Warner Brothers the studio arm of Time Warner, told visitors to the National Association of Broadcasters convention last week that it will release High Definition DVDs later this year using Microsoft Windows Media Video Codec 9 protocols.
The announcement calls it VC 1, but that’s a bit of a misnomer given that there is no licensing scheme for VC 1 and the technology behind it is in dispute. VC 1 is the name given to the standard version of VC 9 that Microsoft is hoping will become an SMPTE standard. Warner Brothers could be letting itself in for retrospective royalties without such a license, and that’s likely to be a painful lesson.
The VC 1 codec is a draft standard offered by the Society of Motion Pictures and Television Engineers, but 11 un-named companies have emerged to claim essential patents in the standard as the MPEG LA has tried to write a license for the technology.
However the HD DVD standard, set by the DVD Forum, has named VC 1 as one of the mandatory codecs to offer, but given that this technology has no central licensing scheme yet and that these 11 companies are not yet named, it makes licensing it rather dangerous.
Faultline has guessed that the 11 companies are likely to be the 11 companies that have technology in both the MPEG2 and MPEG 4 Level 10 AVC codec standards, and this includes many companies that have a lot to lose if the HD DVD standard emerges unscathed, including Sony, Philips, Matsushita, Samsung, Thomson and others.
Given that they are no players (and no licenses to be had for players) available for this format yet, the Warner Brothers announcement looks like it is verbal window dressing for its support of all things Microsoft.
It could go ahead and license the VC 9 codec from Microsoft, but legal action is understood to be under consideration for this too, and the existence of content using the standard might trigger those legal moves.
Warner Home Video says it will release titles in the fourth quarter of 2005 but by then it is likely, given the current talks going ahead (see separate story) that the two formats Blu-ray and HD DVD, will be unified or in the event the talks fail, all legal actions out in the open. Somehow Faultline cannot see the DVD formats being unified using a proprietary codec which has technology that is in dispute, so we shall see.
Almost every other content company has tried to avoid this conflict by electing to use the H.264 codec, a standard which has been around a while and which is every bit as good (perhaps better), and rather similar to the VC 1 codec (based on the same patents).
Warner Brothers claims to have over 6,500 feature films, 40,000 TV episodes and 14,000 animated titles to put onto the format. Expensive mistake if they are all impounded through an injunction.