The US Senate Commerce Committee began hearings this week on whether telephone companies can deliver IPTV over the same networks they use for making broadband access available to consumers. The hearings will attempt to determine whether the telcos can offer IPTV without being subject to tens of thousands of franchising regulations by local governments.
The franchising regulations were established to govern the cable TV industry. State governments passed laws that made the cablecos subject to local regulation under a federal law. At that time, the cablecos pay-TV was the only such service available to consumers.
Today, DirecTV and EchoStar offer pay-TV nationwide and are not subject to local regulations. Of course, they don’t dig up the streets either.
AT&T has said it will comply with local regulations but that it will not submit to local franchising requirements. The basis for its claim is that it’s delivering video over broadband. Verizon, although protesting loudly, is applying for local approvals in each locale where it wants to offer pay-TV.
In an ideal world, the cablecos would probably like the telcos to have to go through the tortuous and expensive process of applying for the tens of thousands of local permissions, but they’d probably settle for having the requirement completely abolished.
Senators, such as John Ensign (R-Nevada), chief sponsor of the Broadband Investment and Consumer Choice Act, want to create a national franchise law that would free all pay-TV services from having to obtain municipal permits from a labyrinth of over 30,000 franchising jurisdictions.
“To put the current system in perspective, at a rate of one new franchise per day, it would take a new competitor more than eighty years to reach every municipality in America,” said Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) VP for policy Clyde Wayne Crews. “Unless the system is reformed, the full benefits of competition in video services are unlikely to reach customers any time soon.”
The CEI says that while a complete elimination of government franchising requirements would be ideal, freeing video competitors from numerous regulatory barriers via a national video franchise would also be a significant step toward a truly free market.
Video consumers will end up with more choices at lower prices, with the resulting competition offering them cutting edge video services and technology, according to the CEI. Freeing the video market, including incumbent cable providers, from the current outdated and anti-competitive system will also result in billions of dollars in investments as competitors from various industries seek to reach new customers.
“Nearly a decade has passed since Congress addressed significant telecommunications reform, and in that time technology has grown by leaps and bounds,” said Crews. “It is essential that Congress allow a free and competitive market in which new technologies can flourish.”