There is quite a lot of nonsense traveling around the web about the US Patent and Trademark’s Office decision to work with the Open source community over prior art.
The USPTO is basically opening up patent applications to the open source community so that they can yell if they find something that’s already out there and it will work with them on creating intelligent searches of what’s in open source files.
It has been a source of great annoyance and many big software firm’s early product lines, that open source code can be taken, adapted and used to create leading software products. But the plagiarism is rarely noticed and sometimes it also ends up with patents being issued.
In some instances software patents have been awarded for time honored programming techniques that are detailed in the venerable Knuth’s Book of Algorithms, written in the 60s. The SCO suit against Linux could have been halted if only SCO had been told in the first place that it could not take ownership of certain parts of Unix code because it was open source prior art.
In every case a responsible group of open source contributors would have known in advance that there was prior art and that’s really all the suddenly enlightened USPTO is looking at, clever search technology and access to smart people who know an awful lot about what’s already been done in software.
A number of reports we have read this week seem to suggest that because the Open Source community is opposed to software patents, that it will raise spurious, difficult to check opposition to many software patents, wasting the time of patent examiners.
We’d rather have that than some chancer coming along and making $500 million on the back of patents that should never have been issued, and don’t forget the huge waste of US public resources in legal costs involved in sorting out patent issues.
Last year the European Parliament shot down legislation that would award software patents and business model patents in the European Union, in a move designed to stop massive amounts of patent litigation which tends to favor bigger organizations.