Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 May 2014

US no hire settlement opens lid on anti-competitive practices

At first sight nobody should be too surprised to hear that major Silicon Valley companies including Apple. Google, Intel and Adobe, have been engaged in no-hire agreements with the apparent objective of keeping salaries down for all parties. But the case leading to recent settlement of a class antitrust case from the employees whose salaries were checked as a result of the agreements has exposed a raft of documented internal rules over hiring and recruitment among a wide range of technology companies way beyond the big four, that have actually agreed to pay out. It exposes a range of dubious agreements that are presumably not confined to the high tech sector, but are particularly significant there because of the close correlation between quality of employees and commercial success.

Bill Gates used to argue that Microsoft was in the IQ business and as such success depended on successful recruitment and retention of the brightest people, with competitors including not just high tech rivals like Apple but also the financial sector offering unmatchable salaries and bonuses for top graduates.

Those comments from Gates indicate that the purpose of the no-hire agreements between high tech companies was not just to constrain salaries but also to retain staff, at least by the big companies who tend to lose their brightest people to dynamic startups, offering greater prospects both of personal fulfilment and getting rich quick. It is also of course about reducing leakage of intellectual property.

But as such the no-hire agreements can be seen as directly anti-competitive as well as acting against the interests of employees by retarding the development of emerging players. It is this that particularly contravenes the ethos and founding principles that these Silicon Valley companies are supposed to uphold, but that have long been discarded in the heat of corporate battle as Machiavellian tendencies take over.

This anti-competitive streak was confirmed by some of the documents, including various emails sent around August 2007 in which Apple’s Steve Jobs threatened its smaller rival in the then fledgling smartphone market, Palm, with a patent lawsuit if it did not agree to stop soliciting Apple employees. In one of these emails, Jobs insinuated that “if Palm did not agree to such an agreement, Palm could face lawsuits alleging infringement of Apple’s many patents.” In another email Jobs threateningly alluded to the asymmetry of the situation, meaning that Apple had much deeper pockets, writing: “I’m sure you realize the asymmetry in the financial resources of our respective companies when you say: ‘We will both just end up paying a lot of lawyers a lot of money.'”

This highlights how these deals often described as ‘gentlemen’s agreements’ were not that gentlemanly, especially when one of the parties was smaller than the other.

Even more revealing are some of the specific instructions to recruitment staff revealed by diving deeper into the documents, with Google having a list of ‘sensitive’ companies whose employees it had agreed not to cold call, and required approval for any recruitment at director level. These included IBM and AOL.

Most revealingly, Adobe at the same time had a list of companies described as ‘off limits for talent acquisition’, including Apple, SAP and EMC, with different specific stipulations in each case. In these three cases, the rule was ‘do not pro-actively solicit candidates. However, if a candidate from this company applies to a position, you can pursue.’ But in the case of a Ukrainian partner Syncroquest, there was an absolute ban on all recruitment in either direction, which is almost tantamount to a restriction on employee mobility.

Apart from the embarrassment of the revelations the companies appear for now at least to have escaped relatively lightly from the out of court settlement reached with around 65,000 employees that brought the class action, filed in 2011. The deal seems to exonerate the companies from the more serious claim of collusion to hold down salaries, instead only admitting they had conspired to refrain from soliciting one another’s employees. This might sound like splitting hairs, but active collusion over salary levels would be more serious than merely agreeing not to poach each other’s staff, even if the affect is similar. On that basis, the employees have been awarded $324 million to settle the lawsuit, which works out at an average of $5,000 each.

Had the case gone to court, which was anticipated with a trial scheduled to begin at the end of May, the plaintiffs would have asked the jury to award roughly $3 billion in damages, according to court filings. Under antitrust law, that could have then been tripled to $9 billion, which would have been more like $150,000 each. It looks like the plaintiffs had been advised that the case would not stand up and that it was better to settle out of court for a much smaller sum.

The defense was that such no-hire practices, while leaving a nasty taste in the mouth, are quite common across the commercial world. The settlement will certainly not cause too much financial grief to the players involved. It is most likely that the award payments will at least be apportioned between the companies on a pro rata basis, determined by how many of those 65,000 plaintiffs worked for them and the salary levels involved.