Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2007

Virgin may get second bite at ITV as OFT agrees to look at Sky bid

Perhaps it wasn’t obvious at the time, but the recent £5 billion ($9 billion) bid by NTL to buy long standing UK free to air independent TV firm ITV, is probably the start of a long series of bid attempts by telecommunications operators at buying content firms.

This week the UK commercial regulator the Office of Fair Trading has launched a formal investigation into the bid which killed the deal, the surprise purchase by BSkyB of a 17.9% stake in ITV.

It’s an interesting conundrum, in that BskyB is so dominant in pay TV in the UK that it would never get permission to buy ITV, while NTL might, so the share chunk was really clearly designed to kill off the NTL deal.

Had the deal gone through, the dominant UK cable operator NTL, which we really must start calling by its new name pretty soon, Virgin Media, wouldn’t have stopped at being a quadruple play, but it would have become the first quintuple play (neither laugh nor sneer) incorporating a major broadcaster as well.

Faultline has to agree with all the naysayers about this type of combination, that we would do well, as consumers, to steer clear of anyone that wants to provide all of our operator needs ‘ fixed and mobile voice, internet access and pay TV services, never mind one that also wants to buy the local free to air broadcaster.

While in the fixed line world of pay TV, the local free to air channels are often mandated as having to be carried by cable and satellite companies, and this, in a way, prevents the two from being fiercely competitive, this is not the case in mobile TV, and the way legislation is going it is unlikely to become so.

That leaves a natural hostility likely to emerge between free to air TV broadcasters and mobile operators, the world over. They both use spectrum, and they are increasingly wanting to own the same spectrum ‘ UHF, and they each want to offer TV services ‘ one digital terrestrial, one mobile TV- that are virtually identical. At some not too distant point in the future it’s fairly obvious that the hugely profitable cellular operator community will not want to feel beholden to a partner that runs free to air TV, and probably funds and runs the local DVB-H franchise.

One way round this is for cellular operators to begin looking at buying local country broadcasters, in order to take control of their spectrum, and own all the revenues that are set to be delivered by mobile TV services, one way or another.

Of course the other way is for cellular operators to use a different technology that doesn’t require the use of existing digital terrestrial antenna and broadcasting facilities, such as DAB or cellular multicasting.

So this decision is not entirely a local spat about UK ownership. It is a wider discussion about media ownership. The negatives for BSkyB to have a share of the UK free to air market leader is that it will almost have a stranglehold on UK TV advertising and content if this is seen as a merger by the back door, combined with its holdings in multiple national newspapers. Sky in turn is owned by News corp. But if Virgin Media gets its hands on the prize, much the same dominance across multiple sectors is also afforded.

But without the support of one or other of the two, the dwindling free to air audiences will leave ITV without a future or much of a plan. It has tried to begin a foray into P2P broadcasting over the internet, and it is one of the de facto choices for inclusion in mobile TV system Movio, run by BT, and sold so far only by Virgin Mobile. Neither move though is enough to turn the fortunes of the UK nor the entire European free to air advertising based TV community. However the arrival of a new CEO in the form of Michael Grade, the son of one of the key entrepreneurs that built ITV, has suggested that better times are on the way for the broadcaster, and that perhaps it doesn’t need rescuing, as such, at all.

Sir Richard Branson, the largest shareholder in Virgin Media called Sky’s intervention ‘a blatant attempt to distort competition’ and called on the authorities to intervene. And the fact that the OFT is investigating, will initially gratify him, but that really depends on the outcome.

If the OFT finds that the Sky position in illegal, it will almost certainly force Sky to sell all or part of its stake, and while Branson might be the likely acquirer, it may still be open for the OFT to investigate his bid.

But the wider picture is likely to see this position repeated all over Europe and indeed the world, as cellular operators seeks partnerships or control of fixed operators and then seek control over the content that is broadcast across both technologies.