Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

VoIP Services Should Pay Telcos

Internet service providers like BellSouth should be able to charge Web sites to deliver their content faster than others and to charge VoIP telephone services like Skype and Vonage for using its networks, according to William Smith, BellSouth CTO, according to the Washington Post. BellSouth’s threats follow similar ones from AT&T (nee SBC) chairman Ed Whitacre’s two weeks ago.

Smith said that charging for faster Internet delivery speed is the same as an airline charging for first class and coach tickets or a shipping company charging different rates for next-day and five-day delivery.

Consumer advocates were incensed and immediately reacted. “If we want to ruin the Internet, we’ll turn it into a cable TV system that carries programming from only those who pay for transmission,” Gigi Sohn, president of Public Knowledge, a digital rights advocacy group, told the Post.

“This threat is as serious as a heart attack, and needs to be taken as such by all those who care about the Internet,” added Dana Blankenhorn at Corante.com, a network of technology Web logs. “If you have an AT&T or BellSouth DSL line, you need to seek out an alternative and send those companies a letter saying you will switch unless they back off. A marketplace response to a marketplace threat is the correct alternative here.”

What was not seen is the fear, uncertainty and doubt Smith and Whitacre’s remarks caused at Internet-dependent giants such as Yahoo, Google, AOL, eBay, Microsoft and the like. Without those and similar companies, there’d be no demand for broadband. Oh, yeah, there was that P2P file-sharing surge that first created the need for broadband.

Google, which has already stuck one toe in the wireless broadband market, and the other Internet behemoths, do not want to bet their highly profitable futures on the whims of the telcos. The telcos and cablecos shouldn’t be surprised to find that high-level meetings are taking place at the Internet-dependent companies outlining their broadband alternatives.
There’s no doubt that News Corp, with its broadbandless DirecTV operation and EchoStar with its Dish service, would be interested in partnering up with potential new broadband suppliers.

Smith and Whitacre’s remarks bring to mind all the warnings about an unregulated duopoly being more dangerous to consumers than a regulated monopoly

Reversing the threat, what would happen if Yahoo, Microsoft, AOL, Google, eBay and others were to suddenly block their Web sites from being used by AT&T and BellSouth broadband customers?