No-one in the financial community is taking our comments from last week about Verizon and a Netflix competitor seriously, so we’re going to repeat them with a little bit of spin. News this week has centered on Verizon paying just under $5 billion to buy Netflix. It’s just a rumor and to use it’s a little absurd, created out of mischief and a blatant attempt to breathe some life into the Netflix stock, or at least to hold the hard of thinking from baling out of the stock.
We are not a stock analysis service and we don’t hold shares. Netflix has simply managed to breakthrough with its service, because its prior service of DVD rental was so popular and so close to online video, that an avalanche of subscribers all drifted to Netflix as the idea of online movie viewing finally coalesced.
There were companies with the rights and the technology to do this back in 2006, and that includes Liberty Media and its Starz content. And yet major content businesses have failed where Netflix won ‘ for a while ‘ with a magic price formula that meant for no extra you could have online movies. It was, or appeared to be, free.
We are unhappy saying things like ‘this company will never buy that company,’ mostly because, and this is especially true in the US, all sorts of crazy deals get done, mostly by managements which have a cock-eyed view of this or that market. Verizon is not such a company. It has its feet on the ground.
Taking over Netflix would have to be hostile, because the share price has slumped to about a third of its recent highest price, and the management would fight it tooth and claw. So would any shareholder who was either too slow to get their money out of Netflix, or like us, simply believed it was still the best shot in the US for online movie dominance. To ask them to sell would be to ask them to crystallize their recent losses, and they will fight that.
That would mean that Verizon would have to pay over the odds, and fight a proxy battle to get into a business that could never be a significant proportion of its revenue. It makes no sense. Now come back to what we wrote last week, Verizon is not only prepared to go into business as a partner for cable companies, in order to invade the geographical turf of AT&T, but it is also prepared to return the favor and sell their services on its own turf. That’s a big deal and a major understanding that it could earn twice as much money if its fixed line services were available on a nationwide footprint, as its cellular services are. At the moment it can compete with AT&T in cellular, but in fixed lines it doesn’t have the lines, hence its ability to think the unthinkable, and get into bed with the cable companies, long seen as its worst enemy.
Of course it’s worse enemy is really AT&T, and by working with cable companies that have their best footprint in the AT&T space, it works with cable companies where there is little overlap with its own fixed line services.
The creation of an Over the Top video service would be nice, but not with a Verizon brand. Quite rightly Verizon sees that the ability to carry video to any part of the world is a potential global network opportunity. And it has global assets, focused on Enterprise from its purchase of MCI Communications. Why can’t it repeat the process in video carriage. After all, the Cisco Visual Networking Index shows that carrying video is one of the biggest problems that fixed line and cellular networks have ever faced.
Which is why back in April, after spending $300 million in hard assets, Verizon made a play to carry video content to any device on the planet, lining up best of breed technology suppliers – Technicolor, Motorola, Alcatel-Lucent, Hewlett-Packard – in a video distribution play. That’s not going to do well if it is a branded service. It’s going to offer significant growth revenues if it solves the problems that we talk about every week ‘ the massive problem of all IP networks delivering video without it strangling all other network services.
If you have content rights, for instance if you are Netflix, you could go and get a great global deal from Verizon. In fact if Verizon is going to be seen as buying anyone, shouldn’t it really be Akamai or Limelight Networks or Level 3 Communications? It would make sense buying them, if that could extend the Verizon proposition, not only as a global CDN, but as a complete service enabler, with billing, network tools and device delivery management. That way it is an arms dealer in an arms race ‘ it could supply Netflix, Comcast and UPC and DirecTV with delivery of their OTT content.
Which is why it is in talks with Redbox, the Coinstar owned DVD kiosk business, to create a Netflix rival ‘ not because partnering with Redbox will make it rich, but because this is a service that it can supply, like any other, to multiple partners. And all of them collectively can enrich it. That’s the kind of strategy which works whoever wins the fight to offer OTT video ‘ if its TV Everywhere services like Comcast’s Xfinity, or a rival version from DirecTV, or Netflix or something new. This is a bid to go up against the football fields of hardware that Google and Amazon own, to make money from the cloud, but purely in video.
Verizon is not going to go and buy one of these service companies because then this new video delivery service is dead, because it’s seen as a rival business to new Verizon network customers. The company having built multiple backbone lines across the globe delivering video at between 40Gbps and 100 Gbps, is not going to then put all its eggs in one basket by owning that service. Now it might do a variety of cut price, partner oriented deals to prove that it has the skills to be a major player here, and these will get publicity, but what a company like Verizon does not know, now that it runs its own FiOS TV service, about large scale video delivery, is not worth knowing.
It can work with Hulu and the Broadcast Network owners, it can work with new OTT players, it could work even with content delivery cloud rivals such as Google or Apple, it can then carry video for cellular networks, such as its own, but also MVNOs which emerge. That makes Verizon a sensible, stick to its knitting, kind of carrier play and we think this is really what’s going on here.
Verizon is trying to manage every aspect of the process, from video ingest to workflow, distribution to web retailers, security management and DRM and device formatting, running off fault tolerant mirrored servers in Southern California and Northern Virginia. It might even manage the SEO aspects for the service. Its partnership with the cable companies will also let it extend this reach to 100% of US homes.
We have, on many occasions, talked about the US not having very much competition in telecommunications services, effectively a duopoly ‘ well this move has to be applauded because it takes it to AT&T, and a host of smaller CDN rivals. So sure the company is working with Coinstar, but that doesn’t mean it’s not also working with every other online video supplier in at first the US, and soon the rest of the world.
And this is where rumors such as Verizon looking to buy both Hulu and Netflix has come from ‘ what it really wants is the video carriage business, we’re sure.
And what better way for Verizon to advertise its arrival than by launching a TV and movie product by the middle of next year with Redbox, a service which is slick and which begins to undercut Netflix with low end subscription tiers at $6 a month, leveraging off Redbox kiosks, so you can get either a DVD or an online movie, in the same way that Netflix did.