On the one hand a US judge this week has ruled that Universal Music and EMI misled the US Justice Department when it was investigating price collusion in the music industry, and on the other there are also reports that the four big record companies are abandoning their efforts to force Apple to tow the line and change iTunes into a variable price structure.
Instead the companies, Sony BMG, EMI, Universal Music and Warner Music Group, are said to be considering removing their catalogue from the iTunes service when their current deal expires. What do you call it when a cartel colludes to force a change in a monopoly?
Can you imagine the outcry and the accompanying piracy if they were to collude to do such a thing? And why would they spurn all of that revenue? It’s another case of record companies moaning to their friends in the press and then finding that when they get around to thinking it through their hands are tied, in this case by the company that single-handedly saved them from themselves. Let’s hope they are not that hell bent on ruining their businesses yet again.
In the meantime, Burst.com said this week that it has filed counterclaims accusing Apple Computer of infringing four its US patents. In the counterclaims, filed in Federal District Court in San Francisco on Monday, April 17th, Burst alleges that Apple’s iTunes Music Store, iTunes software, the iPod devices, and Apple’s QuickTime Streaming products infringe Burst’s US Patents.
Apple filed suite against Burst last April aiming to get Burst’s Patents declared invalid or a declaration by the court that Apple does not infringe them. Apple decided not to license the Burst patents because it was in a legal action against Microsoft at the time, defending them, which it subsequently won.
Burst pioneered what it calls faster than real time video and audio delivery, which is what all the fuss is about.