With Sprint and T-Mobile essentially unable to merge, the initiative in US consolidation has passed to the cable operators, as seen in Altice’s quad play-focused acquisition of Cablevision.
With AOL and DirecTV under their respective belts, Verizon and AT&T have limited freedom to make further major acquisitions on the home front, while Sprint and TMO are more likely to be targets for cablecos than the other way around. That means the mobile players need to look for other ways, apart from M&A, to continue to build up their spectrum arsenals – expanded licence-exempt bands, supporting LTE as well as WiFi; next year’s 600 MHz auction; the rising use of carrier aggregation and of formerly spurned frequency bands like AT&T’s WCS.
All that activity will intensify as the auction approaches and the operators start to feel the capacity pinch again from 2016. But there is one major spectrum holder still in play for the MNOs (or the cable players), and that is satellite TV operator Dish. When AT&T acquired Dish’s rival DirecTV, there was understandable speculation that Verizon might go after the other satellite pay TV company, but the telco insists is not interested in that acquisition.
However, CEO Lowell McAdam told last week’s Goldman Sachs Communicopia conference that he would be interested in a deal for Dish’s spectrum. That might involve buying it, if Dish chairman Charlie Ergen gives up on his dream of creating an LTE-Advanced network to support a quad play, plus the potential to develop creative wholesale businesses. The most interesting outcome would be for Dish to partner with a disruptor like Google and finally deliver what Clearwire and LightSquared both promised and failed – a flexible wholesale LTE network enabling hundreds of service providers, including specialists in vertical markets, on an on-demand basis.
As with Clearwire, now part of Sprint, however, economic reality may drive Dish towards a more conventional telco partner and business case, wasting the opportunity to enable a new set of players in the US. Dish – which some analysts have always believed is in the spectrum game only to collect assets which it will later sell on – insists its preferred route would be to build out in its airwaves, but that it needs a partner to host its network in order to make the sums add up.
It has a significant amount of spectrum following various acquisitions and auctions – primarily, 40 MHz in AWS-4, 25 MHz in AWS-3 (pending FCC clearance),10 MHz in 1.9 GHz PCS H block, and much of the 700 MHz E Block. That could attract any of the big four operators to a partnership – exchanging access to the frequencies for network infrastructure.
Once it has finalized the purchase of its AWS-3 licences, Dish is expected by many to rationalize the structure of its spectrum holdings and spin them off in a separate leasing company which would have greater flexibility to pursue carrier deals.
The most likely candidate, according to a new client note from New Street Research, is Verizon, and its analysts expect a deal to be announced by year end.
They were basing their predictions on McAdam’s comments at last week’s event, where he said: “We have had discussions about how we can provide him [Ergen] with megabytes and he could pay for it with spectrum. Those sorts of options are still open to us. But to get the spectrum by buying the entire company isn’t something that we are interested in.”
Those comments showed Verizon, in effect, throwing down the gauntlet to Dish and indicating publicly that it will not pay Dish’s asking price in cash, but would be open to more flexible arrangements. Tim Farrar of TMF Associates expressed this view in a recent blog post, writing: “It seems clear that Verizon would be interested in gaining access to both Dish’s AWS-3 winnings and the adjacent AWS-4 downlink through a leasing deal. However, by advertising its bottom line in public … it seems that Verizon has presented Ergen with a take it or leave it proposition, calculating that Dish has no other options.”
The New Street analysts wrote: “The last point suggests a very specific structure that we have written about before. We are inclined to think that the shift in tone is significant. Verizon management is generally careful about their messaging.”
A leasing deal involving spectrum-for-capacity would be preferable to outright purchase because of Verizon’s current debt load. Verizon could pay for at least some of the spectrum rights with network capacity – enabling Dish to launch mobile broadband services without it having to build its own network.
New Street values Dish’s spectrum at $63bn and its AWS-3 and AWS-4 airwaves alone at $53bn and calculate that Verizon would need to pay about $4bn a year to lease it, in cash or kind – or there could be a sliding scale of fees based on rising usage.
However, Verizon could find itself vulnerable to future Dish decisions to offload spectrum. “This has been the stumbling block to a transaction, in our view,” the research note continued. “One way around this would be a very long term lease with a right of first refusal if the spectrum is ever sold.”
Verizon CFO Fran Shammo said on the operator’s Q2 earnings call in July that Verizon would only lease spectrum in perpetuity, “in order to protect the viability of our network and our planning and our capital allocation … so that you could never be held hostage by anybody. Because once you deploy a spectrum in your network, if somebody turned around 10 years from now and said I think I’m not going to lease that you any more, that would be detrimental to your business and you just can’t let that happen.”
And in the shorter term, there is the issue of the satellite firm’s designated entities having to pay an additional $3.33bn for spectrum they acquired on behalf of Dish in the AWS-3 auction. The FCC recently granted them an extension, until October 1, to pay up, having ruled they were not entitled to the 25% bidding discount usually available to smaller players. No deal could be done until that transaction is completed.
If a deal does transpire, it will help establish the benchmark pricing for other spectrum arrangements which Dish could make (Farrar suggests a 700 MHz E Block lease to AT&T and an H-Block/AWS-3 uplink deal with Sprint). However, the analyst also points out that Dish might find it hard to raise substantial debt for a new leasing company, if that was not receiving most of its fees in cash – which could in turn limit Dish’s ability to acquire further spectrum to bolster its new business. The pay TV provider is expected to participate in the 600 MHz sale.
There are time pressures on Verizon if it does want a leasing deal, which Ergen could use to force an agreement forward. There will be a quiet period, ahead of the 600 MHz incentive auction of broadcast spectrum next year, in which no spectrum negotiations will be allowed. That will probably start at the end of 2015 and last for at least six months, with the auction itself scheduled to start on March 29.
The 600 MHz auction will be the last major spectrum sale in the US for years, but it may not result in the inflated prices seen in the AWS-3 process. This is because Verizon and AT&T, in particular, are turning their network deployment priorities from broad coverage, which both have now achieved using their 700 MHz digital dividend frequencies, to capacity, which requires mid-band or high-band spectrum. Hence the focus on the AWS bands and on higher frequency options like AT&T’s 2.3 GHz WCS assets or Sprint’s huge store of 2.5 GHz airwaves.
So Verizon may be keen to ensure access to a large amount of AWS spectrum before the 600 MHz process, which is less strategic for its network plans, begins. If Verizon and AT&T cannot find enough optimal midrange spectrum from various sources, they may be forced to spend billions of dollars on frequencies which are now sub-optimal for their LTE expansion projects.