Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 April 2006

UK gets breakthrough Mobile TV and satellite radio spectrum

The UK regulator Ofcom has committed to auctioning spectrum early next year which is ideal for use in mobile TV networks. It will make space for a 40 MHz slice of spectrum in the 1452 to 1492 MHz range on a technology and application-neutral basis by March 2007.

Proposals were called for in January 2005 and many of the interested parties made a strong case for this spectrum to go on the block, not least of which came from Arqiva, previously the broadcasting arm of NTL, which is behind the largest Mobile TV trials using DVB-H, in the UK, along with its partner O2.

However Ofcom says that the spectrum could be ideal for a number of applications including mobile TV, broadband wireless networks like WiMAX and Satellite Digital Radio, which has taken off in the US.

The WiMAX statement is a complete misnomer, as this really is mobile TV territory. There is no existing WiMAX profile that has been standardized on in this spectrum and there are none planned in that time frame, and since no other European territory is proposing broadband wireless applications here, equipment will not be economical for WiMAX networks in this L-Band spectrum. But most trials for DVB-H are in three specific bands and this is one of them, albeit the highest with perhaps the least attractive propagation characteristics, the others being Band III in 220 MHz, UHF in 600 MHz and this L-Band in 1470 MHz spectrum.

The upper 12.5MHz of the 40MHz available could be used to deploy satellite digital radio using the S-DAB standard while the lower portion might be used for Mobile TV says Ofcom. However both DAB using the Enhanced Packet Mode for pure IP packet delivery, and T-DMB would equally fit into this spectrum as DVB-H. These would require chunks of around 1.5GHz for 2 to 3 TV stations, while DVB-H uses between 5 and 8 MHz channels that will deliver between 10 and 16 TV stations. Qualcomm’s proprietary technology, MediaFLO needs 6 MHz and claims to offer up to 20 TV channels. They all use Coded OFDM with QPSK modulation and Arqiva has gone on record as saying that 5,000 transmitters might be needed using 7.6 MHz of bandwidth for good UK wide coverage.

While BT with its Movio service, which it shares with Virgin Mobile, has a clear one year advantage using spectrum it has already acquired and DAB technology, it may decide that its holdings are not enough and become one bidder for the spectrum. If 27.5 MHz was all used for mobile TV as suggested, then as many as 50 TV channels could be created offering QVGA pixel density, about a quarter of that on a PC VGA screen. It would make the UK a hotbed of Mobile TV technology and give it a chance to catch up with Germany, Italy and Finland, and of course the US, which are all surging ahead with trials and planned services.

This block of spectrum is subject to international agreements, including the international plan agreed at Maastricht in 2002. These agreements impose some constraints on use of the spectrum in the UK but Ofcom no longer believes all of these constraints are necessary and will be seeking agreement to a more flexible approach over the coming months.

The licenses will be tradeable, with an initial minimum period of 15 years, with no guidance of what technology and which application should be used, the lower 27.5 MHz of the 40MHz available could be made available as one or more packages, but the upper 12.5MHz will be awarded as a single spectrum block, using a simultaneous multiple round auction. In our view the 27.5 lower chunk should be in at least 3 slices to promote competition.

Responses are requested by 9 June 2006 for interested bidders, with the final auction completed by first quarter 2007. This is a full 5 years ahead of the release of UHF TV spectrum, as the UK is one of the last countries in Europe to switch off analog TV in favor of digital broadcasting. It was previously feared that 2012 would be the first opportunity to bid for appropriate Mobile TV spectrum in the UK, putting the country at a severe disadvantage compared to other European countries. This is now at least partially rectified.

Other likely bidders will be media groups, their broadcasting arms and even one or two of the mobile operators, although their likely approach to Mobile TV will be to use existing 3G spectrum in an unpaired arrangement, something that will be made possible using a special multicasting protocol, MBMS, that will be supported by the next software base station release. These services will reach the market at almost the exact same time as this new spectrum, leading to vigorous competition between those that buy the new spectrum and 3G spectrum holders, each offering two ways of delivering mobile TV.

In total Ofcom said it would release a total of 400MHz of spectrum, more than the total spectrum currently used for mobile telecoms, over the next few years, but much of the rest of this is likely to be extending competition within cellular networks and underpinning wireless broadband and WiMAX.

We would expect that the spectrum appropriate for satellite radio is likely to create a separate, but huge rush from existing satellite owners, in the most part private equity groups, which will want to leverage from the experiences of XM and Sirius satellite radio in the US, as well as their extraordinary stock market valuations.