Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 April 2006

US analyst tries to pump EchoStar by saying AT&T will delay

It’s worth noting that this week a controversial US financial analyst has come out and said that he believes AT&T will slow down the roll-out of Project Lightspeed and the associated U-verse IPTV system because the 25 Mbps it offers simply isn’t fast enough.

Most analysts have criticized Verizon for going straight to the home with fiber in its FiOS rollout and praised AT&T, but Anton Wahlman, senior analyst at Think Equity Partners says that AT&T will have to scale back deployment and improve on is VDSL2 technology.

Is this the same Anton Wahlman that got into big trouble during the tail end of the dotcom boom, and attracted a class action law suit for pumping a stock Interspeed, which his company, then USB, IPO’d, while privately dissing it and telling his friends to get out? Yes it is, but that doesn’t mean that he is automatically wrong, just that he has a track record that says moving a stock price is more important than ‘being right.’

The upshot of his prediction is that AT&T will push its ‘Homezone’ product in conjunction with EchoStar’s Dish in the interim. So we presume this is the stock that he is trying to drive up. (See elsewhere in this issue for the Akimbo deal with Homezone).

While we have nothing against Dish, and perhaps its share price should go up, it is the work it is doing behind the scenes to find a return path and a full triple play that will make or break it. The satellite TV sales of all the RBOCs have fallen off radically, according to their 10Qs, and we see no sense in them reversing this trend, they are winding that activity down in order to drive IPTV activity up.

If Wahlman looked closely at Project Lightspeed, he’d see that all this consists of is taking fiber closer to the home, to within 5,000 feet. This means that it will be substantially less than 5,000 to some homes, and a full 5,000 for others.

VDSL2 will speed up, unless it is artificially blocked, the closer it is to the home, and if his analysis was right, it would be a gradual process of taking the fiber even closer to some homes that would be needed, not the abandoning of the strategy. The strategy has been designed to offer one HD channel plus two concurrent SD channels, and it’s true that a household that has 4 TVs on at once (usually with no-one watching more than one of them) will drain the network if one of them is HD. Wahlman’s contention that cable can offer more bandwidth just shows he doesn’t really understand cable networks.

Wahlman says further that the issue is the lack of takeup, but of course, no-one yet knows the rate of take up, unless he’s done some personal research he’s not mentioned. He reckons that AT&T will blame the decision on anything from a slow upgrade cycle to VDSL2, Microsoft’s unstable software, or the pending BellSouth merger.

Our take is that AT&T wanted to avoid adverse publicity and got its early systems out on time, it will now make sure that they work properly before driving rollouts too rapidly, but 25 Mbps should be more than adequate. Ask a customer of one of the European IPTV systems with just 1.5 Mbps last mile access.