Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2018

US skinny bundles on the rise – driven by greedy content owners

The suspicious among you may have sensed enemy action this week as US skinny bundles quietly increased pricing from DirecTV Now to Sony Vue and Dish Network’s Sling TV. This is bound to happen and eventually, many protagonists – i.e. content owners, will try to recoup all losses from their various of content audiences.

But there are problems in that approach. In the US mostly free to air broadcasters used to pay for content, and then consumers paid for that content in two ways, by viewing it alongside adverts and by buying it in pay TV bundles.

The skinny bundle has left many TV channels unwatched. And what should happen is that they should die. Their owners however want to extract money with menaces for them. A while back US pay TV and broadcast TV delivered on average 190 TV channels to each US home, which had an average of 3 to 4 TVs in the home, and where this community supported almost 2,000 different TV channels. All of these numbers are going down.

There will be perhaps one or two skinny bundles per home, fewer than 50 channels to most homes delivered online, less than 2.5 TVs in each home, many replaced by tablets, and a clean-out of the fat in TV circles.

And as those content owners are attracting less money for advertising, they are asking for more from the MSOs for distribution rights. Every skinny bundle owner in the chain is saying, “We are not making money with our skinny bundles, and if my neighbor raises his pricing, then so will I.”

There is something tantamount to content collusion in US markets – cord shaving has freed up enough consumer wealth to spend on these skinny bundles, but the content commitments required by content owners have all been savage, and so have the costs of adding original content. So price creep is bound to enter the equation. Low pricing is all about harvesting more market share – once that process settles down, the game is all about churn reduction and those constant price hikes that cable has become so famous for.

But there is a difference between what is happening now and what happened a decade ago. Netflix has raised prices recently, but only of UHD – essentially it has been static in pricing for a decade. And Amazon Prime does have price hikes, but only once in a blue moon, not every year, and Hulu has a free version and a paid version that has not increased in price for a while. So the idea of going back to the future, and just passing price increase after price increase every year through IP delivered pay TV bundles, rather than cable, just does not cut it. Raise your price – lose subscribers.

Which is why most of the changes are complex. The Sony move this week is a $5 hike, plain and simple, across all four tiers. Vue now starts at $45 a month although you can spend much more. AT&T actually brought out a version of its OTT bundle called Watch TV, which is far cheaper. The AT&T move can be seen as pushing more people at this low end product, rather than a genuine $5 a month price hike.

Only days earlier sling TV added $5 a month, and YouTube did it a month ago. These are more “strategy adjustments” – Sling’s parent Dish Network is constantly in turmoil around content negotiations – it’s in the middle of one right now with Univision which has led to yet another content blackout, but this one will adversely affect Spanish speaking viewers – who may vote with their feet. They each need a fighting fund to create original content.

In none of these situations are existing customers being grandfathered – keeping their old price – in services which live by the sword (can be cancelled at 30 days’ notice) they also die by the sword (suffer mass exodus as pricing changes). In the old days Comcast would hike your bill $5 and you would just put up with it, or spend an hour arguing with someone in their help desk about it. But then you were tied to a two year contract, and the same company supplied your broadband and your phone line. Now in skinny OTT bundles all you can do is cancel. And after these prices rises, most operators will get a whiff of just how aggressively customers will do that. In our some they will cancel and move over to a cheaper, better services – like Watch TV or the CBS offerings.

And it’s not as if advertising offers any hope, We now know the day by which Go90 will shutter from Verizon on July 31, leaving it largely visionless – i.e without much visual content and without an idea of what to do about it. That was supposed to herald in the great AVoD era into the US, but while it is a powerful force in China, it is struggling in the US, with almost no successes.

PlayStation Vue raised its prices to “keep pace with rising business costs and enable us to continue offering a better way to watch the best in live sports, entertainment, and news,” it said.

But as customer numbers rise in this new OTT world, content businesses are no longer free to pass on their shareholder expectations to their partners in price increases, and in turn those bundle owners pass those costs to the consumer.

Soon we share know if this is a single market correction – moving from the customer acquisition phase to customer exploitation phase, or simply because the expected sign-ups are simply not high enough.

Sony Playstation Vue is estimated to only have 670,000 customers, well below the multiple millions that CBS and AT&T have for their offerings and even Sling’s numbers.

If we are right here, and these moves slow down the market enthusiasm for these new offerings, then these protagonists will all be looking for a new strategy the next time their P&L suggests they should push through a price hike. And the smaller of them will be facing extinction.