When Vodafone bought Kabel Deutschland right on the doorstep of its great rival Deutsche Telekom, it probably sparked something of a renewal of the war between them, so it was only a matter of time before Vodafone began to put its nose into parts of the European market where Deutsche Telecom has been developing. And this week it has triggered what may turn out to be a bidding war in Greece for the leading pay TV player.
Greece, along with Romania, Slovakia, Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic, Croatia, Austria, Netherlands and Bulgaria are all territories where Deutsche Telekom has been active. The end game for Deutsche is to own all of the incumbent telcos in these regions, with the possible exceptions of KPN in the Netherlands and Telekom Austria, although long term those are both potential targets.
So it was no surprise this week that Deutsche’s operation in the region, called Hellenic Telecommunications Organization, but universally referred to as OTE, has tried to bypass Vodafone, already a shareholder of the dominant Nova branded pay TV and broadband operation in Greece, and try to buy it from under its nose.
The Nova brand is now owned by Forthnet, having acquired it from Multichoice a few years back and using the brand to spread over its native ADSL broadband service. Today it successfully sells a triple play.
OTE has only bid for the Nova pay TV operations which run from a digital satellite, and which have grown to take in 452,340 Greek homes, out of a total of over 3.7 million, for pay TV, using DTH. Forthnet would retain its 632,000 plus broadband homes. This pay TV operation brings in a lowly amount per home at just €162 million of its €382 million revenues. Its revenues have fallen since last year down 6.3% from €408 million. The service comes complete with rights to the local Greek premiership soccer league.
So far OTE has been building up its pay TV operation and has 278,000 Greek homes subscribing. These two operations make up all of Greek pay TV which has come through the problematic Greek Eurozone problems, and so has fallen in revenue terms somewhat over the past few years. However both companies have increased customer numbers and have between them some 730,000 Greek homes captive out of 3.7 million, one of the lowest pay TV penetrations in all of Europe (just under 20%).
But OTE has glimpsed some success in neighboring Romania, where the same tactic of buying the incumbent, and investing in infrastructure over a prolonged period has brought it 1.37 million customers through Romtelecom.
It’s tough to say whether or not the local regulator or the European Commission would intervene because this would create a 100% market share in pay TV in Greece, in one company, but at only 20% penetration, there may be no grounds to prevent such a deal.
The OTE’s offer is pitched at something under €300 million, but it has not yet been accepted by Forthnet. There have been a variety of quotes suggesting that the price is right, and it is above the current level of the Forthnet share price.
Other potential investors include Wind in Greece which owns shares and which has made an offer in the past for the other half of the business, its broadband. Other previous investors have paid higher prices for a share of Forthnet, for instance Emirates International Telecommunications, which paid €250 million to build up a 44% stake in Forthnet.
Vodafone has recently tried to buy control of the company by the back door, buying 14.58 million Forthnet shares from Wind, and adding it to its existing 6.5% holding, to go to 19.75%.
If anyone breaks up the asset, it will lose its ability to sign triple play customers and grow more slowly. We think that in a bidding war Vodafone has the weight to outbid Deutsche, but it is likely that Wind, Emirates and Vodafone really only have to hold their shares and vote accordingly and OTE is unlikely to win out.