Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

Virgin Mobile and NTL; an odd couple to chase quadruple play

The deal this week struck by NTL and Virgin Mobile just shows how the triple and indeed the quadruple play world can change with just the signing of a single major contract. It has to be emphasized that no contract has been signed, but it is likely that this deal will go ahead and won’t be snuffed out by either shareholders or any regulatory body.

Essentially Richard Branson, the celebrated entrepreneur that drives Virgin, has traded his 72% holding in the MVNO Virgin Mobile in return for merging it with the combined NTL and Telewest group, leaving him with a 14% shareholding of the combined group.

The offer is worth £3.23 ($5.56) a share to Virgin shareholders, valuing Virgin Mobile at around $1.4 billion and making Branson a billionaire yet again. If the deal comes off, Branson will become the single largest shareholder in the new group and it will almost certainly operate with the brand of Virgin, but retain its current management.

Branson is one of the UK’s biggest music billionaires, who has also moved his empire into areas as diverse as multimedia and transatlantic flights.

Press speculation in UK daily newspapers forced Virgin and NTL to reveal their hands in a statement this week, confirming that discussions have been ongoing for 9 months.

This deal does in the UK what the US cable companies joint agreement with Sprint did, opening up the battle lines for a full quadruple play and beyond, including mobile voice, mobile music and data and mobile TV, and fixed voice services combined with broadband internet access and cable TV/IPTV video services. Sprint and a collection of US cable operators announced a deal in November to take cable TV directly onto a mobile phone.

Standing opposite this new Virgin group will be British Telecom, also planning services across each of those dimensions and the News Corp owned BSkyB, already delivering broadband film services alongside its satellite TV play. BSkyB has also recently bought Easynet, a UK broadband supplier that unbundles lines at local BT exchanges. Sky just did its first mobile deal last month to offer some of its programming on Vodafone handsets.

Virgin is one of the strongest entertainment brands in the world and Branson can leverage years of dealings with the record labels and the part of the group that will remain outside this merger has just launched a new online music store based on the Musicnet offering.

There is room here for lots more collaboration and transformation using the Virgin brand and contacts, and it looks finally like Branson is putting his weight behind digital media in a big way. How long will it be before the same Musicnet offering finds its way onto the mobile service as a full download, or until it appears as an extra ARPU option to NTL cable TV customers.

In June, Virgin Mobile set up a mobile TV trial with British Telecom Wholesale using DAB Enhanced Packet Mode, a kind of internet packet based version of Digital Audio Broadcasting that can use existing radio transmitters to send video files.

This service would be ideal to introduce something like 2 TV channels and lots and lots of music videos, sent as clips, to Virgin mobile phones. The service is being trialed under the name BT Livetime and delivers Sky Sports News, Sky News, a new music channel Blaze and 50 digital radio channels.

And if that’s not enough of a link to NTL cable content, then the fact that NTL Broadcasting, sold off and renamed Arquiva, and currently trialing DVB-H and DAB services, may also help. A partnership with NTL’s old broadcasting arm for the transmitter network may see the combined company launch full scale cable TV on mobiles phones using DVB-H. Of course that would require the acquisition of some spectrum which could come available in 2006 as UK airwaves are re-organized or much later in the 2008 to 2012 time frame as analog TV spectrum is handed back.

One of the problems these two companies must see immediately is that any quadruple play that either of them sets up can only work in the UK, and that would leave the great bulk of Virgin’s US customer base either with a mobile-only offering. It could be that Virgin Mobile in the US comes up for sale, to drive funds back to the rest of the group, or it can stand alone. NTL’s content licenses would have to be amended to take in US rights, and that’s unlikely.

About the only danger to the deal as it has been laid out by Virgin and NTL is if the NTL share price bombs and the Virgin price rises too far.
In the deal at present Virgin Mobile shareholders get 0.09298 shares of NTL or a cash alternative of £3.23 per share.

Virgin Mobile is a Mobile Virtual Network Operator on the T-Mobile network and T-Mobile has said it will support the deal.

In the past NTL has used the Virgin name in the broadband area and has been in discussions with Virgin to extend that license to cover television and fixed line and mobile telephony.

Both companies emphasize that their discussions are still at an early stage and a prospectus will be issued later through an SEC filing.

The combined NTL and Telewest businesses would have 3.3 million cable TV customers and 2.5 million broadband Internet customers, and 4.3 million fixed phone customers while Virgin has 5 million mobile customers. But 3 million of those customers are in the US, with some more in Australia.

Another challenge that a merged group will have to deal with is the historical service problems that have been associated with NTL, which have become so bad that it has a fanzine site named NTHell that highlights its service issues.