government action to create not just one international copyright exchange, but perhaps one per country, each of them linked to one another. Better still there would be either a single European or Global exchange or perhaps two, a bit like global positioning satellites, credit card companies or PC operating systems ‘ with two major suppliers, so that it’s not quite a monopoly, but without hundreds of fragmented services which would be useless.
In Professor Hargreaves’ mind this is an online method for copyright licensing, a way for content suppliers such as TV channels and Pay TV operators, to browse available content, find content that would suit their audiences, view the terms under which it is available, perhaps make offers on it, or bid for exclusivity and purchase permanent, long term, temporary or non-exclusive VoD rights to the content, along with all copyright licenses. It would be, if you like, a backbone for Netflix-like services and it takes us back to the Verizon announcement in April this year, where it says it has a network that can carry content streams to any part of the globe, and also to the NDS InfiniteTV Exchange, a just launched B2B internet content marketplace which ties content owners up with platform operators.
One is a network operator coping with all the issues of delivering streams to said operators, and the other is a way of conducting the deals to agree on terms of such sales. In our view it is pointless having one side of this equation, the copyright and financial side sorted out, without the other side, the mechanics of delivery.
As we thought about this in further detail we felt that perhaps this really does need a government behind it ‘ because it doesn’t seem very simple at all.
Just assume that content has to be viewed on multiple devices ‘ TV sets, gaming platforms, set tops, tablets, PCs with Windows, PCs with Linux, handsets in various operating systems ‘ just think purely about the method for content protection. It would have to be software based, and there are plenty of content protection technologies out there which offer multi-screen protection by offering downloads to different processing architectures ‘ but we have to acknowledge that if these are delivered as executable files, even encrypted files, that this will lead to increased opportunity for piracy (which may or may not, in turn, lead to increased piracy).
The Verizon network idea is not about delivering files but about delivering HD streams. This is far more measurable than the delivery of files. For instance if a cable operator was to order a piece of video, let’s say a movie over this exchange, if the content was delivered as a file and broadcast to the entire cable network, the cableco would only know who watched it based on fairly technical audience statistics, based on remote control clicks. The network delivers it to every home, only the local tuner device knows that channel the system was tuned to. The cable operator could keep the file, and if it was supposed to automatically delete after it was used, it would need a secure application for that, which could be bypassed. Files in this environment are too dangerous.
It’s the same with DVB-T broadcasts. If a file is delivered to the UK’s BBC and it send it out over the air, it only knows who watched it based on fairly inexact audience data. If a content owner wanted to charge per viewing, it couldn’t, it would need a flat broadcast fee as well based on population reach perhaps. All of this type of logic has to be built into the deals and financial offers of a copyright exchange, and that’s complex. The security itself is complex and really this only works with streams over the internet.
Flat up front pricing, discounts for volume, payment per home or per device, flat rate for inclusion in bulk subscriptions or flat pricing so an operator can deliver it for free to a segment of its audience and even VoD pricing which changes over time as the asset ages ‘ all of these and many more business models have to be automated into such an exchange as well as the method of protection, both in the delivery to the operator and in the consumption, it has to negotiate payment terms and deliver the asset with watermarking to isolate piracy reporting to any particular deal. You want to be able to identify the operator that lost the file to a pirate, and better still which of his customers stole it, so you need complex, layered watermarking that only a handful of players can provide.
If the UK tries to operate such as system across Europe it has language issues to deal with, about 27 different legal interpretations on the subject of piracy and breach of copyright (though many of these were harmonized when the World Copyright treaty was added to existing legislation).
And if a minor broadcaster were to lie about the number of people that will be allowed to view a particular piece of content, there has to be a way of checking it.
Back in 2005 the Harvard School of Law tried to put together something it call a Digital Media Exchange. This was far simpler because it was focused on copyright free works ‘ and it delivered content with creative commons licensing, and was non-profit making. It was entirely for music, and still had the concept of payment and subscriptions and compensation for copyrighted music artists. But even in this fairly liberal view of content exchange, the system had to count how many times a musical piece was accessed, which meant streamed delivery.
And that was fine, because that particular exchange was all about streaming from a remote server, something that is so much easier. Stream protection was all that was envisaged at the time. But that wouldn’t be considered safe enough today we don’t think. Instead you would need a secure application at the far end ensuring that consumers couldn’t store an unencrypted stream.
If you try to apply those kinds of rules to video, and only deal with internet delivered content and drop the idea of files and only deal with streams, you have a much simpler solution, but perhaps not one which major broadcasters can us, because of the shift to internet protocol delivery. Most TV channels today are delivered in real time by satellite downlink, but this exchange will be for discreet programming ‘ more suitable for ISPs and smaller pay TV operators. In fact overnight if such an exchange existed, it would inevitably lead to a whole new industry ‘ ad hoc TV channels over the internet.
So such an exchange would lead to further internet disintermediation of video content (although Professor Ian Hargreaves believes that this would also be applied to music and games and not just video).
All of which should mean that when Broadcasters take a long look at this suggestion they MUST immediately oppose it and that’s a worrying thought. Most TV content has its exploitation rights controlled, not by the studios who make it, but by the broadcasters who commissioned it. And if broadcasters are NOT behind such an effort, then it will be only for non-TV content.
If the UK Government gets behind such a plan, it could actually force all BBC content onto such an Exchange because it controls the BBC, and then smaller businesses might gain the benefit from easier access to content in order to start Over The Top video services, using the internet. But the BBC alone would not create sufficient impetus for this to work. About 70% of TV content in the UK and much of Europe is supplied from the US, and this means that either US broadcasters or US studios control those rights, depending upon how old the content is, or whether or not internet exploitation was included in broadcasting rights.
Today those businesses are all cozily operating together. The CBS and ABCs of this world, as well as Disney and Fox, know their counterparts in the BBC and other European broadcasters. They deal in a world which is split up by territories and allocate rights accordingly. But if the Digital Copyright Exchange is NOT aimed at these people, it is a far smaller enterprise than it might be and then perhaps the technical issues that need to be overcome, make it less worth the effort.
We’ve seen from the NDS effort with its InfiniteTV Exchange, that it is smaller content owners that initially sign up, and smaller operators that use it, at least at first and it is only for Internet delivered content. In fact, we wouldn’t be at all surprised if the idea for a Digital Copyright Exchange wasn’t somehow put in the head of Professor Hargreaves by the NDS efforts ‘ either that he is familiar with the product or familiar with the same needs that NDS discovered.
If the entire idea was constructed for Over The Top video efforts, then it would be solely internet delivered, which means it could be fully accountable in terms of views, and delivered in streams, which are easier to protect, it would need a secure application created with a version for each playout device, but that’s little more difficult than many apps which are targeted for iPads and Android Tablets. A stream based service would make it bombproof in terms of giving value for money ‘ everyone could have access to every video product and only pay for the streams they use. That might lead to mass innovation in internet delivery services.
And given this would be exposed to the internet, it would be easy to collect audience figures, which in turn would show everyone the video which is most popular. Those figures could be made available alongside the service. Such a system could also have extensions which plug into social media platforms giving various operators access to the comments made about each piece of content. The entire thing could be made to have all the capabilities of YouTube and Facebook, except designed for professional content.
But of course Facebook and YouTube are still both there, and Facebook in particular, looks to have every chance of bypassing such a mechanism, and recruiting content for its 500 million audience, directly from studios, at prices that other video operators could only dream of.
So if social networks and user generated content would not be the target audience and if Broadcasters would not play ball, and if pay TV operators all offer their own TV Everywhere service by individual negotiation, through their existing channel suppliers, then who will use this? It looks like it is only for businesses trying to get the same benefits as all those larger players, but which don’t have the resources to put a team of content licensing negotiators on sourcing content. Perhaps fledgling Netflix style businesses would use it, or maybe OTT start-ups. But that won’t be many people, certainly not at first. Which is perhaps why our vision from 2004 has never come into being.
Yes we agree that it makes sense that content owners should put their content on a ‘For Sale or Rent ‘ database and that a system should be automated so that the owner can put in its terms, and the buyers could decide whether or not to accept them, and an automated deal could be done. And that delivery of the finished good should be part of this.
But in allowing that, content owners will have to agree to publish their pricing, and that’s going to give away a lot of their negotiation advantage. It doesn’t have to but anyone that enters a negotiation with a content owner will immediately get a feel for its terms. Given that one content user never knows what deal his rival has, that would not sit well within the existing content owners, since rivals would use such a mechanism to check rival prices. And yet any Exchange that didn’t automate every step of the way, becomes nothing more than an email directory of interested parties and that’s not much good.
In Europe there are about 206 million TV homes, and already 122 million of them have at least one pay TV relationship. Their Pay TV provider is likely to prefer going through its existing channels in order to source TV Everywhere content which it plans to GIVE away to subscribers, Over The Top. In the US it has been predicted that over 80% of TV homes will shortly have access to over the top content for free from their pay TV provider. If that trend continues into Europe, which it looks set to, then it severely narrows the potential applications for such an exchange.