The Universal Powerline Association versus Homeplug wars continually interest us, and if home networking was as simple as just putting a plug into the home power supply, that battle would be all over by now, but interference, regulatory and costs issues have, until recently, dampened enthusiasm for using the power grid to support broadband.
This week Spain’s DS2, one of the main the chip companies that is driving the UPA Powerline effort, said that D-Link had chosen its chips as a 200 Mbps Powerline Ethernet Adapter (DHP-300) for high-definition media streaming, music sharing and online multi-player gaming out of any AC wall socket in the home.
Interestingly back in April D-Link was commissioned to supply a Homeplug product for the Chunghwa Telecom in Hong Kong, to carry IPTV around the home. There it used the Intellon HomePlug chips. Along with Chunghwa, Intellon says that France Telecom, Neuf Cegetel, PCCW, Telecom Italia France, and T-Online France are all currently deploying Intellon Homeplug systems for their IPTV services, which is news to us and we’re not exactly sure where that leaves D-Link now hat it’s pushing DS2’s devices.
Fundamentally Homeplug uses the same protocols as Ethernet, while UPA uses the same OFDM protocols as WiMAX and some Wi-Fi for signaling, and both shoot for 200 Mbps. Our understanding is that UPA is about a year ahead and that collisions in the Ethernet based CSMA\CD protocols reduce output substantially and make video over Homeplug less reliable. Both sound more a lot more reliable than Wi-Fi, and yet Ruckus wireless seems to be doing a great trade recently in a Wi-Fi variant for carrying TV around a home.
During October Belgacom signed to use Corinex designed UPA power connections with its IPTV service, based again on the DS2 chip.
DS2 says that it is now the preferred powerline technology at Belgacom, Telefonica, and Telecom Italia, which is also listed by Intellon as a customer. Belgacom said that it chose the DS2 based device after rigorous testing and field trials with technologies which included coaxial cable, so think MoCA.