There’s something going on in advertising that we should all be aware of, it is the leading edge of any radical change in content. We can thank Michael Nathanson of MoffettNathanson for pointing out the latest key element, but we have seen falls in the US Upfront negotiations of both broadcasting and cable and yet everyone talks about TV advertising being up this year. Nathanson has just counted up this quarter’s advertising from the 11 TV oriented companies he follows, and has concluded it is down 0.5% in the third quarter— which he describes as worst quarter since the recession.
Casting any eye over the obvious numbers, CBS is off 8% for the year in advertising down to $5,057 million year to date and this perhaps explains why it is so aggressive and ambitious when it comes to negotiating new retransmission consent deals – and why it is in such a tough negotiation with Dish Networks right now which has led to its channels going dark on Dish.
It talks in its results about rising revenue in licensing and affiliate payments but falls in US advertising.
Fox revenues for the quarter were up 15% on strong affiliate and advertising sales with advertising up 10% over last year, but when you look closely US advertising is off by 5%. It also says that it is having strong retransmission consent negotiations.
The pattern goes on, Disney says all is right with the world, that advertising is up at ESPN, although content costs are up even more, and that media networks are up 5%, but there is less advertising revenue in broadcast, balanced once again by higher affiliate revenues and program sales.
NBC is the exception in broadcast, because of ratings gains, but even there, its cable networks have witnessed a 4.6% decline in advertising, due to a decline in ratings.
At Turner advertising is flat in the US and down 2% globally, and yet it has witnessed a 10% gain in its subscription revenues.
There is something very wrong with this picture. All of these companies are being ruthless about retrans consent, to make up for the US broadcast advertising weakness, but surely if less people are watching your ads, for the most part less people are watching your channels and eventually that will show in affiliate, subscription and content sales.
It has always been this way with US content businesses. If ads are down, you charge more for programming, it is the ultimate double dip revenue model. And right now they are getting to license companies like Sony and Verizon with up-front fees for carrying channels OTT, so it is a buyer’s market in OTT services. But advertising seems to be drifting out of TV, and the rise of programmatic advertising is perhaps demonstrating the benefits of other types of interactive advertising ahead of TV. The more programmatic purchases there are, perhaps the less traditional broadcast gets advertising.
Nathanson counted that broadcaster ad revenue was down 0.3% in this quarter, while cable networks were off even more at 0.6%. Viacom has yet to announce its results, and when they come it may skew things, for better or worse.
After bad upfronts everyone (in advertising) said they would get it back in scatter, but after poor scatter sales there is no-one left to blame. US TV is losing strength in one of its revenue mainstays and its other subscription mainstay could be right behind it.
The next quarter promises further weakness and with a lower upfront volume and lower cost per thousand values in those negotiations, that will put more pressure on scatter, which will weaken further. By Christmas there could be a full scale crash in US big media stock prices.